MIDTERM 1 (L01-08) Flashcards
What is the mind? What is consciousness? Where is it located?
- Let’s define consciousness as the state or quality of awareness - awareness of our thoughts, perceptions, memories, and feelings
- The state of awareness creates a subjective experience
- If a being is capable of having subjective experiences, then there is something that it is like to be that being
- What is it like to be a rock, or house plant, or ant?
- What is it like to be a calculator, computer, or AI robot?
What was the frontal lobotomy used for at first, in the 1940s?
- The frontal lobotomy was used to treat psychosis, depression, anxiety, etc.
- The Nobel Prize was awarded for this procedure in 1949
- By the 1950s, over 20,000 lobotomies had been performed in the US alone
What is split-brain operation?
An outdated surgical approach for treating seizure disorder (epilepsy) that involves cutting the corpus callosum
This surgery is generally effective, but it has unacceptable side effects
What is the corpus callosum?
the bundle of nerve fibres that interconnect the left and right sides of the cerebral cortex
it enables the two hemispheres to share information so that each side knows what the other side is perceiving and doing
it is the largest commisural pathway in the brain consisting of over 200 million nerve fibers-axons
What is the anterior commissure?
The anterior commissure is a small band of approximately 50,000 axons that connects the cerebral hemispheres
What are our cerebral hemispheres used for?
- Our cerebral hemispheres are critical for our ability to CONSCIOUSLY process sensory information (sights, sounds, touch, etc.)
- Our cerebral hemispheres are also critical for our ability to CONSCIOUSLY (purposefully) move our body in space (e.g., hand and leg movements)
- Each cerebral hemisphere is responsible for one half of the body, but the nerve fibre mostly crisscross
- The left brain is largely responsible for the right side of the body
- The right brain is largely responsible for the left side of the body
How do the left/right distinction in cerebral hemispheres apply to visual processing?
When you look at something (fixation point), everything you see to the left of that spot is processed by the right brain, and everything you see to the right of that spot is processed by the left brain
What happens when the corpus callosum is cut?
the two cerebral hemispheres cannot directly talk to each other
but they can still send information downwards (to the brainstem and spinal cord) to control muscles
What do the brainstem and spinal cord help our bodies do?
These lower brain areas help coordinate body movements by integrating the information they receive from the two cerebral hemispheres
it is impressive how well they can do this job (coordinate bilateral movements) when the two cerebral hemispheres lose the ability to talk to each other
What did Roger Sperry find during his experiments done on corpus callosum?
He became confident the corpus callosum was important for something
His lab cut the corpus callosum of cats and monkeys, where they could be confident the surgeries were clean and complete
They found that it caused cognitive peculiarities
What are the intersting dilemmas found in split-brain patients?
- In general, when these new split-brain patients were recovering from their surgery, they reported that they felt fine, no different than before
- Often the frequency and/or severity of their seizures were reduced
- The surgeries were a success
- BUT some of these patients later said that their left hand sometimes seemed to have a mind of its own
- Their left hand sometimes actively worked against what the person was consciously trying to accomplish
- It seemed that their left hand was being controlled by processes outside their conscious awareness
- The right hand, controlled by the left brain, never acted out of the ordinary
- Its actions were always consistent with the person’s conscious intentions
What happens when a split-brain patient closes their eyes and touch a familiar but unidentified object with their left hand?
When a split-brain patient closes their eyes and touches a familiar but unidentified object with their left hand, they cannot identify the object out loud
What happens when a split-brain patient sees an image only in their left peripheral vision?
When a split-brain patient sees an image only in their left peripheral vision, which is processed on the right side of the brain, they cannot verbalize what they see
Split-brain patients cannot say out loud something that only the right brain sees
TRUE or FALSE: Split-brain patients appear to be unconscious of - cannot verbalize - any stimuli directed exclusively to their right brain
TRUE
How do split-brain patients compensate for their deficits in perception?
- Often one hemisphere seemed to take the lead in controlling behaviour in a situation dependent manner, and well-practiced bimanual skills could be coordinated by subcortical structures
Where is language located in the brain?
our comprehension of language and our ability to talk and write is generally located in the left cerebral hemisphere
What did Sperry discover in the mute right cerebral cortex of some split-brain patients?
That they could understand simple phrases
- It seemed to retain a bit of a “dictionary” and could understand simple numbers, letters, and short statements
He also found that split-brain patients could use their left hand (controlled by their mute right brain) to indicate answers to simple questions
What is Gazzaniga’s Interpreter Theory?
Gazzaniga’s Interpreter Theory says that behaviour is fully controlled by unconscious processes, and that the function of our left-brain consciousness is to create narratives in an attempt to make sense of the world
Our consciousness doesn’t directly influence behaviour
- It weaves disparate points of information into a story that has meaning
The underlying premise is that free will is an illusion, and consciousness is just storytelling
- Since storytelling relies on language, consciousness must only be located in the left cerebral hemisphere of the human brain
What is the Mind-Body Dualism?
- Cartesian doubt or hyperbolic skepticism
- “I think, therefore I am”
- But what is thinking? What are thoughts and ideas? You can’t touch them nor hold them. You can’t find them by cutting open the head; they are immaterial
- For Descartes, the act of thinking proved that an immaterial world exists
- Mind-Body Dualism
- While the body may be a mechanical device and the world deterministic, the mind (or soul) is something else, something immaterial that exists outside the body
What is the Cartesian impasse? (in relation to the mind-body dualism)
If the movement of all atoms can be well explained by the physical laws of nature, how can our immaterial souls control our material bodies?
How does evolution “solve” the Cartesian impasse?
- Neural networks have the function of controlling movement, but in service of this function they seem to have gained the ability to control their own dynamics through storytelling and theorizing
- Ideas exist as patterns of brain activity
- Once generated, they act to constrain and direct future brain activity (by harnessing the laws of physics)
- It is by theorizing about cause and effect that we generate the idea that things happen for a reason, that things have meaning
- Self-awareness may stem form the realization that our thought do influence the future
- It is perhaps by envisioning a potential future that neural networks gain influence over or to some extent construct the future
What is thinking?
-Thinking is not calculating
- Rather, it is an act of creation that involves theorizing, not only about what we are and how the world is, but how these things ought to be, how they might otherwise be
What atoms make up >99.99% of the universe’s atoms?
hydrogen and helium
What is ordinary matter made of?
all ordinary matter in the universe is made from elements on the periodic table