Module 5 Flashcards
What is the judgement in the Fourie case?
In the Fourie case, the Constitutional court declared that the restriction on opposite sex couples to marry was unconstitutional and instructed parliament to change the law. Parliament passed the Civil Union Act, which allows both opposite and same-sex couples to marry.
What is the difference between the Marriage Act and Civil Union Act?
Marriage according to the Civil Union Act mirrors the requirements and consequences of marriage under the Marriage Act, except that it can also be concluded between two people of the same sex it is monogamous.
What is the Civil marriage definition?
A Civil marriage is defined as the legally recognised voluntary union for life of two people with the exclusion of all others.
What are the Acts for same-sex marriages and the Act for opposite sex marriages?
Civil marriages are same sex marriages according to the Marriage Act 25 of 1961 and opposite sex marriages according to the Civil Union Act of 2006
What are the requirements for a civil marriage?
Requirements for civil marriages:
- Capacity to marriage
- Consensus/Consent to marry
- Formalities complied with to marry
- Sex of the spouses
What is the absolute capacity to marry?
The absolute capacity to marry is the ability to marry any other person. The absolute capacity can be hindered by a marriage to someone else, mental illness, intoxication, age or factors which impede their ability to understand or control their behavior.
What is the absolute ability to marry hindered by?
The ability to marry is hindered by:
- Mental illness- people who are mentally ill have no capacity to perform juristic acts of any kind as they are unable to understand the legal consequences and their actions could be motivated by delusions caused by the illness. Any marriage that’s done will be void.
- Age- In the Civil Act they have to be 18 years or older to get married. In the Marriage Act, they must be over the age of puberty (girls over 12 and boys 14) and with the permission of the Minister of Home Affairs for boys under 18 and girls under 15.
- Intoxication- People that are severely toxicated that are unable to understand the legal nature have no capacity to marry. However the onus is on them to prove their incapacity
- Nature of marriage- Civil Marriages are monogamous and so you can’t get married if you are already married to somebody else
- Other factors- The declaration of a prodigal doesn’t affect the ability to marry.
Can you marry more than one spouse in civil marriage in customary marriage?
In civil marriages if there is more than one marriage in a customary marriage these subsequent marriages would be void. Similarly, a spouse in an existing customary marriage is not allowed to conclude a civil marriage in terms of the Marriage Act or the Civil Union Act to someone else such a subsequent civil marriage will be void
What is the relative capacity to marry?
The relative capacity to marry is the ability to marry a particular person in a prohibited degree of relationships. In South Africa the only legal pediment stopping people with the capacity to marry is if they are related to each other within the prohibited degrees of relationship.
What are the different blood relatives in law?
In law there is a distinguisher between people who are related by blood relations (relationships of consanguinity) and relationships created by marriage (relationship of affinity). The law also distinguishes between direct lines of descent and people who are collaterals.
Who are people related in direct lines?
People are related in a direct line if they are descendants or ancestors of each other. People are collateral if they have a common ancestor but are not related in a direct line, such as siblings, aunts, uncles and cousins.
How do you calculate the degrees of relationship?
The degree of relationship between collaterals is calculated by counting the number of generational steps between one of the collaterals and the common ancestors, then adding them up. The total number of steps is the degree of relationship
What are the relative capacities of relationships that are prohibited
The relative capacity prohibited marriages are:
- No marriages in the direct line (ascendants and descendants), this even if you’re related to them by blood or marriage. These rules apply to people involved in half-blood people
- No marriages to relations if one person is related in the first degree to the common ancestors. The closest degree of relationship is two degrees, which is siblings and is a direct line.
- You may not marry your spouse’s direct line. This prohibition continues after the marriage has ended, whether through divorce or death.
- Adopted children may not marry their blood relatives or their adoptive parents but are free to marry anyone else in their adoptive family
Can people marry collateral blood partners?
People may marry their collateral blood, provided that there are four or more degrees of relationship between them. There are no prohibitions on marrying the collaterals of a former spouse.
What is the voluntary capacity in civil marriages?
A civil marriage is a voluntary union of two people. People can only marry each other if they give voluntary consent to the marriage. The voluntary consent must also be informed consent and must understand the material aspects of the marriage and give consent to them.
When is consent invalid?
- They are unable to give consent because they lack capacity to do so
- There was duress or intimidation such as in the Smith v Smith case. - The intimidation can take the form of physical violence.
- There was a mistake about the identity of the person they were marrying (error in persona). Since both parties have to be present at a wedding, this is difficult to happen in practice.
- There was a mistake about the nature of the transaction that is a marriage (error in negotio). This would occur if one or both spouses did not realise that they were concluding the marriage.
- Misrepresentations about other material aspects can affect the validity of the marriage. A marriage may be voidable if one of the spouses has misrepresented certain important facts that go to the heart of the marriage relationship.
When can a coerced party have their marriage annulled?
