Medicine Through Time Flashcards
What was medicine and public health like in Britain before the Romans in summary?
- The Ancient Greeks had developed an explanation for ill health based on the idea that it was caused by an imbalance in a person’s Four Humours. Treatment could be based on changes in diet, and encouraging the patient to exercise and take rest. However, treatment could also be bloodletting or purging by letting out excess humour.
- Many people relied on religion, by praying and carrying charms, herbal remedies were also used.
What was medicine and public health like in Britain after the Romans came?
- In 1347, the Black Death arrived in Europe and approximately one third of the population died.
- The understanding of disease was very limited and people continued to base their treatments around Galen’s ideas. But discoveries in the 16th and 17th centuries began to improve the understanding of the body.
When did the Romans conquer Britain?
43AD
Why did the Romans become interested in improving public health but less interested in what caused disease?
They relied on healthy citizens for trading and farming therefore they needed a healthy empire however they thought that it was unnecessary to know about what caused disease.
What did Romans bring with them which lead to major improvements in public health?
They brought a system of government which brought:
- Access to clean water
- Sewage systems
- Public baths
The Romans put emphasis on hygiene and fitness which meant that fewer people stood a chance to get ill.
Even though the Romans brought new ideas to improve public health, there was a lot of continuity in treatment. What was still carried on?
- The use of Galen’s ideas such as bloodletting
- Herbal remedies
- Praying and charms
Why didn’t the Romans help all citizens?
As treatments such as bloodletting which may have been the most sophisticated out of all the treatments was only done if you were able to afford for a physician.
What increased the chance of disease?
More and more people moved into the towns, making them more crowded and therefore disease spread quicker.
As soldiers moved from country to country, there was a more likely chance of a pandemic adding to the chances of an epidemic.
Overall what was the effect of the Romans?
They bought many changes to public health which lead to healthier people and an increased life expectancy however due to very little progress in treatment and medical understanding your chances of survival were no greater than before. Bloodletting was only afforded by the wealthy so not everyone’s health improved.
Who influenced Roman medicine and what did he believe?
Hippocrates
He believed that disease wasn’t sent by God but had a physical, rational basis and therefore can be treated
What was Hippocrates’ main ideas?
- A doctor should respect life and if he did not know how to treat something, he should not try anything harmful
- He developed The Theory of the Four Humours as an explanation for disease. If there was an excess of a humour it needs to be let out to prevent or cure an illness.
- He developed the Clinical Observation
What does the Clinical Observation state?
- Study the patient’s symptoms and ask about how this illness had developed
- Make notes and use knowledge from similar cases to predict what would happen next.
- Once the predictions are accurate, correctly diagnose the illness and treat it, preferably through diet, exercise and rest
What were the Four Humours?
Four different liquids of the body
- Blood
- Phlegm
- Yellow bile (sick)
- Black bile (blood in vomit)
What did each humour represent?
(Refer to diagram and pic)
How does the Four Humours identify when a person is suffering from illness?
The humours will become imbalanced.
When did Claudius Galen work in Rome?
2nd century AD
What did Galen develop?
Using the Four Humours he developed the Theory of Opposites, eg. if you had a cold you should eat hot peppers
How did Galen develop knowledge on how the body works?
By doing dissections on animals.
Overall, what was Galen’s impact on medicine?
Many of his ideas were based on Hippocrates therefore there was a lot of continuity. He did dissections of animals and developed knowledge on anatomy however as it was on animals his findings weren’t entirely accurate. Due to him boasting about perfecting Greek ideas, he developed the reluctance in believing in new ideas in people to discover further in medicine.
What were Romans ideas on the causes of disease?
- It was a supernatural reason; God has given a punishment for someone’s sin
- Bad air from swamps and other places with bad smells (they realised that hygiene was linked to health but didn’t know why)
- Caused by an imbalance of the Four Humours
What did the Romans do when they needed treatment?
There were very few doctors therefore the majority was treated at home within the family. The wealthy who were able to afford a doctor would be treated at home too. There were a few hospitals but they were assigned to the wounded and injured soldiers. They were well equpped and provided excellent training for physicians and surgeons. However, very few hospitals were open to the public so they would have had very little impact on ordinary lives.
