Methods for assessing nutritional status Flashcards
Topic 2 on moodle
Why would public health be interested in dietary assessment?
to evaluate the adequacy and safety of the food people eat
Why would dietary assessment be important from a clinical prospective?
To assist in diagnosis and treatment of diet related diseases
Why is dietary assessment important of research?
to study associations between food intake and disease
Why is it difficult to assess habitual diet?
Because diet varies so much depending on life stage, season, work or health and there is not a method that can measure diet without error
What does a reliable method mean?
when you repeat the experiment the repeated results will all be close to each other.
What does an accurate measure mean?
how close the measured result is to the actual result
What does a valid measure mean?
how good the method is at actually measuring what it is meant to measure
What is the problem with looking at domestic food production in dietary assessment?
no country is completely self-sufficient so looking at domestic food report alone will not be fully representative of national diet.
Who produces the food balance sheet?
the Food and Agricultural Organisation of the United Nations Statistics Division (FAOSTAT)
What is the food balance sheet?
It can provide a complete and comprehensive picture of the pattern of a countries food supply. Food produced plus food imported, minus food exported then adjust for any changes in stocks will give you a total that can be divided by the number of people in the population to give a per capita supply figure that is representative of nation diet.
How can you look at household food purchases?
by utilising the National Food survey (NFS) organised by the Ministry for Agriculture, Fisheries and Food (MAFF)
How does the national food survey work?
by getting one person in the house to collect info on foods purchased over a 7-day period.
What was the National Food Survey renamed to?
Living Cost and Food Survey (LCF)
What does the Living Cost and Food Survey (LCF) involve?
a comprehensive household questionnaire, individual questionnaire for each adult over 16, a personal expenditure diary kept by everyone over 2 weeks and a simplified diary kept by children aged 7-15.
What are the prospective methods for looking at individual food consumption?
Food diaries and chemical analysis of duplicate diets
What are the retrospective methods for looking at individual food consumption?
diet history, FFQ and 24-hour recall.
What 4 things do you need to carry out a food diary?
Record books, scales, personnel to collect the data and a computer analysis package
What should you tell or not tell participants completing a food diary?
Stress that is is usual diet that is being looked at and do not say what nutrient is being looked at
What is the most accurate method of dietary assessment in free-living individuals?
Food diary
How can food diary validity be improved?
by randomising study days across a variation of conditions to help eliminate bias. For example, a mix of week days and weekends, different seasons and different stages of the menstrual cycle.
How can reliability of food diary be improved?
By increasing the number of days it is carried out for
What are the limitations of using a food diary?
It is unsuitable for those who find it difficult to write and it requires a high degree of cooperation
Why might volunteers to record a food diary not be representative of the whole population?
Those who volunteer may be more health or diet conscious
What is good about using a food diary?
It doesn’t rely on memory or errors in estimating portion size
What are some of the errors associated with using a food diary?
coding errors (misreading someone’s dietary input), variation of intake over time and people altering their diet due to the diary
How can you find out food diary under-reporters?
use doubly- labelled water to measure EE and compare that to the EI from the food diary and when you have taken into consideration any changes in weight you can find any under-reporters.
How does chemical analysis of duplicate diet work?
subjects weigh and record food consumption at time of eating and put aside a duplicate portion that gets sent into a lab to be specially analysed for energy and nutrient content
What is good about chemical analysis of duplicate diet?
avoids errors associated with food tables (exact food not being found there or substitutes with different nutrient profiles needing to be used)