midterm Flashcards
what are the defining characteristics of deviance?
violation of a social norm that is…
- socially recognized
- normative
- relativist
what does malum in se mean?
wrong or evil in itself; essentialist view of deviance
what does malum prohibitum mean?
- wrong because it is prohibited
- unlawful by virtue of statute
- relativist view of deviance
does Becker’s “Outsiders” accept a malum in se or a malum prohibitum view?
- malum prohibitum
- relativist approach: believes the deviance is socially constructed
according to Becker’s “Outsiders” (1963), what is deviance?
- socially constructed - deviance is what society labels it to be
- failure to obey rules and the consequences/ sanctions that follow
according to Becker’s “Outsiders” (1963), what makes deviance political?
deviance is characterized by a failure to obey rules, and rule-setting always involves a power dynamic, and is therefore a political action
does Costello (2006) support a relativist or essentialist view of deviance? how so?
- essentialist
- there is an overarching idea of deviance based on the harm that a behaviour causes
what are the main critiques of Costello’s “cultural relativism and the study of deviance” (2006)?
- gap between theory and empirical analysis
- lack of cross-cultural comparisons
- uses only one case study
- alt interpretation of results (eg. concern with extramarital sex may be due to religious context in the US)
- is homosexuality really normative? it is still considered highly deviant in many places
- “facts” and cultural diversity
- lack of historical insight
what is the main thesis of Costello’s “cultural relativism and the study of deviance” (2006)?
- denounces cultural relativism and blames the demise of the sociology of deviance on its prevalence in the discipline
- argues that deviant behaviour is universally evaluated in terms of the harm that it causes
- what is considered harmful is based on victimhood, not political ideology
- eg. adultery is more deviant than homosexuality
what is the thesis of Goffman’s “the presentation of the self in everyday life” (1969)?
- our daily interactions follow the same patterns as a theatre performance (“dramaturgical analysis”)
- we engage in impression management
- serves to help us maintain norms
what is a dramaturgical analysis? who’s work employs this perspective?
- analyzing daily interactions in terms of a theatre show or performance
- Goffman: “the presentation of self in everyday life”
according to Goffman’s “The Presentation of Everyday Life”, how are norms maintained?
- our social interactions strive to create and maintain a particular image of the self
- this impression management is a moral obligation to society
- all parties work for this representation to succeed
in Goffman’s “The Presentation of the Self in Everyday life”, how do our modern social interaction differ from in the past?
- there is no more backstage: Goffman believes that people’s guards are always up
- we live in a society of complete scrutiny
according to Goffman’s “The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life”, what is the difference between cynical and naive role-playing?
- cynical role-playing: when actors are aware that they’re playing a role
- naive role playing: when actors identify with the role and forget that it is something that they are playing
according to Colin Sumner, why did deviance “die”?
deviance couldn’t generate a core group of general theories due to…
1. the discipline’s relativist view (which focused on the situational nature of deviance), and
2. its related attempts to explain behaviours through the lens of legality (which then became criminology)
according to Miller, Wright, and Dannels (2001), is the sociology of deviance dead? why or why not?
- (like Goode) the pure study of the sociology of deviance may have declined since the late 70s, but saying it is “dead” is an exaggeration
- the deviance perspective (notably its social constructionist thinking) continues to hold influence in various fields, including criminology, feminism, postmodernism, etc.
according to Goode (2002), is the sociology of deviance dead? why or why not
- (like miller et al) the sociology of deviance has declined in theoretical vitality since 60s/70s, but has an enduring legacy in terms of influence in other fields
- (unlike miller et al) criminology has not replaced the sociology of deviance, it is just its most dominant sub-discipline
according to Goode (2002), why has the sociology of deviance seen a decline since the 70s?
the postivist-constructionist split has greatly contributed to the fall of a coherent “sociology of deviance” field of study
what is the statistical view of deviance?
anything that varies too much from the mean or median is deviant
what is the pathological view of deviance?
- deviance is what causes an organism, institution, or society to become wrought with disease or to behave in an unhealthy or inefficient way
- relevant mostly to the medical field
what is the functionalist view of deviance?
requires us to discriminate between features of a society which promote stability and those which disrupt stability
according to Goffman’s “The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life”, what is performance disruption? what are its consequences?
performance disruption = acting in a way that is incompatible with one’s facade of the self
consequences occur at three levels:
1. personality (impacts to one’s ego and sense of self)
2. interaction (eg. feelings of embarrassment as convo comes to a halt)
3. social structure (repercussions for one’s reputation)
according to William Sumner, what are the two types of norms? what are their characteristics?