Many visited temples to offer prayers to God and often consulted with a priest. They also went to public baths as they believed that they had healing properties.
Pregnant women relied on other women to help them with child birth. Some women were very experienced and were used as midwives.
Overall what were medical treatments and ideas like during the Roman era?
There were various supernatural as well as rational ideas about the causes of disease. Threatments were also a mix of supernatural and practical. A variety of people treated the sick but only a few used trained doctors as there were very few of them and they were expensive.
What did Romans notice about disease?
That disease seemed to increase if you lived near bad smelling places such as swamps and therefore started building in much cleaner, and hygienic places. They believed in the theory of miasma (bad air causes disease) and also recognised a link between dirt and disease however could not explain it. They stressed on removing sewage and cleanliness.
Was admission free to enter public baths?
No
What were the functions of public baths?
- Social - places for people to meet for pleasure and discuss businesses.
- Hygiene - people kept clean here
- Exercise - they provided places for people to keep fit
- Medical - they believed that the water had healing powers so they visited regularly to get cured
What did people do at public baths?
- Before going to the baths, both men and women would do exercise.
- Public toilets were less private than nowadays but waste was removed by the sewage systems and people washed hands with clean hands.
- Baths came in various warm temperatures and oil massages were given and dirt was scraped off.
- After having a warm bath, people will have a dip in a cold one.
How were complex water systems used to transport water to towns and homes?
- Fresh water form springs in the hills were transported to towns via pipes and aqueducts
- Water was stored in reservoirs near towns
- Pipes carried water from these reservoirs to public wells, baths, fountains or private houses of the rich.
What were the set backs of the sewage systems?
Although the piped water and sewers were impressive and enabled people to stay healthy and prevent disease, in most towns there were open drains and when water supply was low there wasn’t enough sewers to work properly therefore waste built up and made disease more likely.
What were the three main factors which made public health important?
- Government
- Army
- Communications
How did government help with public health?
- They made the central decisions
- Organised large-scale projects
- Raised taxes to pay for projects and provided the manpower to carry them out
How did the army help with public health?
- They needed a good standard of public health
- They had soldiers from all over the empire who brought different ideas and extra manpower
- During peacetime, they built roads, baths, sewers .etc
How did communications help with public health?
- Good quality roads made travel which meant that communications were easier and quicker across the empire.
- Central control from Rome and regular changes of officials kept Britain up-to-date with new ideas.
- Knowledge and ideas spread as people travelled throughout the empire.
What was the period with huge chaos after the Romans left?
410AD to 1000AD
What happened after the Romans left?
- Loss of the Roman army
- Loss of one ruler or government
- Wars and chaos
What happened with the loss of army?
- No one to maintain law and order amongst the locals.
- No engineers or builders to keep the public health systems in towns running
- No one to stop invasions
What happened with the loss of one ruler or government?
- No control to commission or pay for public health schemes to be built or maintained.
- New rulers used money to expand kingdoms therefore didn’t use time or money for public health systems and education.
What happened with wars and chaos?
- Led to destruction of towns therefore libraries and books got destroyed.
- Became more dangerous to travel so ideas and people did not spread.
- As people’s possessions and crops got destroyed poverty increased.
What was the impact on medicine and public health when the Romans left?
Public health systems were destroyed by war and many left the towns. When towns started gradually growing back again, they became far more unhygienic therefore a more likely chance for a spread in disease. Also, trained physicians began to disappear as:
- Books and libraries with medical knowledge had been destroyed
- New rulers were illiterate and weren’t interested in educating doctors
- People no longer travelled far to obtain knowledge from elsewhere
- An huge increase in poverty meant that no one was able to afford for a trained physician
When did Christianity’s importance increase?
After the Norman invasion when the Roman’s left in 1066
What was England like when Christianity had grown?
- Christianity affected all over Europe
- Most priests were literate and senior churchmen were included among the king’s advisors
- Learning was preserved in libraries of monastries and convents
- Monastries and convents had an infirmarian who cared for the sick
- people were strongly into religion and accepted the Church’s authority over their lives
- Illness was a punishment from God
Which were the two biggest changes between 50 and 1350?
