Micro Context Flashcards
Example of firm being X inefficient
De Beers Diamond monopoly for much of 20th century, nationalised utilities not facing competition
Example of firm being productively inefficient
Manchester United- Jim Ratcliffe has to undergo cuts, 250 redundancies and restructuring as they had lost £300 million in last 3 years; employed a body- language consultant earning £175,000 a year, Government- subsidised agriculture firms, Ford before 2000s
Example of firm being allocative inefficient.
Pharmaceutical company, De Beers, Apple, AT+T used to operate as a monopoly in telecommunications in the USA
Example of third degree price discrimination
Taxis and rail- timing between peak and non- peak hours, Student discounts, Cinemas: students/ adults/ seniors (?), Night- clubs: early- entry ticket (?), Means-tested student tuition fees (different for different incomes)
Example of collusion in Oligopoly
CMA found collusion over 19 contracts, trying to inflate prices by submitting cover-bids (bid-rigging), in construction industry between 2013-2018 (regional oligopoly). Firms fined nearly £60 million. Virgin Atlantic and British Airways colluded on fuel surcharges- £121.5 million fine on BA; Virgin avoided fines due to whistleblower status
Example of price leadership in an Oligopoly
Delta airlines in US airline industry (tacit collusion)- American Airlines and United airlines followed suit on a fare increase in 2028 across domestic routes. BT dominant in broadband pricing in UK over TalkTalk and Sky. Tesco in supermarket industry (but more competitive)
Example of a price war and a competitive oligopoly
Supermarket industry due to competition from Lidl and Aldi- leading to Tesco doing ‘Aldi price match’ campaign etc. Budget airlines Ryanair had dropped prices as low as £5-10 on routes to attract volume (over EasyJet for instance)
Examples of non price- competition used in an oligopoly
Loyalty schemes- Nectar card, Tesco clubcard (which has over 16.3 million users), Perks such as with 02 priority- exclusive access to concert tickets, branding and sponsorships (Coke sponsoring Olympics and Pepsi using advertisements with Messi), After sales care: Curry’s tech support and free recycling, Vauxhall Care- car warranties
Example of a monopoly being dynamically efficient
Dyson invested £9 million a week in Research and Development in 2023, historically pioneered bagless vacuum cleaners, digital motors and baseless fans. Ocado has developed robotic warehouse systems and AI driven logistics software. Tesla hasn’t always made a profit but is a frontrunner in investing in EV technology.
Example of a monopoly not being dynamically efficient.
British Rail pre privatisation.
De Beers had little incentive in investing in technological advances to lower costs and improve consumer choice. Thames losing 600 million litres of water per day, no investment in smart/AI leak detection sensors like Yorkshire water. In 2023 CEO Bentley was payed £1.5 million in a compensation package. 2023-2024 first half- 54% drop pre-tax profits despite revenue increasing 12%.
Examples of monopolies exploiting consumers with ridiculously high prices
In 2015, Turing pharmaceuticals raised the price of Daraprim, a life saving Parasitic drug, from $13.50 to $750 overnight, (over) a 5000% increase. De Beers artificially restricted supply to keep prices high and promoted the myth of diamond scarcity through ‘A diamond is forever’. Uk water companies- regional monopolies as households cannot choose their water supplier.
Examples of where markets have been subject to ‘hit and run’ tactics
Jet 2 and Flybe temporarily entered busy routes in peak season charging lower fares; then withdrew once Ryanair and EasyJet matched them. Kapten and Bolt made aggressive short-term entries in London and Manchester offering heavy discounts. Kapten left UK entirely in 2021. During lockdown, Big Eats and Goodeats entered during the pandemic offering lower commission fees to restaurants(but failed to scale)
Examples of contestable markets pushing down prices
Ryanair offering budget flights as low as £1 pushes incumbents to cut fairs and introduce similar budget offerings- British Airways’ BA CityFlyer, Entry of online-only banks like Monzo/ Revolut led traditional banks to cut fees on overdrafts, international transfers and ATM withdrawals, Aldi and Lidl leading to price- matches, Pre-2021, the entry of Bulb and Octopus energy who had lower overhead costs pushed prices down for energy
Examples of differentiated goods in monopolistic competition
Restaurants and cafes- different menu items, clothings stores- different styles (fast-fashion), coffee shops- atmosphere, additional services like WiFi, Bottled water- branding
Give examples of Creative destruction
Nokia forced to sell its business to Microsoft in 2014, having been replaced by IPhones, Samsungs and other Android phones.
Blockbuster (DVD company) being replaced by Netflix.
Amazon disrupted traditional department stores like Sears and Toys R Us.
Example of a natural monopoly being wasteful
Thames Water underinvest in infrastructure- leak 600 million litres of water a day, don’t have smart/AI lead detection technologies. Paid over £150 million to its parent company in dividends in 2024 whilst being in £19 billion of debt- fined by Ofwat. Has been fined for waste and environmental exploitation.
Example of framing policies
‘Global warming’ seems more drastic than ‘climate change’.
‘Clubcard prices’- makes discounts seem exclusive and like more valuable savings
‘Freshly prepared in-store’ vs ‘pre-packaged’
‘Essential range’- budget lines are labelled to imply practicality rather than financial constraint in Waitrose
‘25% fat free’ sounds better than ‘75% fat’
Example of nudging policies
Place healthier food at front of store and at eye level; Social norm messaging on bills ‘more energy than their neighbours’; calorie labels on menus, smaller plate sizes in buffets
Examples of where loss- aversion can be exploited
Scarcity messaging+ limited time offers e.g. Amazon: only 3 left in stock- triggers fear of losing out on deal
Free trials with automatic renewal e.g. Spotify/ Netflix : cancelling fees feels like a loss of something already gained
Pension auto- enrolment- opting out feels like losing future security
Example of second degree price discrimination
Bulk- buying water cheaper than a single unit
Cinema: front-row seats vs middle vs back vs VIP
E-book, hardcover or paperback
Examples of indirect taxes
VAT (20%); Fuel duty- tax on petrol/ diesel; Alcohol duty, Tobacco duty (cigarettes); Air passenger duty (long haul economy £87); Sugar tax; plastic packaging tax (less than 30% recycled plastic)
Examples of Government policies used to correct negative externalities
Carbon pricing & emissions trading scheme (UK ETS)- companies must buy permits to emit CO2 ;10p charge for single- use plastic bags; Tobacco duty/ sugar tax, ULEZ
Examples of government failure
Housing planning restrictions- Green belt has artificially restricted supply of housing pushing up house/rent prices.
2019 Energy Price Cap by Ofgem has discouraged new entrants and innovation- small suppliers went bust in 21/22.
Fuel duty frozen every year since 2011- estimated lost £80bn in revenue/ limit incentive to switch/fund greener transport
Examples of Common Access Resources
Sea, air, forests