MGMT 200 Flashcards
Federal judges are appointed to their positions for life. They do not have to run for election. True or false?
True
Judicial Review means that the:
a) supreme court has the power to declare legislative acts unconstitutional
b) the president has the power to appoint judges
c) congress has the power under the constitution to grant pardons
d) the Chief Justice is always appointed from current members of the Supreme Court
a
which of the following is NOT a response by a defendant to a plaintiffs initial pleading?:
a) complaint
b) answer
c) motion to dismiss
d) motion for summary judgement
a
over the years the Courts have clearly defined the parameters of free speech guaranteed by the first amendment. True or false?
false.
always changing
Concurrent jurisdiction refers to which of the following?
a) a case with both in peronam jursidition and in rem jurisdiction
b) a case involving minimal contacts
c) a case that may be filed in either the state or federal court system
d) personal service using a long-arm statute
c
Liebeck V. MCDONALDS
jury awarded Liebeck $2.86 million
judge reduced award to $640,000
parties settled
What is law?
a body of rules and conduct prescribed by controlling authority and having binding legal effect
who determines whether a law has “binding legal effect”?
judicial review
how are laws made?
- legislation: congress/state legislatures/ city and county governing bodies
- court decisions
- initiatives by the people
- regulations by government agencies
U.S. law is based on…
the English Common Law
What is common law?
use of case law as precedent
federalism
constitution as the foundation of all US laws
Stare Decisis
mandate that Inferior courts follow decisions of superior courts
-provides stability and predictability to legal system
alternate references for term common law: case law, court law, unwritten law
what is federalism?
a govt consisting of a union of more or less self-governing states under an umbrella of federal government
stare decisis
the common law doctrine that binds an inferior court to follow and apply decisions and interpretations of higher courts when similar cases arise.
Precedent
a court deicions on a question of law that gives authority or direction on a similar question of law in a later case with similar facts
Brown V Board of Education
in 1954 the US supreme court decided that maintaining separate schools for black and white children was unconstitutional.
–Equal Protection Clause of the fourteenth amendment to the constitution.
Statutes
laws enacted by congress or by state legislatures
Doctrine of Supremacy
swhenever state or local governments and the United States enact conflicting laws on the same subject, the federal law will prevail.
Judicial activists (or “activist” judges)
judges whose judicial philosophy includes treating the law as a vibrant and active source of rules. When faced with new issues, such judges are likely to see the constitution as a flexible document and stare decisis as challengeable when they believe important social needs must be addressed.
“Strict constitutionalist” judges
judges whose reading of the law narrowly interprets legal words and who subscribe to interpreting the law consistent with the believed meaning given it by the drafters.
Initiatives
law-making by the people
citizens can place proposed new laws on the ballots for direct vote by the people
Civil Law
the body of law, both federal and state, that pertains to civil or private rights enforced by civil actions.
examples: laws governing contracts
- individual right and duties and their enforcement
Criminal law
the body of statutory law, both federal and state, that declares what confuct is criminal and prescribes penalties for its commission.
-deals with crimes and their punishments
Private Law
the body of law regulating the rights and duties that exist between private persons (including private corporations)
-Example: contract law
Public law
the body of law directly concerned with public rights and obligations, such as constitutional, administrative, criminal, and international law
Ethics
standards of fair and honest conduct applied to social behavior
Morals
values concerning right and wrong
Procedural law
general principles and detailed rules that define the methods of administering substantive law.
-Example: dictates the dates and time limits within which papers must be filed, the size of paper used by attorneys, the size of the print to be used, what info must be contained in legal papers, how witnesses and parties can be orally examined before trial, etc.
Substantive Law
General principles and detailed rules that define legal rights and duties.
-Example: prohibits murder, requires a real estate agent to be licensed, and imposes speed limits and registration requirements on automobile drivers.
Concurring opinion
a written opinion wherein a judge agrees (concurs) with the result reached by another judge, but for different reasons from those stated by the other judge.
Dissenting opinion
a written opinion by a judge or judges who vote(s) contrary to the majority opinion and holding of the court
The Equal Protection Clause has the Fourteenth Amendment has been a useful tool for people attempting to reduce discrimination in this country. True or False?
True
Appellant or petitioner
the party who appeals to a higher court for review of a lower court ruling
Appellee or respondent
the party who, on appeal, defends the earlier court determination
Federal Law
- national in origin
- consistent with constitution
- supreme over state law
- exclusive in international affairs
- multiple sources of federal law
State Law
- ordinary affairs of citizens including most contract, tort, and criminal law
- multiple sources of state law
International Law
governing relations between sovereign nations
Domestic Law
Law of a particular sovereign nation
How do courts make laws?
The principle of Stare Decisis
- Latin term meaning “to stand by decided cases”
- treating these cases “precedent”
- application of doctrine in typical situations
Variables to consider when applying stare decisis:
- jurisdiction issues (which court, which state?)
