MD Flashcards
METAPHYSICS
study of what exists and how
Philosophy of mind focuses
-mind-body problem
-problem with consciousness
-desire, belief, emotion, intention
-can minds be uploaded into machines
axiology
study of value
-ethics, social and political philosophy, philosophy of art
methods of philosophy
-argumentation (evaluating inferences, interrogating implicit assumptions)
-analyzing concepts (conceptual clarification)
Philosopher’s argument
-consists of premises (uncontroversial truths) and a conclusion
-will either analyze logic of supporting arguments or search for opposing ones
-do not conduct empirical investigations, can use pre-existing ones
-do not need studies; just good arguments
John Searle, is mind a machine?
-Premise 1: computer programs are formal (syntatic)
-Premise 2: Human minds have mental contents (semantics)
-Premise 3: syntax by itself is neither constitutive of nor sufficient for semantics
-Conclusion: Programs are neither constitutive of nor sufficient for minds
-attempts to show that idea of minds being machines is inconsistent w/ generally accepted ideas
Thought experiments
-devices of imagination
-Mary the Colour Scientist (can colour be described to someone in a black-and-white world)
Linguistic analysis
-examining how a term is used
3 Methods of conceptual clarification
-intuition and thought experiments
-linguistic analysis
-conceptual reconstruction
Conceptual Reconstruction
-forcibly reconstructing a concept
The Pioneer
-first to tackle important issues that other disciplines (e.g., science) are unable to currently address
-e.g., problem with consciousness
The Building Inspector
-Questions overlooked assumptions of research era
-philosophical investigation demonstrated inadequacies of 1950s behaviouralism and proposed new principles
The Zen Monk/Tinkerer
Focuses on arcane but important issues, typically involving conceptual puzzles
The Cartographer
-Focuses on understanding and describing how the various elements of cognitive science interact
-produce large-scale conceptual maps; e.g., Haugeland, Artificial Intelligence: The Very Idea (1985)
The Archivist
-Tracks the history and development of ideas over time
The Cheerleader
-Backs research programs, explains their promise and significance, pushes forward their developments
Logic
-Study of correct reason
-examines structure of arguments
Inductive arguments
-Premises make conclusions more likely
Deductive arguments
-If premises are true, conclusions must also be true
-high validity, difficult to confirm; can be done via mathematical methods
Historical perspective
-philosophical way of approaching an issue, based on accumulated insights/arguments of philosophical history