midterm Flashcards
Ethical Challenges of Studying M-E
- For decades, some researchers have contributed to Western power structures in the Middle East by contracting for think- tanks, the intelligence services, and the military
- Additional ethical challenges for Western scholars arise from interactions with local experts, activists, and informants, especially in countries with repressive governments
Islam through Western
eyes
-Written by Said
-Two Sides of False Coin
-Brutal radical Islamist representation
-Apologetic form of a plea for Islam Humanism
- West views Islam through: passion Prejudice and political interests
Said on Orientalism
- impossible that “a large ideologically freighted generalization could cover all the rich and diverse particularity of Islamic life”
-“Orientalism” as an “imaginative geography” civ. west and unciv. other
The “Oriental Other”
-endowed both with far greater size and with a greater potential for power than the Wes
-objectifying it while also fearing it as a threat to Christianity
Scholarship and colonial knowledge
-Familiarity, accessibility, representability: these were what Orientalists demonstrated about the Orient. The Orient could be seen, it could be studied, it could be managed.
-Development of social sciences toFrance conquered Algiers in
France conquered Algiers in
1830
In colonial eyes, the First World possesses knowledge while the Third World possesses
Culture
Perceptions of Muslims by the west
Muslims and Arabs viewed as either oil-suppliers or potential terrorists especially after 9/11
“Saving women in Iraq” (3)
-US First Lady Laura Bush says that US instilled democracy and saved women & daughters
-Gayatri Spivak offers analysis of narrative of “white men saving brown women from brown men”
-Abu-Lughod: Why only look at “saving women and culture” instead of looking at role of USA in repressive regime
Why state formation matters for IR
- The process of state formation in Third World/underdeveloped countries underscores colonial powers’ role
- The Western role in drawing Middle Eastern borders would have an impact on interstate relations within the region and beyond
Decline of the Ottoman Empire
- Late 19th century: Ottoman Empire was waning; European powers carved out chunks of territory for themselves: Cyprus, Tunisia, the Balkans, Egypt
- In 1839, the Empire undertook the “Tanzimat” reforms intended to slow its decline
- These reforms continued and expanded into the 20th century
Endgame: the Ottoman Empire
- During WWI Besieged by British and Entente forces on the Mediterranean (Gallipoli, 1915) , southern (Arabia and Palestine, 1917), and eastern (Iraq, 1916-7) fronts, the Ottoman Empire lost much of its territory
- Believing the British would help them achieve statehood, Arab militiamen joined them under the leadership of T.E. Lawrence (“Lawrence of Arabia”)
Wilson’s Fourteen Points, Jan. 1918
- Reflecting growing US power, he made his“Fourteen Points” address to the US Congress, envisioning self-rule for previously occupied nations
- In his 12th point, he addressed Arab nationalist aspirations: “the other nationalities which are now under Turkish rule should be assured an undoubted. Security of life and an absolutely unmolested opportunity of autonomous development”
The San Remo Conference, April 1920
- UK, French, and Italian representatives met at San Remo to finalize arrangements of trusteeship in the Middle East
- The Mandatory governments were given “full powers of legislation and of administration”
- The League of Nations awarded the trusteeship of Palestine, Transjordan, and Iraq to the British at the San Remo Conference, 1920; it came into operation in 1923
- France received Mandatory powers over Syria and Lebanon, ending King Faisal’s rule over Syria
The Franco-Syrian War
- 30/9/1918: British forces capture Damascus
- 5/10/1918: With British permission, Emir Faisal, commander of Arab rebels vs. Ottomans, declares independent Syrian Arab government
- July 1919: In Anglo-French Agreement, UK agrees to cede Syria to France a per terms of Sykes-Picot Agreement
- Mar. 1920: Arab Kingdom of Syria declares its independence; European powers convene San Remo Conference in April to divide up Middle East territory
- June-July 1920: Syrian rebels revolted, expecting to lose but seeking to undermine French imperial legitimacy; kept fighting after Faisal’s surrender
- 24 July 1920: French forces seize Damascus; create separate Lebanese state
- 1921: British made Faisal King of Iraq in exchange for approving San Remo terms
Egypt: the limits of decolonization
-1919 Mass nationalist uprisings vs Brit control led Britain to consider other options
-1919 Joint copt muslim protests shows religious unity
-1922 British Treaty with Egypt ended the Brit mandate and gave Egypt independence
-However under the treaty’s terms the brit maintained control over Suez canal, military bases on Egypt soil to “defend” it against “external aggression” protecting foreign interest and local minorities and the S/udan
-Egypt still wasn’t admitted to the league of nations
Iraq a British Mandate invention
-By 1914, the uk wanted iraqi oil
-British captured Baghdad in March 1917
-British carved iraq out of the ottoman provinces of mosul baghdad and basra
-They imported king daisal from Arabia appointed a Sunni monarchy to govern
-Kurds in north shi’a in south rejected Sunni primacy
-British made utrastrataegic kuwait a separate country angering Iraqis
Iraqi revolt 1920
-Angered by brit control
-The brits put down the revolt only with great difficult
-Brits relied on aerial bombs, Brit General Haldane called for poison gas use
Paradox of british strength regarding Iraqi resistance and policing
Had so many ressources and strength but colony could revolt at any moment so is it strength