Modernity In Class-Test Flashcards
Who is JS Mill
- “the most influential English-speaking philosopher of the nineteenth century”.
- All About Negative Freedom *freedom from
- ## An atheist
What does JS Mill look for
- looks for freedom
- Always thought the humans and society can be better version of themselves
- Democracy does not solve the issue of despotism
- Individuals must be able to act upon their intentions without causing harm
What did JS Mill argue
- against the idea that in a democracy, no needs to worry about than abuse of power.
- argues that that individual difference, and weirdness should be celebrated and protected wherever possible.
What is JS Mill’s Liberalism
- No one but the individual can determine what the good life is
- Freedom from outside influence (freedom is the absence of coercion)
- Tension between liberalism and democracy
- so long as no harm is done to another, freedom must be respected
- Happiness is the sole basis of morality
- encourage individuality to become better versions of your self
What is the History of Liberty (JS Mills)
- started as a protection against the tyranny
- was the attainment of certain immunities in order to limit the threat either through political liberties of rights or through constitutional checks
- At this early stage, love of authority or fear of the lack of authority meant liberty was caged
What is Representation and Majority (JS Mills)
- Representative government - No longer a clear division b/w rulers and ruled
- Who is represented? - Exercisers of power are not always the same as those over whom it is exercised (class) But also pluralism
what is Tyranny of the Majority (JS Mills)
- There must be protection against prevailing public opinion and convention not just authority
- The Majority has power in a democracy
- Protect the oddities from the conforming masses (both win)
What is Finding the Limits (JS Mills)
- If you have the capacity to stop harm, and don’t do it, you have violated the harm principle
-the minority performs and/or appears as a majority due to the lack of liberty/individuality - Those who understand democracy want to support you, those who question it want to criminalize you
What is the Harm Principle (JS Mill)
- everyone should get along with their life as long as they don’t commit harm
- Anyone who sees harm, you own it to yourself to do something about it
- Individual requires to act not acting to cause harm
- Individuals must not make him/herself a nuisance to others (without justifiable cause)
- Despotism and illiberal actions are fine if dealing with savages if the end is an improvement for those “barbarians”
what are the 3 Untouchable liberties that the Harm Principle can’t not compel
- Inward Consciousness
- Thoughts, feelings, opinions, Freedom of speech (for all) - Pursuit of happiness
- As long as our acts don’t harm others leave us alone - Freedom to gather together and unite
“No society in which these liberties are not, on the whole, respected, is free, whatever may be its form of government.”
what is Individuality (JS Mill)
- societies normally want conformity over individuality= means Stability
- Pursuing our own good in our own way, so long as we do not attempt to deprive others of theirs, (THIS IS INDIVIDUALITY)
- Conformity is pushed by customs and tradition
Why is conversation important (JS Mill)
- Fallibalism (incomplete knowledge): YOU MIGHT BE WRONG!
- Empiricism (senses): NO TRUTH MEANS WE MUST EXPERIENCE TRUTHS AND TEST THEM THOUGH OUR SENSE
- Progress (testing)
BE REASONABLE AND DEMAND THE IMPOSSIBLE - deny the right to speech = deny the right to hear that speech
- Individual freedom is not a divine right so It must be practiced to be realized*
What is the loss of living power (JS Mills)
- If a true opinion is not debated, the meaning of the opinion may be lost
- Christianity has this problem as people’s beliefs are not reflected in their conduct
- Mill accepts that uncontested opinions will appear but this doesn’t mean that is good.
What is Conflicting Doctrines (JS Mill)
- doctrines rarely is one entirely right and the other entirely wrong
- Truth is usually somewhere in between
- Law shouldn’t restrict discussion and public opinion should consider the merits of both sides equally
What are Some of Toussaint L’Ouverture’s Achievements
- Haiti’s - 1st successful revolt in the modern world led to the liberation of people of colour and slaves
- Haiti - 1st independent country in Latin America
- Haiti - 1st post-colonial independent black-led nation in the world
- Haiti- only nation independence was gained by a successful slave rebellion
what was Aristide guiding question
- Did L’ouverture liberate himself from Physical and Mental slavery?
- Does Toussaint’s legacy offer a line of liberation that can be implemented today
- Would fulfilling Toussaint’s social and economic* legacy allow us to eradicate poverty, the modern version of slavery, and move towards real freedom?
Did L’Ouverture Liberate himself from Physical and Mental slavery?
- He cared for the protection of his former masters
- YET always consistent with his basic principles, understood that ends do justify means (Consequentialist and Rational)
- Was not a mental slave
- Minority control majority with the help of mental slaves who internalize the imposed identity (KEY ISSUE!)
- You deal with me and engage with me as an equal, no higher no lower
What are some facts FROM Adam
- Conquest came with the dispossession of land and seizure of natural resources
- Followed by the creation of the Manichean system, whereby the Indians were confined on reserves and white European settlers on the newly sized land
- How does this fit “Enlightened ideals?”- spirituality, industrialization, individualism, private property, the scientific revolution
What does it mean Enlightenment for some (Adam)
- Canadian government was to ensure the gifts of the enlightenment were to never shared with indigenous communities
What was Freedom from /Freedom (Adam)
- The tension that has been looked at throughout the term
- Freedom/equality
- locals were seen as a nuisance (setters wanted to be free from the nuisance)
- Dispossession and seizure of land were rationalized into the acts of the settlers
What is the Indian Act (Adam)
- remove Aboriginals from land needed to build the railway across Canada (industrialization)
- racist police force (Royal Mounted Police RMP) was created in order to ensure compliance which included not being allowed to leave the reserve without written permission
What is Prison-Like Culture (Adam)
- “Silencing voices before they are ever heard”
- Obedience to colonial authority was part of the social conscience
- colonialism had rendered the tribes submissive and harmless (childlike)
- incapable of self-reliance due to theft of land and put on reserves (also something required for enlightenment)