The decline of public health systems and the growth of the importance of Christianity
What period is known as the Middle Ages or the Medieval?
Between the ancient world and modern world
What was treatment in the Middle Ages like compared with the Romans?
No big change as the Romans did not develop any understanding in disease and people in the Middle Ages took the idea of local herbs and praying to local Gods from the Romans and using trial and error, remembered successful remedies and repeated using them eventhough they did not know how they workes. For instance, honey. Most remedies were passed down by word of mouth but some were written in Leechbooks.
What was the impact of religion and superstition on the Middle Ages?
People would say prayers and give offerings to God and may go on a pilgrimage to the holy shrine. Many may carry lucky charms or carry out a superstitious ritual. Scholars used astrology and linked it with the four humours eg. when to do treatments.
What did richer people get treated by during the Middle Ages?
Physicians used Galen’s ideas such as bloodletting and also used herbs.
What were the biggest health problems in towns caused by during the Middle Ages?
- Lack of clean water - latrines(toilets) were built over rivers where people got their water from
- No sewage removal - it remained in open drains and rivers
- The remains of butchered animals were left on streets and attracted rats.
Why was London so unhygienic during the Middle Ages?
- Lead pipes had leaks which contaminated water
- Animal and human excrement on streets, butchered animals, no rubbish removal which attracted rats
Why did the laws have limited affect during the Middle Ages?
As the systems weren’t developed well
What were some of the attempts made to improve hygiene in towns during the Middle Ages?
- In 1281 pigs were prevented to enter the streets
- In 1347 the Sanitary Act tried to keep streets cleaner.
- In 1388 a parliamentary statute complained about the filth.
On the other hand, how was hygiene like for the rich and others?
The rich had private latrines and lead pipes with a water supply and would bathe in a wooden tub.
Monks and nuns had fresh water piped to the buildings and latrines were built over running water.
What happened after the town councils realised the importance of public health in the 15th century?
London, Exeter and Bristol had supplies of fresh water running through pipes in some areas. There were also large baths called stewes which worked like large wooden tubs.
Overall what was public health like in the Middle Ages compared to the Roman era?
In Roman times, the government provided a good standard of public health through the help of the army and taxes. It w’as different in the Middle Ages, there was little organised provision of water and sanitation. The rich weren’t affected as they afforded for a better quality of life, neither the peasants as they lived in villages which weren’t crowded. It was the poor in towns.
What were doctors like during the Roman era?
They weren’t respected as many of their treatments did not work. Many doctors were foreigners therefore the Romans thought that they were trying to take advantage of them. Doctors hated Galen as he criticised their old methods and was a foreigner.
How was a new doctor trained in the Ancient era?
- Alexandria in Egypt had a library which held medical knowledge from Egypt, Greece and India and was the main centre for medical training as people were allowed to dissect bodies.
- Many read books such as the Hippocrates Collection or worked with a successful doctor.
- Doctors were not examined and no organisation to follow up complaints against them.
- Anyone who wanted to be a doctor can just set up a business.
What were doctor’s treatments based on until the 12th century?
Roman medical knowledge, Christians monastries and convents turned into centres of learning and this is where later doctors gained their knowledge from.
What was medical training like from the 12th century onwards during the Middle Ages?
Some works which were studied were written by Muslim scholars. By the 13th century, people could be doctors if they were able to prove that they completed several years of study.
Education and training was now controlled by the Church which strongly believed in Galen’s ideas, this meant that change was slow in ideas and treatment. Medical training was based on reinforcing Galen’s ideas and students were not encouraged to study anatomy or look for mistakes in his teachings
Overall what was medical training like between the Roman period and early Middle Ages?
Nothing changed until the 12th century when trade increased and economy improved, increasing learning. Universities and medical schools began to be set up in monastries and convents and training was more focussed. However the level of knowledge and treatments did not change very much due to the reluctance to accept new ideas.
What were hospitals like during the Middle Ages?