- identity or similarity of facts
- currency
- ——change in cultural values
- ——change in scientific knowledge
Plessy v. Ferguson
Plessy attempted to sit in an all-white railroad car after refusing to sit in the black railway carriage car. Was arrested in 1890 Louisiana for violating a statute that provided for segregated “separate but equal” railroad accommodations
- Thirteenth Amendment Issue
- Plessy lost the case
-BUT, the case was later overruled by Brown v. Board of Education
Brown v. Board of Education
- Justice Warren wrote the opinion for a unanimous court, holding that separate facilities which segregate based on race are inherently unequal.
- segregation unconstitutional under the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment
Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission
reversed the ban on electioneering communications, and also prior court decisions restricting “independent” contributions to campaigns.
The Tillman Act [1907]
Corporations may not donate directly to political candidates.
but…
Corporations found loopholes to funnel money though.
-courts and congress attempted to limit corporations’ influence on elections, but courts recognized corporations’ First Amendment rights to free speech.
The Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act of 2002
corporations could not publish “electioneering communications” within certain blackout periods.
Business and Free Speech
U.S. First Amendment freedom of speech
- most highly valued!
- have to examine on an individual basis
- commercial speech (advertisements)
- political statements by corporations (public issues)
- usually allowed : corporations are persons , treated as individuals who have free speech
-UNLESS: compelling state interest to prohibit (i.e. public safety or health)
In 1791 the first 10 amendments were ratified by the States. These are called…
The Bill of Rights
How are constitutional amendments made?
1) a proposed amendment must be passed by 2/3 vote in the House and Senate
2) then ratified by 3/4 of state legislatures OR
3) may be proposed by 2/3 of state legislature by calling for a constitutional convention
- —this must be ratified by 3/4 of state legislatures
The Defense of Marriage Act
Marriage being the bond between a man and a woman
Affirmative Action
Once used to help minorities (i.e. schools accepting a certain proportion of diff races) but this led to the idea of reverse racism
Indiana Religious Freedom Restoration Act
- Early 1990s: US supreme court ruled that an employer could fire employees who participated in a religious ritual (using peyote) if action doesnt explicitly favor or target a religion
- Federal Religious Freedom Act of 1993: govt may substantially burden the free expression of religion if dong so accomplishes a “compelling governmental interest” and is the “least restrictive means” of doing so
The Commerce Clause
- Congress has power to “regulate commerce w/foreign nations and among the several States and w/the Indian tribes”
- deals with “interstate commerce”
- state laws cannot interfere with federal commerce, federal law prevails
Katzenbach v. McClung
Principles of the case:
Family owned restaurant in Alabama argued it could segregate between customers. It argued that Federal law didnt apply to them.
-however, 1964 Civil Rights Act prohibits racial segregation in public accommodations if serving interstate travelers of if food moved in interstate commerce
Wickard v. Filburn (1942)
Commerce Clause Violation
- Ohio wheat farmer decides to keep some bushels of wheat for home use, fed law states that it affects the market prices of wheat, thus violating the commerce clause
- although one farmer doing this seems small and trivial, all small farmers together would impact “interstate” commerce and “market conditions”
- Congress may regulate all production
True or False? Almost all commerce is defined as “interstate”.
True.
Very broad, Congress may regulate all production
Necessary and Proper Clause
Power “to make all Laws which shall be necessary and proper for carrying into Execution the foregoing Powers…
- the power with the commerce clause provides BROAD congressional control of commerce
- most laws are necessary and proper
Federal Supremacy: The Supremacy Clause
if theres a state law that interferes with Federal law, Federal law prevails (state law become invalid)
EX: McCulloch v. Maryland
McCulloch v. Maryland (1819)
Maryland wanted to regulate National Bank
-NO. Violates Supremacy Clause
Can Congress establish a National Bank?
Yes, it is constitutional under the Necessary and Proper Clause, which EXPANDS, not restricts, Congress’s powers
Hughes v. Oklahoma
A state law that prohibited the transportation of minnows outside the state violated the Commerce Clause of the United States Constitution (Constitution).
Synopsis of Rule of Law. It is a violation of the Commerce Clause for states to enact laws that attempt to conserve natural resources for use by their own residents.
The Hughes Test
1) does statute regulate evenhandedly with only “incidental” effects on interstate commerce?
2) does statute serve a legitimate local purpose? if so,
3) could alternative means promote this local purpose as well without discriminating against interstate commerce?
Example: Fine to protect wildlife, but could be done in a less discriminatory way (against interstate commerce) by the state
What is the Fed. govts’ major income source?
Income Taxes!
Taxing Power
congress has the power to “lay and collect taxes”
- taxes used to raise revenue and/or deter/punish/encourage certain behavior
- Supreme Court: “the power to tax includes the power to destroy”
Which Amendment gave the Fed gov. the power to impose income taxes?
the 16th amendment
State Taxation
State taxes cannot impede interstate and international commerce
i.e. Goldberg v. Sweet
Goldberg v. Sweet
Illinois can tax long-distance calls or from the state unless taxpayer can show that another state has billed the call; if so, then the IL tax is refunded. Did not violate commerce clause.
