Midterm Flashcards
Due Process- Amendement(s)
5th and 14th
Which amendment applies the fifth amendment to the states?
14th
Fifth amendment
Bars the federal gov’t from depriving anyone of life, liberty, and property without due process
Hurtado v. California
The state is not required to hold a grand jury for a serious crime in a state court to satisfy due process
Hamdi
Due Process guarantees that US Citizens held in the US as enemy combatants must be given meaningful opportunity to contest factual basis in front of neutral decision maker
Sixth Amendment
Right to counsel; speedy trial; etc.
Gideon
The 14th amendment incorporates the Sixth Amendment right to counsel to the states.
Special Circumstances Rule
Effective assistance, or an adequate opportunity to obtain it must be provided in capital cases if defendant are unable to represent themselves adequately.
Argersinger v. Hamlin
Decided that right to court-appointed counsel extends past non-petty offenses and included them.
Alabama v. Shelton
Broadens Gideon- The right to counsel extends to defendants that have a suspended sentence which could lead to imprisonment.
When does right to counsel begin?
A formal charge must have happened. It can’t just be under investigation. When a defendant becomes the subject of “adversarial judicial criminal proceedings– whether by way of formal charge, preliminary hearing, indictment, information or arraignment.
When does right to counsel end?
Whether or not the event is a critical stage in the proceedings.
What is a critical stage in the criminal proceedings?
Where the presence of counsel is required to protect the rights of the defendant.
Right to counsel at identification
Kirby case- Police may conduct an identification outside the presence of counsel before a suspect has been formally charged with a crime
Right to counsel for photo arrays
The Sixth right to counsel does not apply to photo arrays.