Midterm Content Flashcards
Ways of knowing [5]
- tradition (passed through generations; often immoral/incorrect)
- authority (professional tells you; not always trustworthy)
- trial-and-error (may not always arrive at best solution)
- logical reasoning (employs power of deduction to reach a conclusion; not always reliable)
- scientific research (via scientific method)
Scientific method [4]
- systematic (series of steps → identify problem, design study, collect/analyze data, interpret)
- empirical (observable/measurable)
- controlled (not all studies can be controlled, however)
- critical examination (reviewed/repeated by peers)
What is evidence-based medicine (EBM)? [4]
What does EBM take into consideration? [3]
What are barriers to EBM? [2]
EBM used to solve clinical problems.
It uses (1) conscientious, (2) explicity, and (3) judicious use of (4) current best evidence.
It considers (1) available resources, (2) client preferences, and (3) practitioners ability.
Barriers to EBM include (1) lack of time, and (2) lack of skill in critically reviewing/applying research.
Describe challenges in nutrition research. [5]
- optimal intakes differ across body systems
- difficult to accurately measure nutrient intakes
- length of exposure vs. timing of impact
- the nutrient effect may be small
- challenge of having no ‘no-intake’ group
Describe the procedure for EBM. [5]
- Formulate a question (PICO)
- Patient/problem of interest
- Intervention of interest
- Control/alternative treatment
- Outcome of interest
- Search for answers (3 S’s)
- Systematic (comprehensive resources)
- Syntheses (systematic reviews)
- Studies (original research)
- Appraise the evidence
- Appropriate study design?
- What does the data show?
- What does the data mean?
- Apply results
- Assess outcome
What are the stages in the research process? [8]
- Idea
- Literature review
- Define research question and hypothesis.
- Question is important, answerable, feasible, clear
- Hypothesis is testable NOT provable (either accept or reject it)
- Planning and study design
- Choose study design, define population, sampling method, what/how to measure variable, ethics approval
- Data collection
- Analysis → statistics
- Interpretation
- Dissemination
What type of research is hypothesis generating?
Descriptive research (of phenomena/populations), which may not have a hypothesis.
What is research?
Systematic investigation utilizing the scientific method.
What is a theory? [3]
A theory (1) organizes information, (2) helps explain past events, and (3) predict future ones.
Describe features of good quality research. [6]
-
relevant, answerable
- carries meaning
-
theory-driven
- builds upon current understanding
- reproducible
-
generalizable
- should apply to outside situations (outside study setting)
-
ongoing
- generates new questions
-
without bias/political motivations
- research is not done in a vacuum however
Compare basic, applied/clinical, and translational research.
-
Basic → acquires new knowledge, helps understanding of phenomena
- Includes cell and animal research
- ‘Bench’
-
Applied/clinical → directed towards solving a specific problem
- Done in humans (clinical trials)
- ‘Bed’
-
Translational → ‘bench to bedside’
- Starts with basic research, is then applied to a problem.
Describe types of clinical research. [7]
-
Observational → cannot test cause and effect
-
Descriptive
- Qualitative (examines behaviour in natural social/cultural/political contexts; information from open-ended answers)
- Quantitative (descriptive statistics)
- Case study/series (description of one/several patients)
-
Correlational/exploratory: looks for relationships between variables
- Cross-sectional (E+O)
- Case-control (O→E)
- Cohort (E→O)
-
Descriptive
-
True experimental research → investigator controls variable of interest; tries to discover causal relationships
- The Gold Standard → double-blind, placebo-controlled, randomized controlled trial
What is ‘true’ experimental research? [4]
- Treatment variable (exposure) is controlled by researcher (i.e., not associated with any confounders)
- Control for comparison
- Participants are assigned to groups randomly
- The Gold Standard = double-blind placebo-controlled randomized clinical trial
What is double blind?
What is double-double blind?
Does triple blind exist?
Double-blind: neither researchers nor participants know who is receiving a particular treatment (helps to prevent bias)
Double-double blind: two treatment groups and two control groups; neither researchers nor participants know who is receiving a particular treatment (even better at preventing bias)
Yes, triple blind exists, I’m not sure what it is though…
What is outcomes research?
What are the four types?
Outcomes research is conducted to measure the effects of services/interventions.
- clinical (length of stay, morbidity, mortality)
- functional (activities, mental/emotional health)
- patient satisfaction (expectations, self-assessed health status)
- economic (costs)
How is choice of research method restricted? [3]
Depends on the question and how much is already known, as well as available resources (time, staff, money, tech, etc.)
Further research is restricted by ethical considerations.
How is research disseminated? [5]
- Publication in peer-reviewed journals
- Meetings, conferences, proceedings
- Books
- Guidelines, policies
- Media
Describe the peer-review process.
Provides more confidence in scientific journals because other experts review/assess quality, suggest revisions, and decide whether to accept or reject.
