MEE Criminal Procedure Flashcards
4th Amendment
People should be free from unreasonable search and seizures.
Exclusionary rule
All warrantless searches conducted by law enforcement officers are unconstitutional unless under exceptions.
ESCAPES
ESCAPES: Exigent circumstances, search incident to arrest, consent, automobile, plain view, evidence from administrative warrant, stop and frisk.
Search Incident to a lawful arrest
warrant exception
(1) After a valid arrest, police can search, (2) police can make a protective sweep of area (person and the areas within the person’s reach), (3) search must be contemporaneous in time and place with arrest.
* If arrest is unconstitutional, then search incident to that arrest is unconstitutional as well.
Automobile arrest
warrant exception
Police may search passenger compartment incident to arrest if: (a) arrestee is unsecured and may gain access to vehicle, OR (b) police reasonably believe evidence of offense for which person was arrested may be found.
(Gant rule: Police can’t get to the trunk, only passenger compartment.)
Search incident to incarceration or impoundment
warrant exception
police may make an inventory search of arrestee belongings, and of an impounded vehicle. (Can search any containers contained within the vehicle)
Automobile Exception
warrant exception
Police may search the whole vehicle, including trunk, if PC to believe the car contains evidence of a crime, and any container that may had the item for which PC to search. (probable cause)
* Car may be tow and search later, unless car is in a curtilage (driveway of a suspect’s home).
* If believed that car itself is contraband, may seized it in a public place without a warrant.
* Passenger belongings – Search may extend to packages belonging to a passenger.
* If PC only in a specific container, may not search the rest. (e.g. luggage recently placed in a trunk)
Plain View:
warrant exception
Evidence of a crime is immediately apparent & PC. Police officer must be legitimately in premises.
Consent
warrant exception
Must be voluntary. Search may be limited by the scope of the consent.
* Persons with apparent equal right to use or occupy property may consent.
* If 2 persons living there and are present, and one objects, no valid consent.
* If co-occupant is removed for unrelated reason, police may act on consent of remaining occupant. (e.g. removed by a lawful arrest)
Stop & Frisk:
warrant exception
(1) Reasonable suspicion of criminal activity, (2) may conduct a protective frisk if officer believe the person may be armed and presently dangerous. (weapon or contraband).
* Officer may seize any item that he believes, based in plain feel, is a weapon or contraband.
* If PC arises during investigatory stop, detention may become an arrest, and then can conduct a full search under the exception of search incident to arrest.
evanescent evidence, emergency aid and hot pursuit
warrant exception
(1) evanescent evidence: Evidence might disappear quickly if police took time to get a warrant.
(2) Hot pursuit: If fleeing felon, police may make warrantless search and seizure and may pursue suspect into private dwelling.
Rule of thumb – If not within 15 minutes by the fleeing felon, not hot pursuit.
(3) Emergency aid/ community taker: if officer faces emergency that threatens health or safety
Public schools searches allowed if:
reasonably grounds necessary. (1) offers moderate chance of finding evidence of wrongdoing, (2) measures reasonably related to search objectives, (3) searches not excessively intrusive in light of age and sex of student and nature of infraction. (e.g. smoking in school grounds).
Wiretapping and eavesdropping needs warrant, exception:
(1) unreliable ear, persons assumes risk other person consents to gov monitoring or is an informer, (2) uninvited ear, no 4th amend claim if no attempt to keep conversation private.
5th Amendment (confessions)
The 5th Amendment protects against coerced self-incrimination by the government. privilege against compulsory self-incrimination, double jeopardy, Miranda Warnings.
6th Amendment (trial related)
right to speedy trial, public trial, trial by jury, confront witness, compulsory process for obtaining, right to counsel.
8th Amendment
Prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment, and excessive fines
14th Amendment
Due Process Clause
Seizure
define
reasonable person would feel they are not free to leave
Arrest
police takes a person into custody for prosecution or interrogation
Reasonable expectation of privacy? Standing
unreasonable search and seizure
- Reasonable expectation of privacy: with respect to the place or item seized.
Standing: (1) should be owned or had a right to possession, (2) person’s home, (3) overnight guest of owner to the place searched.
Informational roadblocks are constitutional if:
(1) must stop cars on basis if neutral, articulable standard, (2) designed to serve purpose closely related to problem pertaining to cars and their mobility. (e.g. DUI checkpoint)