Hospitals were run by monks and nuns as they believed that Jesus wanted his followers to care for the sick. As they believed that illness was a sign of a punishment from God they did not cure diseases but cared for them. Hospitals did not allow patients with infectious diseases or poeple who were in incurable conditions. However, the care which was given did actually make people get better. Food was grown, fresh fruit and vegetables and beds were positioned so that patients saw stained glass windows and religious statues to focus on religion. Some did not allow women unless over the age of 50 as they would distract patients
What were almhouses and when were they set up?
14th century and craed for the poor an old who were able to live under strict rules about behaviour and prayer.
What was the treatment for leprosy like during the Middle Ages?
Leper houses were places for lepers to live and during this time leprosy was incurable. They were kept apart from others and had to carry a bell to warn people to stay away. Care was only provided in these houses, similarly during the plague, pest houses were set up.
What was the role of religion on medicine and public health during the Middle Ages?
- Christianity became the main religion after the Romans left as the last emperor changed into a Christian making it an official religion.
- Controlled the training of physicians and preserved the ideas of Galen making it a source where you gained knowledge from.
- War destroyed other libraries, this was the only source.
- Affected the use of dissections not being allowed and not questioning Galen
- Prayers were said to get cured and the King’s Touch when a patient gets touched by the king he would cured.
- Care was given not treatment as illness was a punishment.
What was the role of government on medicine and public health during the Middle Ages?
- Once the Roman empire collapsed, the new kings focussed on expanding and protecting the people and empire from empire therefore had little to do with medicine.
- In the Roman era, the goverment funded and organised a good system of public health after the collapse, public health fell.
- As towns grew and public health became more important, local authorities began to become more active.
What was the role of war on medicine and public health during the Middle Ages?
- War caused the Romans to settle and they improved health and communications by bringing knowledge from Europe.
- A negative effect was that the fact that the Druids had a good understanding of using plants as herban medicines caused herbal remedies to be a major use.
- Once Romans left due to war, there was destruction to public works and people were less likely to travel and exchange knowledge therefore fewer chance of building knowledge and training.
What sort of information should a historian be looking for in a useful source?
- What sort of information does the source give and how relevant is it to the enquiry?
- Does the source have any added weight because of its origins or intentions? eg. does it come from a person who was involved in the event it describes or represents?
- If the source gives you only one example, can you assume it is representative of the wider situation? eg. would all doctors at the time have behaved in the same way?
What was medicine and public health like before 1350-1750 in summary?
- Beliefs about what caused disease and treatment changed very little since Roman times
- Roman’s public health system has collapsed and few attempts were made to improve it
- Church grew importance and controlled medical understanding and treatment
What was medicine and public health like after 1350-1750 in summary?
- It was not until the late 18thand 19thcenturies were there significant advances in the understanding of illnesses and a greater use of science and technology.
What was approximately the life expectancy in the 1350s?
30 years
Who had a better chance of a higher life expectancy?
- Rich
- People who did not do manual work
- Had better diets
What was death caused by?
illness, injury, poor living conditions and malnutrition
When was the Black Death?
1348-1350
How many people died during the Black Death?
Around 1/3 of the population
What did people believe caused the Black Death?
- God was testing to see if they stayed faithful Christians
- An unusual positioning of the planets
- Poisonous fumes from earthquakes and volcanoes
- Miasma
- An imbalance in the Four Humours
- Foreigners or witches
How did people avoid catching the Black Death?
- Carrying herbs to smell
- Carrying lucky charms
- Smelling bad smells
- Tidying rubbish from streets
- Lighting fire in room
- Ringing bells or keeping birds around the room to keep air moving
- Not letting people enter or leave areas
How did people treat the Black Death?
- Praying and holding lucky charms
- Eating cool things and taking cold baths
- Bloodletting/purging
- Draining the pus or cutting open buboes
- Holding bread against buboes and burning it in ground
What was the effect of ideas about the cause of the Black Death?
No effect at all as the ideas about treatment and prevention was inaccurate.
What was a trained physician like?
- He had trained in medical school and passed exams
- Will diagnose urine and use atrology
- Does treatments based on Galen’s ideas
- Expensive
- Gets medicines from apothecary
- Lets barber draw blood
- Male
What was an apothecary like?
- Trained using passed-down knowledge - no qualifications
- Makes own medicines
- Cheaper than physician
- Probably male
What was a barber-surgeon like?