Goldberg v. Sweet Tests: Constitutionality of State Taxes
1) the tax applies to an activity having substantial nexus with the state
2) the tax is fairly apportioned to those inside and outside the state
3) it does not discriminate against interstate commerce
4) it is fairly related to services provided by the state
What is a court?
a NEUTRAL forum authorized and funded by government (our taxes) to provide for the resolution of disputes between people and organizations
Trial Courts
- presentation of evidence
- determination of applicable law
- application of decided facts to applicable law
- jury, finder of fact. judge determiner of law and instructions to jury
Liability versus Guilty
liability= civil cases, responsibility to pay money guilty= criminal cases, punishment
Appellate Courts
- review of trail court record to ensure proper application of the law
- acceptance of the facts offered in trial court, no new evidence presented and no jury presented
When does a case get taken to Appellate court?
- when there is a bias as a result of courtroom conduct.
- attorneys argue here why the law should be interpreted in a way that favors their client
What is the purpose of an appellate court?
- affirm
- reverse
- remand the case back down to trial court and make them do it all over again.
Judicial Review
doctrine= review laws by congress
Brief
facts of the case, but in a way most beneficial to your client
-critical arguments
Oral Argument
arguing in front of the court
U.S. Supreme Court (highest appeals court)
- appointed by the executive branch
- 9 justices
- appointed for life
- may refuse to hear a case
- final authority
- supreme court takes up only the cases the justices want to hear. Need 4/9 vote to hear the case
Washington is part of which circuit?
the 9th circuit
Jurisdiction
the “power to speak the law”
- when used in reference to the courts, term refers to power and authority over a matter
- political boundaries of state and federal courts
Where is the only place laws are created?
Appellate courts, “stare decisis”
in personam
power over the person
examples:
-contract was breached
-if you did business in WA , drive a car, etc., theres long arm statute to be tried in the state
in rem
power over a thing
-usually property or a relationship
Jurisdiction and the Internet. Zippo case.
three rules to know:
- Passive websites: make info available, reading only
- Interactive websites: more interactive and commercial, greater chances that the courts will say they have jurisdiction over the case.
- commercial websites: contracts, knowing and repeated transmission of computer files
Early Steps in a civil lawsuit- pleading by plaintiff
- complaint
- summons
- service of process (obtaining jurisdiction)
- reply if necessary
Early Steps in a civil lawsuit- pleading defendant
- answer
- demurrer or motion to dismiss
- cross-complaint or counter-claim
Deposition
questioning of parties and witnesses under oath
Motion to Produce
request for documents and things
request for admissions
request of opposing party to agree on certain facts
-helps narrow the scope of inquiry
Interrogatories
- written questions to the opposing party requesting written answers
- this procedure is abused, people bombard each other with piles of paperwork
Civil cases require ____ out of 6 votes of jurors for a jury agreement.
5
Problems with the adversary system
- access to the system
- may take years for a problem to be resolved
- the courts are clogged
- are the results always fair?
inquisitorial system
- counter system to adversarial system
- judge can investigate the dispute, question witnesses, and independently seek out evidence
- although attorneys still necessary in countries with such systems, the lawyers end up playing a less crucial role to the administration of justice
Attorney-at-law
aka lawyer
- a person authorized by law to represent persons (clients) in legal matters
Fiduciary Relationship
- a position of trust undertaking to act for the benefit of another
- must exercise the utmost good faith, honesty, and fairness toward client
Attorney-Client Privilege
- purpose is to encourage full and open disclosure
- rule of evidence protects all communications between a client and his or her attorney from disclosure in a legal proceeding
- attorney cant be compelled by stature or court to reveal such info except in a few narrow circumstances
- client but not the attorney may waive the privilege
What is an engagement letter?
terms and conditions for when you are hiring an attorney
Pro bono publico
helping those who could not otherwise afford a lawyer
What are the 3 branches of the federal govt?
THE SEPARATION OF POWERS
- Congress (legislative–enacts laws)
- Executive (president– enforces laws)
- Judicial (supreme court, lower courts–reviews laws, resolves ambiguities)
Concurrent authority
when state law is more restrictive, its law applies as long as doing so enables federal compliance (e.g. state minimum wages)
Federal Preemption
When it is clear that the U.S. congress only wants federal regulation in a general area, it will strike down state law, even if it doesnt conflict
Example: Interstate commerce
The Police Power
the inherently regulatory power of the state to pass laws to protect the public health, safety, welfare, and morals of the community
The Bill of Rights
- protects citizens against the federal govt.
- comprised of the first 10 amendments
- extended to the state via the 14th amendment (key amendment that expands the right)
The First Amendment
freedom of speech, press, right to assembly, right to petition for redress, separation of church and state, and right to free exercise of religion
Corporate Political Speech
-corporations are treated as persons
-therefore, corporate political speech is treated the same way as individuals political speech
REASONS:
-“no taxation without representation”- corporations are taxpayers
-corporations are not capable of voting
-CPS does not threaten individuals