Midterm Countdown Flashcards
A spouse’s P2IGS are separate (not marital) property
P – PROPERTY acquired by either spouse PRIOR to the marriage
P – PERSONAL injury awards to one spouse during the marriage
I – Property INHERITED by one spouse during the marriage
G – GIFTS to one spouse only, from someone other than the other spouse
S – Property purchased with one spouse’s SEPARATE property
What is the first thing you check for when doing a family law analysis?
Jurisdiction rules
What are the factors in determining a Committed Intimate Relationship?
a. Cohabitation
b. Duration of relationship
c. Pooling of resources
d. Purpose of relationship – stable and marital like
e. Intent to be in a committed marital like relationship.
f. Holding out to the community
g. Property distribution at “dissolution?” WA courts ask – what would be fair? Other states: see statute or refer to contract principles.
What questions do you ask after a CIR analysis?
Did the CIR lead to marriage and, if so, does the jurisdiction backdate asset acquisition?
What are the factors for common law marriage?
i. check jurisdiction rules for any jurisdiction that could apply (domicile)
ii. No ceremony
iii. Benefits and obligations of being married
iv. Cohabitation
v. Correct public perception
vi. Hold out as married – rights and obligations
vii. Intent and agreement to be married – both parties or 1 and uncorrected
When a client asks about getting a divorce, what is the first question you have to ask?
Was there ever a marriage?
What constitutes a void marriage?
c. Void – no divorce because marriage never existed. See Annulment
i. Consanguinity – incest – check jurisdiction
ii. Bigamy (check state procedure rules)
What are the steps of the competing marriage analysis?
- Presume 2nd marriage is valid
- 1st spouse has burden to show 1st marriage is valid on procedural and substantive grounds. 1st spouse must show no dissolution where the spouses were domiciled.
- 2nd spouse can disprove 1st marriage by finding dissolution in any jurisdiction and 2nd marriage ceremony was after dissolution
- If 2nd marriage is void then Bigamy - check putative spouse doctrine
What if there was neither a marriage nor a CIR? What are the next steps?
Check contract principles / express or implied contract / unjust enrichment
a. Clean hands doctrine
b. What was the intent of the parties?
c. What were the terms of the contract?
d. Can’t contract for sex
e. Check mutual benefit – defense for unjust enrichment
f. Unjust enrichment only applies to specific transactions, not to relationships
What is a voidable marriage?
i. Age, not of sound mind, duress – cured by continuing the marriage after
ii. Fraud – going to the heart of the marriage
iii. If cured – divorce
iv. If not cured - annulment
Who can challenge if a marriage is voidable or not?
Only the parties to the marriage can challenge whether the marriage is voidable or not.
What is a putative spouse?
An individual who believes in good faith that he or she is married and is afforded legal rights as a result of the individual’s reliance on the good-faith belief. Entitled to some of the spouse benefits at issue.
What are the steps of the putative spouse doctrine?
a. Check jurisdiction – not recognized everywhere.
b. Marriage ceremony with valid date (valid = check void/bigamy)
c. Good faith belief – check jurisdiction for test: subjective AND objective
i. Subjective – check for suspicions?
ii. Objective – what would a reasonable person believe based on facts
d. No recognized marriage, equitable remedy only
e. Property rights as if marriage was valid
What kinds of divorce are available?
Fault and no fault. Check the jurisdiction.
What are the steps in determining a fault divorce?
a. Check jurisdiction for which faults (if any) are recognized in this jurisdiction
b. Adultery – Majority of states require actual proof
c. Cruelty – physical or emotional (some states) requires proof of harm, harassment, false allegations, ridicule, abuse of relatives. (check jurisdiction for rules or precedents)
d. Desertion – Abandonment without consent or justification, statutory period
i. Constructive desertion – behavior that abandons (refusing sex)
What are the defenses to a fault divorce?
Condonation, Collusion, Connivance, Provocation, and Recrimination
In terms of defenses to fault divorces, what is condonation?
Forgiveness
In terms of defenses to fault divorces, what is Collusion?
Agreement to false claim to facilitate the divorce.
In terms of defenses to fault divorces, what is connivance?
Planning fraud to facilitate divorce or setting a trap
In terms of defenses to fault divorces, what is provocation?
Innocent spouse provoked the fault
In terms of defenses to fault divorces, what is recrimination?
Both spouses are at fault
Where is no-fault divorce available?
In all 50 states
What are the steps of a no fault divorce analysis?
a. Establish Jurisdiction – domicile for 90 days
b. Jurisdiction Rules – Irretrievable breakdown / differences and/or living separate & apart
c. 302 – Irretrievable breakdown or irreconcilable differences
i. Living separate and apart for 6 months
ii. Serious marital discord that makes 1 party no longer want to be married
d. Some states: having lived separate and apart for statutorily required period, typically 6 months if voluntary 12 months involuntary (1 party doesn’t want divorce)
e. 305 – mutual agreement or hearing, if hearing:
i. Court can find irreconcilable differences or
ii. Court can order counselling/conciliation then determine if irreconcilable
How is marital property distributed?
Between separate and community property