M2: Durkheim Flashcards
What three works will we look at to study Durkheim’s sociological theory?
- The Division of Labor in Society
- The Rules of Sociological Method
- Suicide
What does the book, ‘The Division of Labor in Society,’ explore?
-the transition from traditional society to modern society
What does Durkheim argue transition involves?
- an increase in social differentiation
- major change in the nature of morality
In what way did Durkheim agree and reject Spencer’s belief on the cause of the transition from traditional to modern society?
- he agreed with Spencer that the transition was caused by social differentiation
- however he said Spencer only got half of it;
- specialization occurs in all areas of life
What does Durkheim mean by morality?
- being solidified within a group and sharing interests, norms and beliefs
- a system of collective values and beliefs that guide peoples interactions
Did Durkheim believe morality was a property of society or the individual?
-society
What was Durkheim’s main concern in his book the Division of Labor in Society?
-the nature of social solidarity itself (what unites people together)
What is Durkheim’s answer to the second question?
-he is a positivist/naturalist
Can Durkheim actually study morality?
-no, he believes morality itself cannot be studied and must be operationalized (must use an external indicator)
What external indicator did Durkheim use to study morality?
-legal laws
What are legal laws?
-rule of conduct that are enforced through sanctions
What are the characteristics of traditional society?
- small, few parts
- segmental structure (independent and identical parts)
- low level of individualization
What did Durkheim believe held together traditional society?
-mechanical solidarity
What is mechanical solidarity?
- solidarity through the collective conscious
- based on resemblance and similarity
- shared values and beliefs hold society together
What are characteristics of modern societies?
- large, many diverse parts
- parts are interdependent
What does Durkheim believe holds together modern society?
-organic solidarity
What is organic solidarity?
- based on difference and interdependence in relations of exchange
- solidarity through the division of labour
- cult of the individual
What does Durkheim mean by the cult of the individual?
- as opposed to collective conscious
- consensual belief about dignity and worth of individuals
What question does Durkheim ask to account for the transition?
- focuses on question, ‘Do moral norms change as a response to changes in social conditions?’
- studies relationship between increase in differentiation and change in nature of morality
How does Durkheim document the transition?
-by examining development of systems of laws
Why does Durkheim use laws?
- positivist
- external indicator to study morality
- legal codes meet his criteria
How did Durkheim classify laws?
-by the sanctions they entail
What were the two types of laws Durkheim studied?
Laws with;
- repressive sanctions
- restitutive sanctions
Why did Durkheim use the word Organic to characterize modern societies?
-he wanted to show how these societies were like organisms, interdependent parts working together
What were laws with repressive sanctions?
- penal/criminal laws
- objective was to punish the person who broke the law
- demand retribution through punishment
What were laws with restitutive sanctions?
- civil, commercial, procedural, administrative, constitutional laws
- offender must make amends for what they have done
- demand restitution
How did Durkheim use these 2 types of laws to study the transition?
-proportion of these 2 kinds of laws changes with change in the type of society
Based on Durkheim’s analysis using the 2 laws what did he come up with?
-moral norms change in response to changes in social conditions
If you have a low degree of social differentiation what type of laws do you have?
-criminal law predominates
If you have a high degree of social differentiation what type of laws do you have?
-civil/administrative law predominates
Do we still find morality in modern societies?
- Yes, it does not disappear
- however, morality is different then it was in traditional societies