Magic abd Society Flashcards
what vs. illusion
illusion: magicians specialize in illusion
- trickery and deception
what is magic
Magic: the ways in which a person can compel the supernatural to behave in certain ways
- rituals are important in order to get the supernatural to do their bidding
- magic can be used for Good or Bad
- the person who uses magic for bad is called a sorcerer and is considered anti social
- magic will always work
- it is something that is learned - but it can also be passed down
- religious specialists may use magic in their various activities (ex. healers may use magic to heal and individual)
- divination is closely related to magic (trying to gain information about the unknown)
is magic separate from religion: E.B. Tylor
- magic is separate from religion
- magic is a “primitive science”
- magic is not religion because no spirits are involved
- no correlation between the action and the outcome
is magic separate from religion: James Frazer
- magic is a “primitive science”
- evolutionary perspective - magic was there before religion
is magic separate from religion: Emile Durkheim
- agreed that magic can be distinguished from religion, but focused on social context
- magic focuses on “individual need” vs religion focuses on “collective need”
is magic separate from religion: Bronislaw Malinowski
- purpose of magic vs religion: purpose of magic different than purpose of religion
operant definition of magic
- broad enough to study magic as religion
- magic has a clear aim and the outcome is guaranteed when performed correctly
- magic is the “manipulation” of “supernatural forces”
- in religion, you can ask but may not receive
- religion is the “persuasion” of supernatural beings”
magic and science
science is based on empirical observations (using human senses)
- this means that for something to be scientific, it must be observable, repeatable, and testable
- sciences use hypothesis and theories
magic, like science, helps people to make sense of their world and have some element of control over things
- ex. farming
rules of magic (Frazer, 1890)
law of sympathy
- magic depends on the apparent association of agreement between things
Two parts:
1) law of similarity: things that are alike, are the same
- gives ruse to homeopathic/imitative magic
2) law of contagion: things that were once in contact continue to be, even after connection is severed
- gives rise to contagious magic
imitative magic
- assumes a causal relationship between things that appear to be similar (similarity can be physical or behavioural)
- imagine magic is a type of imitative magic: characterized by making an image to represent a living person/animal and the desired end
example: cave paintings, throwing darts at a picture of someone, vision boards
homeopathic magic (imitative magic)
homeopathic medicine or alternate medicine
- uses law of similarity
- doctrine of signature: belief that physical structures found in nature, potential use in healing (or overall health)
example: walnuts for the brain, carrots for the eyes, kidney beans for the kidneys
homeopathic magic: Beng women of the Ivory Coast, West Africa
pregnant women:
- cannot eat meat of the bushbuck antelope or her child will be born with stripes
- enemas using slippery leaves from a vine depict an easy childbirth
- carful of behaviours so as to not pass onto child
contagious magic
- magic that is based on the law of contagion, utilizing things that were once in physical contact with an individual
- the more personal the item, the more the connection
example: the Fore thinking Kuru was black magic against them, voodoo dolls (personal items sown into it), black magic in Mexico video
magic in society Azande (S. Sudan, Congo)
E.E Evans Pritchard (1920s and 30s)
- Zande magic involves objects made of plant material which are transformed into “medicines “ after ritual
- these “medicines” contain supernatural power
- doctrines of signature
- the medicine is used in ritual
- the medicine is more important than the spell, which simply wakes up the power in the medicine
functions: protection, control nature, revenge, curing diseases
- bad magic vs legally sanctioned magic
magic in society: the Fore
- the fore believed that Kuru was caused by sorcery
- sorcerer would use contagious magic to cause illness
- makes a bundle with leaves and the hair, nails, or excrement of the victim
- bury along with leaves in the muddy cold ground
- bets the bundle with a stick and calls the victims name
casting the spell: “I break the bones of your arm … and finally I make you die” - in Fore society people go out of their way to hide possible remnants