Also note: there is a heirarchy of journals - American Journal of Clinical Nutrition is highly rated)
What types of research articles are there? [3]
-
Review (2º): tries to reach general conclusions about current status of literature; summary of past and current knowledge on the topic
- Narrative: no defined/systematic method in choosing papers to include; important to check data sources for author bias
- Systematic: uses clearly defined criteria to reduce bias; all articles meeting criteria are included; conclusions are based on all included articles; great source
- Original research (1º): conducted by author; describes study objective, methods, and findings in detail; usually a single study
- Commentaries, editorials, viewpoints: express professional opinions/interpretations
What are the goals of review papers? [4]
- summarize the state of the topic
- clarify unresolved issues
- suggest new hypotheses
- direct future research
What are the main components of a research paper? [7]
- Title: informative; describes findings or objectives, target population, and study design
- Abstract: summary of article; provides brief rationale, methods, main findings, and conclusion; can be subjective - must read whole article!
- Introduction: summary; provides rationale and background, clearly states thesis; only pertinent references included; does not include methods/data/results/conclusions; do not cite the introduction!
- Materials/Methods: identifies sufficient detail to allow reproducible results; data collection method; ethics considerations; subject sampling method etc; spend the most time here when critiquing study design.
- Results: data in text, tables and figures; does not explain
- Discussion: explains importance or novelty of findings in context of existing literature; future research suggested; synthesis and author opinion; subjective/possible bias; find limitations of study here!
- References and Acknowledgements
How does one paraphrase a research paper? [3]
- What did the study do?
- methods (population, intervention, outcome of interest)
- What did the study find?
- results (main findings including numbers where indicated)
- What does it mean? / Why does it matter?
- discussion (in context of the report; what are your own interpretations?)
Describe characteristics of a good research paper. [5]
- clear, proper use of language
- current, accurate literature cited
- sufficient detail provided for reproducibility
- no bias
- discussion highlights importance and limitations
What are the Bradford Hill Causal Criteria? [5] + [4 bonus]
What are concerns of the first 5?
-
Consistency of association: relationship observed repeatedly
- concerns: consistent errors across studies; inability to find consistent relationships due to methodological differences across studies (different tools used to collect information, different populations studied)
-
Strength of association: effect size
- concerns: often only weak associations in nutrition studies
-
Dose response: statistically significant linear trend
- concerns: threshold effects → nutrient/outcome relationships are not always linear; misclassification → food records vs. food frequency questionnaire
-
Biological plausibility: theoretical explanation/mechanism
- concerns: unknown mechanism for effects of nutrients on diseases; foods vs. nutrients (complex systems); what part of the food is responsible for the effect?
-
Temporality: exposure precedes the outcome
- concerns: did diet cause disease? Or did disease cause a change in the diet?
Bonus:
- Specificity: exposure causes a specific outcome
- Analogy: comparison to a similar biological system can be made
- Coherence: fits in with existing knowledge
- Experiment: true experimental study finds the association
What are some search tips when searching a database? [7]
- Use PICO framework
- Search one concept at a time
- Appropriate use of MeSH terms
- Keyword strategies
- Combining with AND & OR appropriately
- Applying limits at the end of the search
- Reverse engineering
What is a background question?
What is a foreground question?
- BG: general knowledge about a topic; can usually be answered by a 2º or 3º literature source (e.g., review article, clinical guidelines, textbook, etc.
- FG: patient-specific; focused question; PICO is used to formulate a clinical question
What is MEDLINE?
Medline is the premier biomedical database with over 26 million journal articles in the life science.
There are several different interfaces to the database (e.g., PubMed, Ovid)
Searching a database involves both a subject heading (MeSH) strategy as well as a keyword strategy.
How do you combine concepts with boolean operators?
What is MeSH? [4]
Medical subject heading
Controlled vocabulary indexing the article’s content; subject specialists index the article by tagging it with controlled vocabulary from a standardized list.
Organized in a hierarchical structure which allows for searching at various levels of specificity.
Articles are indexed to the most specific MeSH (e.g., articles about breakfast will not necessarily be indexed as well with meals)
Why use keywords?
- It takes a few months for articles to be indexed with MeSH
- Sometimes an appropriate MeSH is not available
- The concept is new to literature or is only recently added as a MeSH (e.g., Vegan / (2016))
- Indexes errors/omissions
- Completeness of your search
Describe 4 keyword strategies.
- Synonyms to describe concept
- Join synonyms with Boolean operator: OR (e.g., fat OR lipid)
- Truncation: * (e.g., diet* = diets, dietary, diet)
- Adjacency operator: adj (e.g., restricted adj2 fat* = the word restricted is within 2 words of the word fat)
What are explanations for associations? [5]
- Bias or systematic (spurious)
- Effect-cause (real)
- Confounding (real)
- Chance/random error (spurious)
- Cause-effect (real)
What is confounding?
A confounder is a 3rd factor that is:
- associated with the exposure and the outcome, and
- makes the two appear related when they may not be.
