Micro - Market Failure and the Role of the Government and Unions in the Labour Market Flashcards
Labour Market Failure
The situation which occurs when the market forces of supply and demand fail to produce an efficient allocation of labour resources. Types of labour market failure are surpluses/shortages in the supply of workers to a particular occupation, workers being in occupations they are not suited to, a lack of training/skills, and wages above or below the equilibrium rate
Monopsony
A market in which there is only one buyer, or one that is dominant - in the case of a labour market, there is only one employer, e.g. NHS for doctors, nurses, etc.
Allocative efficiency
Producing goods and services which match the changing needs and preferences of consumers - essentially, maximising consumer satisfaction.
Equilibrium position for a monopsonist
Employ at quantity of labour at which MCL = MRPL, but wages are set where that quantity meets the ACL curve.
Factors favouring a trade union
- Wage-inelastic demand for labour - this can occur due to inelastic D for the product being produced, inelastic S of other factors, wage costs making up a small proportion of firm’s costs.
- High union density
- Firm making large profits
- Economy in the boom phase of the economic cycle
- Difficult to substitute K for L
- Low unemployment
- Public support
- Favourable legislation
- Strike action causing large-scale disruption
Union tactics - wage rate imposition
Union forces firm to pay workers a higher wage than they currently receive. Result is an improved wage rate but decreased employment and introduction of inequilibrium unemployment - shown by diagram.
HOWEVER decrease in employment is small if DL is inelastic, or if firm absorbs costs into profit margin.
Union tactics - reduced SL
Unions can boost the wage rate by changing the conditions of supply, e.g. by increasing necessary qualifications in order to restrict supply of labour to the profession. Thus, the wage rate is increased - show on diagram - but fewer jobs are available.
Union tactics - increased DL
Unions can work to improve their workers’ MRP, most likely by doing productivity deals with firms - this will force firms to improve their productivity in order to receive a higher wage. Thus, MRP increases, DL increases, wage rate and employment increase.
Bilateral Monopoly
A situation whereby a monopsonistic employer recruits workers from a monopolistic seller of labour - this occurs when the monopolist is a union with high density - can work as a countervailing power to that of the employer, thus achieving acceptable wages and conditions. E.g. NHS vs. Royal College of Nurses. The two sides have opposite aims, so a compromise much be reached, the position of which depends on their relative strength.
Factors favouring employers
- Financial reserves - can afford to withstand strike action, cover legal costs
- Low proportion of workers in the TU
- Ability to substitute K for L
- High unemployment - large recruiting pool
- Low public support for TU
- Minimal disruption resulting from strike action
- Ability to outsource/offshore production
- Favourable legislation
Bilateral monopoly - wage imposition
Theoretically, in a bilateral monopoly situation, a union can impose a new wage rate and increase employment at the same time. Imposition of wage creates new SL curve from WU along to old SL, then up it. Employers still employ at MRP = MCL, but this meets the new SL curve and employers move along the flat section, as they can employ more workers at the same wage rate. Thus, employment reaches QU. In theory, this can continue up to the equilibrium position.
Collective bargaining - positive
- Better working conditions - better productivity?
- Achieves fairer and more efficient wage outcomes in bilateral monopoly situations
- Power of big business is checked
Collective bargaining - negative
- Pay may not reflect the value of work done
- May cause redundancies
- May lead to inefficient allocation of resources and unproductive workers
National Bargaining
Appropriate when pay scales are set on a national level or decided by government, e.g. teachers, doctors.
Local Bargaining
Some view national bargaining as overly inflexible, and argue that some situations call for more focused local bargaining. E.g. it is generally acknowledged that public sector workers in London enjoy a lower standard of living than in areas where the cost of living is lower.
Individual bargaining
Appropriate in a profession in which each worker clearly contributes a different amount to the firm, e.g. footballers.
Wage Rate
The amount a firm pays its workers per unit of time or output
Earnings
Wages plus bonuses/commission/overtime
Remunerations
Earnings plus non-pecuniary benefits
Imperfect Information - The Applicant
- What you know about the employer: what you see in brochures/hear from other employees you know (if you know any)
- What you don’t: any negative aspects about the firm that it chooses not to advertise, e.g. stress, long hours
Imperfect Information - The Employer
- What they know about the applicant: what the applicant puts on their application, e.g. qualifications
- What they don’t: anything which the applicant chooses to omit - usually negative personal characteristics - e.g. laziness
Consequences of imperfect information - applicant
Stress, boredom, long hours
Consequences of imperfect information - employer
Poor work, low productivity, loss of customers, loss of profits
Consequences of imperfect information - economy
Inefficiency, wasted resources, falling output, increased prices, unemployment
Problems arising from skills shortages for - individual worker
Low pay, difficulty in obtaining employment, vulnerability to long-term unemployment, vicious cycle - low-skilled, can’t get work, can’t get training, low-skilled, etc
Problems arising from skills shortages for - firms
Recruitment difficulty/unfilled vacancies, high wage costs, inefficiency (affects profits), difficult to grow/diversify
Problems arising from skills shortages for - the macroeconomy
Problems with growth, trade and tax revenue, lack of FDI
Cyclical unemployment
Unemployment caused by a lack of AD in the economy - usually occurs during an economic downturn