Modules 1-3 Flashcards
How do you prove liability if the injury is unintentional?
Negligence
What does intent mean?
- that the defendant desires the result
- or that the defendant knows to a substantial certainty that the result will occur
How do you prove that the defendant desired the consequences of her acts?
Circumstantial evidence
What is the standard for proving intent in the intentional torts?
Subjective
What is recklessness?
When a defendant takes a substantial or unreasonable risk that the elements of the tort will occur
Ie) driving too fast and risking a collision
What is transferred intent?
- Applied to five intentional torts (battery, assault, FI, trespass to chattel, trespass to land)
- if the defendant intends any of these torts but her conduct result in any of the other torts the defendant is liable for the tort even though she didn’t intend it
What is an example of transferred intent?
If Sally intends to assault George but accidentally makes physical contact with Kim, Sally is liable for battery. This is because the intent to commit one tort satisfies the intent element of another tort. The intent to commit a tort against one victim is transferred to any other victim
What is the mistake doctrine?
If a defendant intends to do the acts which would constitute a tort, it is no defense that defendant mistakes, even reasonably, the identity of the property or person he ask upon, or believes incorrectly there is a privilege
Ie) if you shoot a dog and think it is a wolf you’re liable
Can insanity or infancy be a defense to an intentional tort?
No, but if a person is very impaired or very young they may not possess the requisite intent for the crime
Ie) if a one-year-old pulls the trigger begun she probably intended to pull the trigger but didn’t intend for a battery and therefore is reliable
- I tired/insane person doesn’t need to appreciate the significance or wrongness of their act to be liable (Garrett V daily)
What is battery?
When the defendant’s acts intentionally cause harmful or offensive contact with another’s person or something closely connected to the plaintiff’s body
What are the elements of battery?
1) intent
2) harmful or offensive contact
3) causation
What does intent to refer to in a battery?
Just requires intent, not an intent to harm. Means intended to cause either harmful or offensive contact.
- The least touching of another in anger is battery
- even if minimal or no physical harm was actually intended it is still a battery
Ie) schoolboy kicking his classmate’s shin
- The brisk of unforeseen harm arising from the battery is borne by the defendant
What does harmful or offensive contact include in a battery?
Can be physical, psychological, trivial physical contact, offensive contact. Ie) grabbing the plate out of a person’s hand
- meant to protect injurious physical intrusions and personal autonomy
- victim doesn’t have to be conscious of either the contact or it’s harmful/offensive nature at the time of the intrusion
Ie) you kiss someone while they’re sleeping, and are liable for battery
- offensive according to a reasonable person
What does causation refer to with regard to battery?
The defendant’s voluntary action must be the direct or indirect legal cause of the harmful or offensive contact. Defendant doesn’t have to actually make physical contact
Can set of force in motion ie) can hit someone with a rock, snack something from their hand, blow smoke in their face, putting poison in a drink, knocking glasses off your face,
What are the two types of damages in battery?
1: nominal damages - when the plaintiff suffers only trivial harm or offense, they are still entitled to collect some money. The matter how trivial the incident, a batteries actionable, even if damages are only one dollar
2: economic damages
Are parents liable for their kids torts?
Not unless you can prove that the child’s tort was committed willfully are wantonly
What are the two types of intent?
1) single intent: battery requires a plaintiff to prove merely that the defendant intended to touch -> majority
2) dual intent: must prove that the defendant intended to touch AND intended that the touching be harmful or offensive -> minority
What is the extended liability principle?
The defendant who commits an intentional tort is liable for all damages caused, not merely those intended or foreseeable
What does prima facie mean?
The elements of the plaintiff has to prove to establish his claim by a preponderance of the evidence (must prove each element is more likely than not)
What does a preponderance of the evidence mean?
More than 50%. Must prove each element is more likely than not
How many elements does every intentional tort have?
Five
What are the five elements of every intentional tort?
1) voluntary act
2) intent
3) causation
4) Harm or injury
5) without privilege
What is a voluntary act?
An act of the defendant that is conscious, willed, or purely reflexive ie) epileptic seizure doesn’t count as a voluntary act so there would be no basis for tort liability
What is the difference between subjective and objective intent?
Subjective: requires that you look into the mind of the defendant and ask, “what is he thinking?”
Objective: looks at conduct and evaluates defendants conduct