- mores: norms that carry great importance in our lives (strictly observed, substantial social sanction, often grounded in formal laws)
- folkways: norms for routine and casual daily interaction (lesser social sanctions, often unspoken)
according to Garfinkel, what is ethnomethodology?
- the study of the methods and norms used to produce social order
- includes breaching experiments
what was Stanley Milgram’s subway experiment?
- example of a breaching experiment
- asking people for their seat on the metro; three conditions (no justification, trivial justification, overheard conversation)
- grad students were unable to carry out the experiment out of fear of mild social embarrassment
what was/were the main goal(s) of Fox’s “Watching the English” (2004)?
- identify the common unspoken rules that people follow in British society, and how these define national identity
- examine how new forms of communication technology require the formation of a new set of social norms/rules
describe the theological (demonological) approaches to deviance and crime
- belief that people are deviant because they are possessed by demons/satan, causing them to act against God’s wishes
- met with intense physical sanctions involving making the body uncomfortable for the spirit (torture, skinning, burning, etc)
- deviance is fatalistic: people can’t control their behaviour, as it is based on possession or predestination
when/where were the theological/demonological approaches to deviance and crime popular?
- middle ages -> renaissance
- Western (European/Judo-Christian)
broadly describe the classical approaches to deviance and crime
- committing a crime is a rational choice
- minor crimes were met with fines, while serious crimes were met with execution
- rehabilitation is not an option
- severe sanctions were thought to deter people from committing crimes
- like the theological approaches, classical approaches are fatalistic, metaphysical, and leave no room for alternative theories
when were the classical approaches to deviance and crime popular?
- starting during Enlightenment (18th century)
- neoclassical approaches still exist today (eg. rational choice theory)
what were the main points of Cesare Beccaria’s “Essays on Crime and Punishment” (1764)? what theoretical approach did he use?
- classical approach
- people are rational, have full control over their behaviours, and have full responsibility and accountability for their actions
according to Jeremy Bentham, what were the guiding principles of punishment? what theoretical approach to deviance and crime did he use?
- classical approach
1. swift
2. certain (no consideration for special cases/intention)
3. severe
describe Cohen and Felson (1979)’s routine activity theory. what type of theoretical approach do they use?
- neoclassical approach
- people are more likely to commit crimes when there is a…
1. motivated offender
2. suitable target
3. absence of fear of punishment
who founded the school of early biological positivism? when?
Cesare Lombroso, 1876
what is criminal anthropology? what theoretical approach does it use?
- scientific investigation of the relationship between physical characteristics and criminal behaviour (eg. phrenology)
- biological (positivist) approach
- based in racial superiority perspectives
who invented phrenology?
Franz Joseph Gall
what is atavism? who pioneered it?
- idea that physiological resemblance to earlier stages in human evolution has impacts on criminal behaviour
- Cesare Lombroso
what did Lombroso seek to explain in his book “The Born Criminal”? what were his conclusions? what theoretical approach to crime and deviance did he subscribe to?
- biological positivist approach; influenced by Darwinism
- examined the physical characteristics of 840 criminals to see what aspects of appearance were linked to deviant behaviour
- believed that criminals suffer from lower levels of physical development, which is linked to lower levels of moral development
what were the 4 body types outlined by William Sheldon in the “Atlas of Men”? what were the associated characteristics? which theoretical approach to crime and deviance does this follow?
- endomorph: overweight with large stomach; tolerant and likes people
- mesomorph: athletic and muscular; aggressive, competitive, fearless, risk-taking
- ectomorph: thin and fragile; artistic and introverted
- balanced: average build; without special traits
- biological approach
according to Sheldon’s “Atlas of Men”, which class of men are most commonly linked to criminal behaviour?
- mesomorph: athletic and muscular
- tend to be aggressive, competitive, fearless, and risk-taking
what are the main critiques of Sheldon’s “Atlas of Men” constitutional theory?
- most people don’t maintain the same body type across their lifetime
- alt explanation: more propensity to commit crimes in early adulthood + more common to have athletic body type at that age
- subjective assessment issue: more muscular men may be perceived by law enforcement as being more capable of physical aggression
list the modern biological explanations for crime and deviance
- chemical imbalance (hyperclycaemia)
- genetic influence
- neuropsychological factors
- sociobiology (evolutionary psychology)
what chemicals/chemical imbalances are found to be positively linked to criminal tendency, according to modern biological explanations of crime and deviance?
- hyperglycaemia (high blood sugar)
- arsenic and lead in water/food supply