- The fear was sufficiently serious to invalidate consent
- The fear was reasonable
- The fear arose from circumstances for which this part was not responsible
What is the Smith v Smith case and what happened?
In the Smith v Smith case the court examined what was meant by sufficient so serious or reasonable fear in granting an annulment. Before the wedding, Ms Smith fell in love with another man. Her parents and fiancé did not react well. They insisted she get married and assaulted and threatened her. The judge found that the fear must be serious enough and the court must have regarded the circumstance. It was found that Mrs Smith’s fear was reasonable and therefore the marriage was voidable.
Can misrepresentation due to material facts be grounds for annulment?
Mistakes regarding the qualities of the spouse are not usually regarded as material and thus not grounds for an annulment. Thus a mistake about the race, nationality, religion, previous material status, age, name or prior sexual experience does not render the marriage liable to annulment.
Are sham marriages valid?
Sham marriages that arent for love are valid marriages. These are all valid even if the motives were improper as seen in Marten v Marten.
What is the Marten case and what happened?
In the Marten case Mr Holden fell in love with a women and wanted her to move to South Africa. Mr Holden was unable to marry as he was already married and he asked Mr Martens his friend to marry her woman. It was held that even though the motivations behind the marriage are unacceptable and constituted abuse of the legal system, it was their intention to get married. Therefore, the marriage was valid and the only available form of termination was a divorce.
What are some formal requirements in the marriage Act?
A marriage must be undertaken in a public and formal way. It is a requirement for a valid marriage are found in the Marriage Act with the Civil Act have similar requirements. Failure to adhere to some of the formalities may render the marriage void. The reason for these requirements is to make marriage a public affair and to ensure that the marriage doesn’t happen secretly.
What is a valid marriage officer?
A civil marriage must be conducted by a marriage officer in order to be valid. People are marriage officers ex officio such as all magistrates and all special justices of the peace and
Anybody the Minister of Home Affairs can designate other employees in the public service of diplomatic or consular services to be marriage officers. Ministers of religion and other officials in religious organisations may also become marriage officers.
Can someone object to a marriage?
Civil unions allow legally valid objections to the dealing with the capacity for them to get married. Any person who wishes to object to proposed marriage must lodge the objection with the marriage officer who will have to investigate the matter. If they believe that there is no lawful impediment to the proposed marriage, then they can proceed with the marriage.
Can a marriage officers object to performing marriages?
In the Marriage Act, there are provisions to allow marriage officers to object to conducting the marriage. In the Civil Union Act, civil servants are not allowed to object to perform a marriage due to their beliefs
What formula does a valid marriage have to follow?
For a valid marriage, it has to follow the marriage formula, have at least two witnesses, and a registration of the marriage. If the format of the wedding ceremony and the vows exchanged have been approved by the Minister. The crucial part of the marriage vows is that the couple must publicly agree to be married to each other. The wording of the formula also makes it clearer that both parties answer if they wish to get married and reply affirmatively with an I do.
What are the requirements of witness for valid marriage?
A civil marriage will only be valid if there are at least two competent witnesses present at the solemisation of the marriage as it prevents clandestine marriages.
What does Ex parte Dow case state?
The Acts do have a specific the time and place for marriage however this does not affect the validity of the marriage as seen in the Ex parte Dow case were Dow stated the wedding was invalid due to it being outside and the court found that the purpose was not defeated by marrying in the garden or house but to prevent clandestine marriages.
What are the requirements to register a marriage?
Civil marriages must be registered in the manner prescribed in the Marriage Act or the Civil Union Act. The essential elements of registration are that the marriage officer, the parties to the marriage and two competent witnesses sign the marriage register or other prescribed documents that are then sent to the public official responsible for the population register. An unregistered marriage can still be valid if it can be proven that all other formalities were followed and a marriage did take place.
What is Willies principle about void marriages?
Wille’s Principles states that a marriage which is null and void ab initio is not a marriage at all, in principle none of the legal consequences of marriage attach to it
What happens if all the requirements of a marriage are not fulfilled or are?
Valid marriages are when all the requirements have been fulfilled and therefore all personal and financial consequences of a valid marriage follow from the date of the marriage. If all the requirements have not been fulfilled a marriage can either be void and voidable. If it is a void marriage it may be a putative marriage with certain requirements
What is a void marriage?
A void marriage has never come into existence in the eyes if the law is as if the parties had never entered into a marriage. Each of the parties retains their legal status as an unmarried person.
What makes a void marriage void?
A void marriage is always void regardless of whether or not the court makes a declaration but for the sake of legal certainty an application for declaration of nullity is usually made to a court. The court merely confirms the existing state of affairs by making a declaratory order.
Can a void marriage be made valid?
The court cannot declare a void marriage valid, however it can be made valid subject to certain statutory qualifications. The marriage cannot be made valid except if it is a putative marriage