Margret

Question 1

Quote 1:
“It seems wrong to call her by a Christian name… What would they have called her at Stora-Borg, she wondered. Prisoner? Accused? Condemned? Perhaps it was the absence of a name, the silence where a name should be that they summoned her by.”

Answer 1

Argument:
Characterisation of Margret as skeptical towards Agnes suggests that when first confronted with an individual condemned and marginalised by society, it can be easier to abide by societal views and beliefs, ultimately perpetuating their dehumanisation.
Analysis:
o Listing of possible names “prisoner” “accused” and “condemned” – reflects the dehumanisation that Agnes faces in a society that defines her by her crimes. Margret, considering whether to call Agnes by these labels, demonstrates how she initially conformed to this inhumane view of Agnes, revealing the ease with which society’s prejudices can infiltrate personal perceptions.
o A name provides one with a sense of identity and value. Hence, the “absence” of a name, implying erasure and emptiness, strips away Agnes’ sense of individuality and humanity. Margret pondering whether Agnes deserves a name at all, reflects how she does not question this dehumanising behaviour and perpetuates the idea that Agnes is no more than a product of her crimes.

Question 2

Quote 3:
“I am right here, Agnes. You’ll be alright, my girl. My girl. ”

Answer 2

Argument:
Compassionate and empathetic relationships that validate one’s worth and foster an enduring sense of inclusion and acceptance, can provide a sense of belonging for marginalised individuals.
Analysis:
- “Here”, implying a sense of presence and support, creates a sense of stability and security for Agnes, signaling that she is not alone or forgotten. This implies that compassionate relationships can strengthen one’s sense of belonging by providing emotional grounding and a sense of connection, even in the face of adversity or isolation.
- Repetition of “my girl”- conveys a deep sense of care, affection, and belonging – makes Agnes feel as though she is included and accepted within the family, highlighting the profound impact that compassionate relationships can have in counteracting the isolation and neglect suffered by marginalised individuals within society.
- By addressing her directly by name, Margret demonstrates a personal connection and affirms Agnes’ humanity. Throughout the novel, Agnes is often dehumanized by society through labels like “criminal” or “murderess,” but Margret’s use of her name indicates that she sees Agnes for who she truly is, rather than just the accusations that define her, exemplifying how a relationship based on compassion rather than judgement can create
a sense of belonging.