- Bloodletting
- Does basic surgery
- No anaesthetics - surgeries are of low success rate
- Not trained or respected
What was a hospital like?
- Monastry or convent
- Cared for
- After reformation in 16th century, free hospitals were set up
What was a housewife-physician like?
- Knew traditional remedies for common illnesses eg. sore throats
- Deals with brpken bones and childbirth
- Uses charms, herbs and spells
What was a prayer and pilgrimage like?
Many people will go on a pilgrimage to a holy shrine looking for a cure
What was women and medicine like during the Middle Ages?
Most treatment was done by women at home, very few were also physicians however they weren’t allowed to attend universities which drove them out of the medical profession by 14th century. They continued as midwives but had to get a licence form their bishop to prove that they were of good character.
How much of change was there in treating the sick from the early Middle Ages?
Not much, in fact there was continuity due to Galen and the Church. The dominance of the Church continues therefore people still believed it was a punishment and therefore were only cared for. Education was still controlled with most collections of books being found in monastries. Medical schools taught Galen’s ideas and no one questioned them therefore physicians continued to base their diagnosis and treatment on the Four Humours.
How did health treatment vary for the rich and poor during the Middle Ages?
There were many different choices for the rich but very few for the poor. There were few new treatments as there were few new ideas about the causes of disease.
What is meant by the Renaissance?
Rebirth - it describes the period in European history when Ancient Greek and Roman ideas became fashionable again.
What other things happened during the Renaissance?
- European exploration in Africa and America led to new attitudes and a search for knowedge - new plants on new lands
- Reformation led to the decline in Church’s authority eventhough many stayed religious - reluctance to accept new ideas.
- There was a scientific approach of testing and recording details, questioning old ideas and sharing results with others.
How did the Royal Society in 1660 help with medical progress?
With King Charle II’s approval and support, the society had its own laboratory and latest scientific equipment so that members can experiment and show discoveries. They published regular accounts on ideas which helped spread ideas.
What were the new inventions during the Medical Renaissance?
- Pumps and clocks which helped people accept the idea that the body functions as a machine
- Leeuwenhoek developed better lenses for microscopes and discovered bacteria calling them animacules in a letter to the Royal Society in 1673.
- Most importantly, the printing press - copies of books and journals could be produced more quickly and cheaply in ordinary language (English) so that physicians could learn from each other.
What happened in 1543?
Andreas Vesalius, Professor of Durgery at Padua University published a book called The Fabric of the Human Body. This included drawings of muscles, nerves, organs and skeletons on the human body based on human dissections due to the Church losing its authority. Human dissections meant that Galen’s ideas were proved wrong.
What happened in 1628?
William Harvey also found errors in Galen’s ideas and published an explanation of his ideas in An Anatomical Account of the Motion of the Heart and Blood in Animals.
Name two ways (each) in which Harvey and Vesalius proved Galen wrong.
What was the impact of Vesalius and Harvey on medical treatment?
Both Vesalius and Harvey used the scientific method to investigate how the body works and this helped other physicians also begin using the scientific approach to diagnose and treat people. However it took over 40 years for Harvey’s ideas to be accepted by other doctors and be taught at medical schools as many were resistant to change and especially as most doctors still based their training around Galen’s ideas and did not carry out dissections themselves. Further, Vesalius’ and Harvey’s work was based on anatomy and physiology rather than the cause and treatment of disease therefore weren’t that relevant and had limited impact.
What was the impact of the Renaissance on doctors’ training?
- Improved technology eg. microsocopes, thermometers
- Improved knowledge on anatomy and physiology through Vesalius and Harvey
- Growing acceptance that physicians should carry out dissections themselves
- Introduction of some medical schools and teaching hospitals
- Growing importance of a scientific approach - observation of symptoms and experiment with treatments.
Why was John Hunter important in medical progress?
- His lectures on anatomy helped to develop a more professional approach towards medical training
- He emphasised the importance of the scientific method
- His students included Edward Jenner who followed his methods
- He hired people to write up notes and draw the discoveries he made through dissection
- He published important works such as about the changes which occurred in pregnancy
- He set up an own medical school with his brother which gave intense training