Midterm Flashcards
What things are organized topically?
Encyclopedias
Thesauruses
Dictionaries
Digests
What things are organized chronologically?
Law Reviews
ALR Annotations
Case Reporters
How do you petition to the Illinois Supreme Court?
Petition for leave to appeal
How do you petition to the U.S. Supreme Court?
Writ of certiorari
What are examples of secondary sources?
Encyclopedias Treatises Legal Periodicals Annotations Restatements Legal Dictionary Practitioner’s manuals (such as IICLE) Pattern jury instructions
What can secondary sources do for you?
Provide general overview (“big picture”) and background on a topic
Cite to primary authority sources
Criticize, analyze, and explain the law
Discuss trends in primary authority (where the law is going)
Can serve as persuasive authority if written by expert
What do secondary sources do?
Provide commentary about and analysis of “the law”
What can secondary sources not do?
NOT “THE LAW” (primary authority)
NOT binding on courts
What are A.L.R.’s?
Form of commentary synopsizing the various cases on a fairly narrow legal topic which is usually somewhat controversial
Discusses the law in various jurisdictions, comparing how different states or federal circuits handle a given issue
Written by publishing company staff attorneys, not legal expertsy
How are A.L.R.’s helpful?
Present a thorough general overview of topic
Cite to and provide annotations of numerous cases from varying jurisdictions
Provide comparative analysis among many jurisdictions
Provide reference to additional commentary
Usually very timely and updated
What are the challenges of A.L.R.’s?
Topics are pretty narrow, so A.L.R.s are not a good place to BEGIN your research
Although analysis is comprehensive, it is more descriptive than analytical or critical
Might not be an article covering your topic
How do you search in A.L.R.’s?
Consult the ALR Index or tables of cases or laws to identify pertinent annotations
Read the opening material
Use the various finding tools to identify pertinent passages
Read the text of the annotation
Consult the references section (cites to comm.)
Update your research
Pocket part
More recent annotation?
Latest case service hotline
How do I research cases?
Commentary should lead you to some cases
If you have a case name, you can use:
Digest Table of Cases or
Shepard’s Acts and Cases by Popular Names
SEARCH ON PAPER
Digests
Descriptive Word Index (organized by subject matter)
Topic method (lists info according to West’s topics/key numbers)
Words and Phrases (lists cases that have defined particular words/phrases)
SEARCH ONLINE – Westlaw, LexisNexis, court website
How do you search in digests?
Select an appropriate digest
Look up search terms in Descriptive Word Index or identify a topic and key numbers via the topic list
Assemble the digest volumes and supplements you need
Skim the outline of the topic in the digest
Peruse the digest paragraphs under pertinent key numbers
Use the references in the digest to locate cases in reporters
What are legal encyclopedias?
Present general information (text with footnote cites to authority) about various topics—some broad, some narrow
Usually written by publisher’s staff, not by legal experts
Best cited for broad well-established points of law
How are legal encyclopedia’s helpful?
Provide general overview of subject matter which is easy to read
Cite to authority
Help explain how various jurisdictions handle a given issue
May be used as finding tools (may browse within a subject area)
Identify related legal issues