Market failure and externalities Flashcards
Market failure
A price mechanism leading to an inefficient allocation of scarce resources, and a deadweight/welfare loss
Factors impacting market failure
Merit goods being underconsumed
Information failures/gaps
Demerit goods
Immobility of factor inputs
Monopolies(productively and allocatively inefficient)
Goods giving off negative externalities(consequences)
Examples of merit goods
:Give off positive externalities(are under consumed):
Vegan goods
Public libraries with books
Gym-healthcare
Education
Water
Why should an economy not be left to market forces?
There are certain goods(merit goods) that may not be provided for without government intervention(e.g. public transport, healthcare and education), as no profits are made from this
Quasi-goods
Goods actually provided by the market and government(e.g. health in the UK)
Example of non-excludable public goods
Police- can’t exclude everyone from benefitting from the presence of the police
Causes of labour market failure
Markets fail when they fail to reach a socially efficient/equitable outcome: tends to be corrected with government intervention-
Labour immobility
Disincentives to find work
Discrimination by employers
Monopoly/monopoly power by employers
Labour immobility
Occupational immobility - barriers to moving easily between jobs
Geographical immobility - barriers to changing location to find a new job
Disincentives to find/take work
The unemployment trap - where economic incentives to take a job are poor
The poverty trap - disincentives to earn extra income e.g. Luton are closing down motor manufacturers, leaving many people redundant(without jobs)
Discrimination by employers
This is a part explanation of the gender gap in pay and women in senior roles.
Discrimination badly affects wages and employment for affected groups
Monopoly/monopoly power of employers
They can use their “buying power” in labour market to drive down wages
Why do public goods cause market failure?
Due to the problem of missing markets
Main characteristics of public goods
- Non-excludability
- Non-rival consumption
- Non-rejectable
Non-excludability in public goods
Benefits derived from pure public goods cannot be confined solely to those who have paid for it
Free rider problem
Non-payers can enjoy the benefits of consumption at no financial cost to themselves
Non-rival consumption in public goods
Each party’s enjoyment of a good or service doesn’t diminish others’ enjoyment - the marginal cost of supplying a public good to an extra person is zero
Non-rejectable public goods
The collective supply of a pure public good for all means it can’t be rejected by people e.g. a national nuclear defence system. We get the government to help us through either a petition or a general election(who we want in a position of power, on the basis of what they can do).
Private good characteristics
- Excludable(allows for the enforcement of property rights and collection of payment)
- Rival consumption
- Rejectable
Pure punlic goods
Non-excludable and non-rival in consumption(goods usually provided collectively by the state)
Examples of quesi public goods
NHS, education(either non-rival or non-excludable, not both)
Examples of pure public goods
Reduced risk of disease from vaccinations
Crime control for a community
National parks
Purely private goods
Groceries, supplied by firms, which are all in the private sector
Solution/government intervention towards market failure
Public sector provision - doesn’t constitute nature of public good
Private goods
Goods owned by private individuals/firms/households, for their own benefit
Pricing and Profit
Private goods are typically priced in markets based on supply and demand, and consumers pay for what they consume. Private firms are the primary providers of these goods
Examples of private goods
Private gyms
Tickets to an event
Meals in a restaurant
Why are public goods financed by government?
- Non-excludability
- Economies of scale
- Public interest and equity
Non excludability: why are public goods financed by government?
Taxation ensures everyone contributes to the funding of public goods, preventing free riding and ensuring the costs are distributed across the entire population
Economies of scale - why are public goods financed by government?
Producing public goods for a larger population can lead to lower per capita costs. Taxation allows governments to collect funds from a broad tax base, which can be more cost-effective in providing these goods compared to private firms or individual transactions
Why are public goods financed by government - public interest and equity
Taxation allows governments to allocate resources based on societal priorities, and ensure public goods are provided in a way to promote societal welfare and equity
Government should seek to achieve:
Equity(fairness)
Efficiency
The government gives benefits and housing to the bottom of the income scale, as well as free school meals and free education
Case for higher state spending on public goods
Economies of scale: It’s more efficient to provide public goods at state level, leading to a lower long run cost per user - cheaper for consumers: greater allocative efficiency
Access and affordability: The absence of profit motive makes public goods affordable - this is important for equity
Investment:Public goods can lead to higher private sector investment e.g. regeneration of economically deprived areas attracting entrepreneurs
Public goods and technological change
- Advances in technology are blurring the distinction between some public and private goods and services.
- In some cases, encryption allows suppliers to exclude non-payers - although the product remains non-rival.
- Technological progress reduces the cost of smart-metering(a private good) used in road pricing - making roads more of a private(excludable) good
- The open source/Creative Commons movement has made much digital information a public good in nature(this information is non-rival and non-excludable).
Externalities
The unintended side effects or consequences of an economic activity or transaction that affect third parties who are not directly involved in that activity or transaction
Externalities
Spill-over effects from production and/or consumption for which no appropriate compensation is paid to one or more third parties affected e.g. Thames Water have been putting sewage in the waterworks in the country, but don’t pay to clean the sewage up
Key exam point
Externalities lie outside the initial market transaction, and without state intervention, they’re not reflected in the market price
Why are externalities inevitable?
- Inter-connectedness of Economic Agents
- Property rights and transaction costs
- Public goods
Inter-connectedness of Economic Agents
In a modern economy, individuals, firms and governments engage in a wide range of economic activities. These interactions often have ripple effects that extend beyond the immediate parties involved e.g. when a factory produces goods, it may emit pollutants into the environment, affecting neighbouring communities
Transaction costs
How much you pay when buying property
Property rights and transaction costs
Property rights are not always well-defined, and transaction costs can be high, making it difficult to negotiate and enforce agreements that internalize externalities e.g. people in flats may have free hold(owning the house plus the land built on), or lease hold(having ownership of the house, but not the land, meaning a tax must be paid to the freehold owner).
Public goods
Public goods, such as clean air, often cause positive externalities because they benefit everyone,whether they contribute to their provision or not. Individuals may underinvest in such goods, assuming others will bear the costs
Examples of negative production externalities
Factory pollution emissions
Examples of negative consumption externalities
Household waste, and air pollution
Examples of positive production externalities
Reforestation projects, the free-sharing of academic research