MBE Flashcards
When do the rights of a donee beneficiary vest?
When the beneficiary materially changes position in justifiable reliance on the promise.
Can personal services contracts be delegated?
Not when the person performing has special skill.
What if a party knows about the delegation of a personal services contract and doesn’t object?
Party will have waived the nondelegability.
What is an accommodation?
It is a counteroffer by the seller. It is when the seller includes some conforming and some uncomforming goods along with a note explaining the noncomforming goods.
What if a merchant seller simply shipped noncomforming goods with no note?
Acceptance and breach of contract.
What if there is an agreement between merchants and no delivery term?
The UCC will “gap fill” with a delivery within a reasonable time.
Unilateral offer: what happens once performance has begun?
The offer cannot be revoked as to that performer. (woman buying groceries example)
What happens if a contract is written and contains an ambiguity, and one person knows of the ambiguity and the other person does not know about it?
The contract will be enforced according to the intent of the party who did NOT know about the ambiguity.
What if neither party knows of the ambiguity when the contract is formed?
No contract unless both parties meant the same thing.
Expectation damages:
putting the non breaching party in the position he would have been in had the contract been performed
Firm Offer requirements:
- offer for sale of goods
- merchant signs a written offer
- offer promises to leave open an offer for a stated time period
* irrevocable for stated period (max 3 months)
If there is a valid option contract, will a rejection by an offeree terminate the option?
NO. The offer only terminates at the end of the option period regardless of offeree’s conduct. (unless reliance by offeror)
What if there is a valid option contract and the offeree rejects the offer before the end of the option and the offeror detrimentally relies on this rejection?
This will extinguish the option.
When does Art. 2 of the UCC apply?
Applies: sale of goods
Does NOT apply: services, real estate, construction contracts
Who is a merchant?
One who REGULARLY deals in goods of the kind sold
Implied contracts
Formed by conduct
Quasi contracts or implied in law contracts
NOT contracts at all.
Construed by courts to avoid UNJUST ENRICHMENT
When will a contract be unilateral (2 situations)
- offer UNAMBIGUOUSLY indicates that completion of performance is the only manner of acceptance OR
- offer to the public (reward offer)
Creation of a contract: what three elements must be present?
- mutual assent
- consideration
- any defenses?
When is a contract void? What is the effect of a contract that is void?
A void contract is one that is totally WITHOUT ANY LEGAL EFFECT from the beginning.
Ex: an agreement to commit a crime
What to look for in an offer:
- intent to enter into a contract
- certainty and definiteness
- communication of the offer to the offeree
Offer must be definite: what is the key inquiry?
Whether the contract has enough terms to be capable of being enforced.
Standard for requirements contracts
good faith - not unreasonably disproportionate
How can an offer be terminated?
- lapse of time
- offeror revokes either by acting inconsistently with the offer or by expressly revoking
- offeree states that he will not accept
When does revocation become effective?
Upon receipt
When can an offer not be revoked?
- Reliance by the offeree that is reasonably foreseeable
- Valid options contract
- Unilateral contract and person has started performing
Common law: acceptance with additional terms
NO CONTRACT (mirror image rule)
UCC: acceptance with additional terms when one is a nonmerchant
Contract, but additional terms do not become part of it
UCC: acceptance with additional terms when both are merchants
Becomes part of the contract UNLESS
- material term
- nonmaterial and merchant objects w/in reasonable time
What if there are DIFFERENT terms with the acceptance?
Common law: this is a rejection (violates mirror image rule)
UCC: courts are split
- some courts: treat it like additional terms
- other courts: conflicting terms “knock out” each other out and UCC fills the gaps
When will death not terminate an offer?
- option contract
- part performance of offer to enter into a unilateral contract
Who can accept an offer?
Generally only the person to whom the offer is made.
Exception: an option contract can be assigned
General rule: when is acceptance effective?
When posted (mailbox rule)
Exceptions to the mailbox rule: what happens if rejection is mailed first, then letter of acceptance and rejection received first?
Letter of acceptance is a counteroffer
NO mailbox rule here
Exceptions to the mailbox rule: what happens if acceptance is mailed first, then rejection is sent and rejection is received first?
If offeror relied on letter of rejection before acceptance is received, estoppel may apply.
When must acceptance be received for an option contract?
Acceptance is when received (NO mailbox rule with option contracts)
Elements of consideration
- promisee must suffer some legal detriment
- detriment must induce reliance
- the promise must induce the detriment
*bargained for exchange
Moral obligation
Generally not a substitute for consideration.
2 possible exceptions:
- performed acts at the promisor’s request
- material benefit rule: promisor received a benefit and then promised to pay for it
Preexisting duty rule:common law
performance of a preexisting duty is NOT consideration
There must be consideration to modify
What if a promisor makes a promise and you owe the preexisting duty to a third person?
No preexisting duty, the new promise is enforceable
UCC rule for modifications
No consideration is required - good faith is required for modification
What happens if a debtor makes a partial payment in exchange for a promise to forgive balance of debt: is there consideration to make this an enforceable promise?
If debt is due and undisputed: part payment is NOT consideration
If debt is not yet due OR is disputed: part payment is consideration
When can a promise to dismiss a lawsuit or not bring a lawsuit be consideration?
When the party giving up the claim believes in GOOD FAITH that it is a valid claim.
What if debtor owed a debt but it is now barred by statute of frauds, but he again promises to pay?
A WRITTEN promise to pay a debt barred by the statute of limitations is enforceable.
Promissory estoppel elements
- promise
- reliance that is both foreseeable and justifiable
- enforcement necessary to avoid injustice
Who lacks capacity to contract (3 categories)
- infants
- mental incompetents
- intoxicated persons
*other party must have had REASON TO KNOW person was incompetent or intoxicated
What types of contracts are within the Statute of Frauds?
Marriage: promise in consideration of marriage
Year: can’t be performed within a year
Land contracts: leases or easements over a year, property
Executor promises to pay an obligation
Goods over $500
Surety
Modifications: what should you look at to determine whether the modification is within the statute of frauds
Look at the modified contract - if the contract as modified, is within the statute of frauds, it must be in writing
What happens if at common law there is a contract that says all modifications have to be in writing?
This won’t be enforced. Modifications at common law can be oral if they are not within statute of frauds.
UCC: what happens if the contract provides that all modifications must be in writing?
Under the UCC, these clauses are effective.
What contents must be in a contract other than the sale of goods?
- identify the parties
- identify the contract subject matter
- contain all essential terms
- signed by party to be charged
Part performance of an oral agreement to buy real estate
Possession + full or part payment
Improvements + possession
Sale of goods for $500 or more: what must the contract contain
- quantity
- contract for sale has been made
- signed by the party raising defense
Confirmatory memo: exception to statute of frauds
Use when there is an initial oral agreement.
- both parties are merchants
- writing claims that there is a contract
- writing signed and states quantity
ALSO binds recipient BUYER if:
- he has reason to KNOW of the confirmation’s contents AND failure to object in writing within 10 days of receipt
make sure it was sent within a reasonable time after the oral agreement
What if there is part performance of contract for sale of goods?
Part performance of a contract for the sale of goods satisfies the statute of frauds to the extent of part performance.
(can’t get the other part that fails statute of frauds)