Mod 23 Professional And Legal Responsibilities Handout + Highlighted Text Flashcards
4 elements of negligence
1 duty of care
2 breach
3 damages
4 casuality
5 kinds of liability to clients:
Accountants are liable for…
1 contract breaches
2 negligence
3 fraud
4 disclosing confidential client info without client permission
5 confidentiality of client in working papers accountant retains
Element of negligence:
Duty of care
The accountant owed a duty of care to party harmed
Element of negligence:
Breach
Accountant breached by failing to use due care
Accountant breached by failing to use due care, 2 instances (including what usually means)
1 failed to act like a reasonably prudent accountant
2 usually means failed to follow GAAS or GAAP unless following
GAAS or GAAP would make the report misleading
Element of negligence:
Damages
Some type of harm was suffered
Element of negligence:
Casuality
Damages were caused by the accountant’s breach
Liable for Fraud includes either…
Actual or constructive
Actual fraud must know five elements under what neumonic?
MS RID
What does Actual Fraud MS RID stand for?
Material misrepresentation Scienter Reasonable Reliance Intent to rely Damages
Actual fraud:
Must have M…
Material misrepresentation of fact
Actual fraud:
Must have S…
Scienter
Scienter
Intent to deceive (misrepresentation was made intentionally or
Knowingly)
Actual fraud:
Must have R…
Reasonable reliance
Actual fraud:
Must have I…
Intent to rely
Actual fraud:
Must have D…
Damages
Damages
Liable to anyone suffering a loss
Constructive fraud is also known as…
Gross negligence
Constructive Fraud AKA Gross Negligence has…2
1 All 5 elements of actual fraud
2 but Scienter is taken care of by reckless disregard for truth
What is the neumonic for constructive fraud AKA gross negligence?
MR RID
Constructive fraud AKA Gross negligence:
What does MR RID stand for?
Material misrepresentation Reckless disregard for the truth Reasonable reliance Intent to rely Damages
Reckless disregard for the truth
Making a statement without knowing if it is true or false
Confidential client information can’t be revealed to others without…
Client’s OK
Cannot reveal confidential information to…
Purchaser of CPA’s practice
Confidential client information:
If subpoenaed in a court case, accountant must…
Testify unless in a state that recognizes the accountant client
Privilege
Confidential Client info:
It must be revealed to…
A state CPA society quality control review panel
Who do working papers belong to? Who do they not belong to?
Belong to accountant, not the client
In working papers that belong to accountant…
Same rules of confidentiality apply
Accountant’s aren’t usually liable for negligence to…
3rd parties
Accountants aren’t usually liable for negligence to 3rd parties because…
There is no privity
Privity
No direct or contractual relationship between the accountant and
the 3rd party
3 rules that hold accountant’s liable to third parties at common law
1 Third Party Beneficiary Rule or Intended Users
2 Ultramares Rule (minority view)
3 foreseen users and any foreseen class of users (majority view)
Liabilities to Third Parties at Common Law:
Third Party Beneficiary Rule of Intended Users
Accountants are liable for negligence if they had no reason to know third party would rely on their work
Liabilities to Third Parties at Common Law:
Ultramares rule (minority view)2
1 if they were in privity with them or
2 they knew specific name of 3rd party that would rely on their
Work
Liabilities to Third Parties at Common Law:
Most states have expanded Ultramares to…
Make accountants liable for negligence to foreseen users and any foreseen class of users (Majority view)
Liabilities to Third Parties at Common Law:
Most states have expanded Ultramares to make accountants liable for negligence to foreseen users and any foreseen class of users. (majority view). Under this rule…2
1 accountants are liable for negligence to 3rd parties that are
members of a group accountant knew would rely on their work
2 thus it’s not necessary to know specific name of 3rd party, just
That they are member of group that would rely on accountant’s work
Privity is the only defense for what?
2) what is it not a defense for?
Privity is Only a defense to negligence actions by 3rd parties
2) no defense to fraud, ‘33, ‘34
Securities a to of 1933 requires…2
1 A registration statement filed with the SEC
2 containing audited financial statements prepared by accountants
For public sales of securities in interstate commerce
Civil Liability
Suits for money damages under section 11 of ‘33
Civil Liability- suits for money damages under Section 11 of ‘33 must show…3
1 acquired stock, need not be initial purchaser
2 suffered loss
3 material misrepresentation or omission of fact in the FS
No Scienter or reckless disregard for truth or reliance…
Need be proven by purchaser in securities act of 1933
Liability under Securities Act of 1933:
Accountant is liable unless he can prove…
It was not his fault (due diligence defense)
Liability under Securities Act of 1933:
Plaintiff must sue within…2
1 one year of discovery of misrepresentation and
2 within 3 years of the offering date
Liability under Securities Act of 1933:
Criminal liability if accountant…
Willfully made misrepresentation
Liability under Securities Exchange Act of 1934 generally covers…2
1 stock sold on national stock exchanges in interstate commerce
And
2 requires reports and financial statements prepared by public accountants
Liability under Securities Exchange Act of 1934:
Civil Liability for money damages under section 10 b & Rule 10 b-5 must show…5
1 Purchaser of stock 2 suffered a loss 3 material misrepresentation or omission of fact in CPA's report 4 must show Scienter 5 must show reliance
Liability under Securities Exchange Act of 1934:
Must also show Scienter (or reckless disregard for the truth) an intent…2
1 Intent to deceive or bad faith is not enough
2 negligence is not enough
A member of the AICPA may be expelled or suspended without hearing for any of the following:
Member’s CPA certificate or license or permit to practice is…
Revoked by state as disciplinary measure
A member of the AICPA may be expelled or suspended without hearing for any of the following:
Member is convicted of…
A crime punishable by imprisonment for more than one year
A member of the AICPA may be expelled or suspended without hearing for any of the following:
The member files or aids in filing…
A fraudulent tax return for client or self
A member of the AICPA may be expelled or suspended without hearing for any of the following:
Member intentionally…
Fails to file his tax return
AICPA Professional Ethics Division may investigate ethics violations an may…
Sanction those that are less serious using less serious remedies
Court decisions have constantly held that even if an individual is not a member of the AICPA, that individual is…
Still expected to follow profession’s Code of Professional Conduct
SECs actions against accountants:
After a hearing, the SEC can…
2) why?