How can confounding be minimized? [4]
-
Study design
- Specification: design inclusion criteria that specify a value of a potential confounder and exclude those with that value
- Randomization: aim to evenly distribute confounders among study
-
During analysis
- Stratification: group and analayze participants based on their level of confounding variable
- Statistical adjustment: techniques used to adjust for confounders using available software
Caveat: data on confounding factor must be collected during the study to do stratification analysis/statistical adjustment (importance of good study design).
What is effect modification?
A 3rd variable modifies (does not explain) the effect.
The strength of the apparent association varies over different categories of a third variable (e.g., age, gender, genotype)
Discern between confounding and effect modification.
- Confounder → explains association
- Effect modifier → influences association, does not explain it.
Define populations and samples.
Population: entire group of interest (generalized results apply to this population)
Sample: portion of population included in the study (findings from this sample should be generalizable to the population)
What are the main goals of sampling for research design. [3]
- To choose a sample representative of the population.
- So results can be generalized to the population
- To reduce the sampling error.
What is sampling bias?
Selected individuals over-/under-represent certain population attributes related to the study.
What is sampling error?
Sampling error = x̄ - μ
More of a theoretical concept since we can’t know the true mean of the population. However, it can be estimated.
Sampling error is the difference between the sample and population means.
Reducing this error is the main purpose of sampling.
As the sample size increases, sampling error generally decreases (i.e., larger sample sizes are more representative of the population)
What is the problem with a sample size that is too small or too large?
Too small → significant differences may not be found; sample is not representative of population.
Too large → very expensive
Describe an adequate sample size for quantitative vs qualitative research.
Quantitative sample size → must be large enough to draw inferences from; the larger, the more representative (unless using poor sampling technique); note, a small sample the is representative is better than a large sample that is unrepresentative.
Qualitative sample size → small numbers provide in-depth information; e.g., proceed until saturation (continue until you’re not hearing anything new)
What are the two steps of sample selection?
- Define the target population (i.e., who you want the findings to generalize to); define the sampling frame (i.e., accessible population from which sampling is drawn); set inclusion/exclusion criteria
- Recruit/select subjects via probability or non-probability sampling.
What is the difference between probability and non-probability sampling?
Probability → random selection; reduces sampling bias; preferred
Non-probability → non-random selection
What are the four probability sampling techniques, and four non-probability sampling techniques?
Probability → Simple random, stratified random, cluster, systematic
Non-probability → convenience, purposive, quota, snowball
NOTE: No matter the method, the final sample = recruited subjects who consent to participate.
What is a simple random sample?
A simple random sample is a type of probability sampling where every individual within the sampling frame has an equal and independent chance of selection.
- Define population.
- List everyone in it.
- Choose randomly.
What is a stratified random sample and when is it used?
A stratified random sample is a probability sampling method used if people in the population differ systematically along some characteristic relating to the study factor. It may be disproportionate or proportionate.
- Sampling frame is divided into strata (e.g., age, sex, ethnicity)
- Samples are drawn randomly from each strata.
What is systematic sampling?
A type of probability sampling where researchers choose every kth name on a list (more simple than simple random sampling); will produce a random sample unless the subjects are listed in an order that could affect outcomes.
- Divide population by the size of the desired sample (e.g., 50 (population)/10(sample size) = 5)
- Select a random starting point.
- Select every 5th name as a sampling interval.
Differentiate between proportionate and disproportionate stratified random sampling.
Disproportionate → population proportions are not preserved; higher proportions selected from some groups compared to others; useful when it may be difficult to reach a sufficient sample size with some groups; data must be weighted during analysis.
Proportionate → population proportions are preserved
- Characteristics of interest are identified (e.g., gender)
- Individuals in population are listed separately according to classification
- Proportional representation of each classification is determined (or not)
- A random sample is selected that reflects the determined proportions OR randomly choose the same number from each group regardless of population proportions.
What is cluster sampling and when is it used?
Cluster sampling is a type of probability sampling used if natural groupings exist in the population (e.g., school districts, geographic boundaries). It divides the population into feasible samples.
Instead of randomly sampling individuals, entire units/groups are identified and a random subset (cluster) of them is selected, and then finally individuals from each cluster are chosen at random.
e.g., Of all schools in BC → 10 selected randomly → of selected schools → 10 students collected randomly
What is convenience sampling?
This is a non-random sampling technique is when researchers recruit whoever they can, or the most easily sampled population. This type of sampling has very weak representativeness, and may show bias due to ‘self-section’.
For example, standing at a mall or a grocery store and asking people to answer questions would be an example of a convenience sample. Or posting an advertisement and recruiting any respondent.
What is purposive sampling?
This is a type of non-probability sampling where researchers select subjects specifically for a reason → for example, if they know they need a very specific type of person, they will be sought out.
The sample will be selected by the researcher based on specific (subjective) criteria → more often used in qualitative research (rare in quantitative)
What is quota sampling?
This type of non-probability sampling is ‘equivalent’ to stratified random sampling. It is used when stratified random sampling is not possible.
Participants with the characteristic of interest are non-randomly selected until a quota is met.