Midterm Review Flashcards
Micro ethics
individual’s right of right and wrong
Macro ethics
global view of right and wrong
Philosophical ethics
inquiry about ways of life and rules of conduct
Religious ethics
general pattern or way of life
Set of rules or “moral conduct”
professional codes for ethical behavior
Morality
describes a class of rules held by society to govern the conduct of its individual members
Morals
ideas about what is right or wrong
code of conduct
generally prescribes standards of conduct, states principles of expressing responsibilities, and defines the rules expressing duties of professionals to whom they apply
Code of ethics provide for
standards, principles, and rules of expected conduct
Standards
Guides to human conduct
Principles
describes responsibilities
rules of expected conduct
no allowance for individual judgement
moral judgements
judgement concerned with what an individual or group believes to be right or proper behavior in a given situation
moral judgements involve:
assessment of another person’s moral character
Morality legislated
-law has explicit rules, penalties
-laws are created to set boundaries for societal behavior
-laws are enforced to ensure that expected behavior happens
Moral dilemmas
arise when values, rights, duties, and loyalties conflict
Caregiver must not only examine what he or she considers the right thing to do, but…
-what are the alternatives
-what are the patient’s knwn wishes
Ethical theories
attempt to introduce order into the way people think about life and action
Meta-ethics
the study of the origin and meaning of ethical concepts
Metaethics seeks to understaand
ethical terms and theories and their application
Normative ethics
is prescriptive in that it attempts to determine what moral standards should be followed so that human behavior and conduct may be morally right
-euthanasia and abortion
Descriptive ethics
also known as comparative ethics, is the study of what people believe to be right and wrong and why they believe it
Applied ethics
The philosophical search (within western philosophy) for right and wrong within controversial scenarios
Consequential ethics
rightness or wrongness of an action is based on the consequences or effects oof the action
Deontology ethics
if often referred to as duty-based ethics. It involves ethical analysis according to a moral code of rules, religious or secular. Deon is derived from the greek word meaning “duty”
The non-consequential ethical theory
denies that the consequences of an action are the only criteria for determining the morality of an action
ethical relativism
Actions can be considered right or wrong depending on the accepted norms of the society in which they are practiced
Example of ethical relativism
slavery may be considered an acceptable practice in one society & unacceptable in another
Autonomy
right to make one’s own decisions
Beneficence
-principle of doing good
-demonstrating kindness
-showing compassion
-helping others
Paaternaalism
making decisions for others
A case of Paternalism
the family physician does not fully inform Mr. Smith as to the seriousness of his illness and how the consequences of the various alternative treatments might affect his life style
Nonmaleficence
-avoid causing harm
-not concerned with improving others’
-well-being but with avoidling the infliction of harm
Virtue ethics
focuses on the inherent character of a person rather than on the specific actions he or she performs
Intrinsic value
something that has value in and of itself
Instrumental value
something that helps to give value to something else
Compassion
sympathy for another’s suffering
Conscientiousness
one who has moral integrity and a strict regard for doing what is considered the right thing to do
Discernment
ability to make a good decision without personal biases
Fairness
ability to make judgements free from discrimination
Fidelity
being true to out commitments and obligations to others
Partial reasoning
involves bias for or against a person based one’s relationship with that person
Deontology ethics
is often referred to as duty-based ethics. It involves ethical analysis according to a moral code of rules, religious or secular.
-Deon is derived from the greek word meaning “duty”
Right to self-determination
every person has a right to determine what to do with his/her own body
2 million people die in the US every year
80% in hospital or LTC; 70% of those decide to forego life-sustaining treatment
Euthanasia
mercy killing of hopelessly ill, injured, or incapacitated (legal in Belgium for adults since 2002)
Active euthanasia
intentional commission of an act that results in death (lethal dose of meds)
Passive euthanasia
lifesaving treatment is withdrawn or withheld, allowing person to die natural death (removing respirator); treatment recognized as futile
Involuntary euthanasia
decision to terminate life of an incurable person made by someone else
Value questions face courts involuntary euthanasia
-who should decide withhold or withdraw treatment?
-factors on which decision should be based?
-criminal sanctions be imposed on a person assisting in ending life?
-when does death occur?
physician-assisted with death
dr. kevorkian
oregon, washington, and vermont…
legalized assisted death
oregon’s death with dignity act (1994)
“death with dignity act” allowed terminally ill patients to end their life
Consideration of the courts for the death with dignity
1 - level of function and ability to improve
2 - statements made regarding their wishes when they were competent
3 - the extent known of the pt’s values and beliefs toward medicine, sickness and death
4 - degree of physical pain caused by tx or termination of tx
5 - loss of dependence/humility caused by tx
6 - life expectancy, possibility of recovery
7 - impact of family
court can appoint a guardian if…
-family members disagree to incompetent persons wishes
-pts wishes cannot be known because he/she has always been incompetent
-doctors disagree on prognosis
-evidence exists of wrongful motives or malpractice
-no family member can serve as guardian
In re Storar
every human being of adult years and sound mind has the right to determine what shall be done with his or her own body
In re Quinlan
-constitutiional right to privacy protects pt’s right to self-determination
-a state’s interest does not justify interference with one’s right to refuse treatment
In re Dinnerstein
“no code” orders are valid to prevent the use of artificial resuscitative measures on incompetent terminally ill patients
In re Spring
Pt’s mental impairment & his/her medical prognosis with or without treatment must be considered prior to seeking judicial approval to withdraw or withhold treatment from an incompetent pt
Court involvement when
-family members disagree as to incompetent’s wishes
-physicians disagree on the prognosis
-a pts wishes are unknown because he or she always haas been incompetent
-evidence exists of wrongful motives or maalpractice
Defining death
American Medical Association in 1974: when there is “irreversible cessation of all brain functions including the brain stem.”
Who is equipped to pursue issues of assisted suicide
legislative & executive branches of government are equipped to pursue these issues
Physician-assisted suicide
is an action in which a physician voluntarily aids a pt in bringing about his or her death
US Supreme Court, in two unanimous & separate decisions, ruled:
- laws prohibiting assisted suicide are constitutional
- laws allowing doctors to assist in suicide of their terminally ill pt’s is constitutional
NM judge ruled that terminally ill, mentally competent pt’s have the right to get a doc to end their lives. The ruling by judge Nan Nash of the NM Second Judicial District would make NM the 5th state to allow doc’s to prescribe fatal prescriptions to terminal pts.
Steve Siebold, Huffington Post, March 14, 2014
Quill v. Vacco
The supreme court found that neither the assisted suicide ban nor the law permitting pts to refuse medical tx treats anyone differently from anyone else or draws any distinctions between persons
Pt Self-Determination Act of 1990
-Pt’s have right to formulate advance directives
-HC providers receiving federal funds under Medicare need to comply with regulations
Advance Directives
-pts have a right to make decisions about their HC
-with their physicians may agree to a proposed tx choose among offered tx, or say no to a tx
Durable Power of Attorney for Health Care
An agent makes health & personal care decisions for the pt in event the pt becomes unable to make his or her own decisions
Surrogate Decisioon Making
An agent who acts on behalf of a pt who lacks capacity to participate in a particular decision