Revoke or suspend a CPA from practicing before the SEC
2) if CPA willfully violated federal securities laws or regulations or
Has acted unethically or unprofessionally
If a caps is suspended from practicing before the SEC, he cannot serve as…
Auditor for public company
The SEC can revoke or suspend an accountant from practicing before the SEC upon…
Conviction of felony or misdemeanor in which moral turpitude was involved
PCAOB investigates and sanctions…
Registered firms for violations of standards of performance
Registered CPA firms must have…
Inspections by PCAOB staff
Firms with more than 100 publicly traded clients must…
Be inspected each year
Firms with 100 or less publicly traded clients must…
Be inspected every 3 years
More recently, many courts have expanded liability to…
Other third parties
Foreseen party 2
1 Third party who accountant knew would rely on FS
2 or member of limited class that accountant knew would rely on FS for specified transaction
Majority rule
Accountant is liable to foreseen third parties for ordinary negligence
The rationale for not allowing liability to more third parties is…
That accountants should not be exposed to liability in indeterminate amount to indeterminate class
The accountant is liable for fraud, constructive fraud or gross negligence to…
All parties whether foreseen or not
Foreseeable party
Any party that accountant could reasonably foresee would receive financial statements and use them
Majority rule is that accountant is not liable to…
Foreseeable parties for negligence
The CPA firm is responsible for reviewing for material events that occur up until…
The effective date of the registration statement
S-1 review
Made for review of events subsequent to balance sheet date up
Until making registration statement under securities regulation
5 Defenses available to auditors for the 1934 act
1 audit was performed with due care 2 misstatement was immaterial 3 plaintiff had prior knowledge of misstatement 4 plaintiff did not rely on information 5 misstatement was not cause of loss
4 defenses available to auditors for the 1933 Act
1 audit was performed with due care
2 misstatement was immaterial
3 plaintiff had prior knowledge of misstatement
4 misstatement was not cause of loss
What defense can be used by auditor’s in the 1934 act but not the 1933 act?
Plaintiff did not rely on the information
Professional liability insurance typically is used to cover such losses:
The duty to perform an audit is not delegable unless…
Client agrees to delegation
The duty to perform an audit is not delegable because it is…
It is a contract for personal services unless client agrees to
delegation
What insurance covers an accountant’s negligence
Accountants’ professional liability (malpractice) insurance covers
Their negligence
A fidelity bond…
Protects client from accountant’s fraud
CPA is generally not liable for the effects of events occurring…
2) liability extends to…
Subsequent to date of auditor’s report
2) effective date of registration for reports filed with SEC
Auditors who audit financial statements under the Federal Securities Exchange Act of 1934 are required to establish procedures to…3
1 detect material illegal acts
2 identify related party transactions and
3 evaluate ability of firm to continue as going concern
If auditor detects possible illegal activity, he or she must…
Inform audit committee or board of directors
Under the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act, If senior management or board fails to take remedial action and if illegal activities are material so that departure from standard audit report or auditor registration is indicated, the auditor shall…
Report this to the board of directors
Under the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act, If senior management or board fails to take remedial action and if illegal activities are material so that departure from standard audit report or auditor registration is indicated, the auditor shall report this to the board of directors. The board has how long to notify the SEC?
One day
If board does not notify the SEC in one day, the auditor must…
Furnish SEC with copy of auditor’s report to board and/or resign
from audit
Civil liability may be imposed by SEC for…
Auditor’s failures under the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act
Auditor’s are protected from…
Civil suits for these reports to SEC under the Private Securities Litigation Act
The Private Securities Litigation Reform Act amends…
1933 act and 1934 act
Private Securities Litigation Act was passed to…
Reduce lawsuits against accounting firms and issuer’s of securities
The SEC’s enforcement of securities laws is not affected by the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act because…
Law governs private litigation
Private Securities Litigation Act:
Discourages class action lawsuits for…
Frivolous purposes
Private Securities Litigation Act:
Discourages frivolous suits by…2
1 Providing stringent pleading requirements for many private actions under 1934 Act
2 Awards costs and attorneys’ fees against parties failing to fulfill
These pleading requirements
Private Securities Litigation Act:
Changes rules on joint and several liability so that…
Liability of defendants is generally proportionate to their degree
Of fault
Private Securities Litigation Act: example
Plaintiffs suffered $2 million in damages from securities fraud of a company. The auditors of the company are found to be 15% at fault. If the auditors did not act knowingly… Or acted knowingly?
Not act knowingly, they owe 15%
Acted knowingly, they owe the full amount
The is another name for SOX
Public Company Accounting Reform and Investor Protection Act