LS2: The English Legal System Flashcards
What set of rules are the conduct of criminal cases governed by?
Criminal Procedure Rules (CrPR)
What is the most important rule of the Criminal Procedure Rules (CrPR)?
r1.1 The overriding objective of this procedural code is that criminal cases be dealt with justly. (Justly means guilty are convicted, innocent set free, prosecution and defence dealt with fairly and rights of defendants under Art 6 ECHR right to a fair trial is respected).
What are the three categories of criminal offence?
Summary offences (Magistrates’ Court only)
Either-way offences (either Magistrates’ or Crown Court)
Indictable-only offences (Crown Court)
All have preliminary hearings in Magistrates’ Court.
What are summary offences and in which court are they tried?
Least serious offences, e.g. minor traffic offences, common assault.
Only in Magistrates’ Court.
What are either-way offences and in which court are they tried?
Intermediate level of seriousness, e.g. criminal damage, assault occasioning actual bodily harm and theft (except under £200 shoplifting for under 18yos, which are summary offences).
Can be tried in either Magistrates’ Court or Crown Court (after Magistrates decline jurisdiction).
What are indictable-only offences and in which court are they tried?
Most serious offences, e.g. murder, rape, robbery.
Magistrates’ Court brief preliminary hearing will send case to be tried in the Crown Court.
Who are the personnel in a Magistrates’ Court hearing?
2-3 lay magistrates, who are not legally trained. ( or sometimes a single District Judge instead).
Assisted by a justices’ clerk (court legal advisor) to provide guidance on the law.
No jury.
What are the three distinct functions of the Magistrates’ Court in criminal cases?
- Preliminary hearing for all cases
- Trials of summary and some either-way offences.
- Sentencing of defendants who are found guilty in Magistrates’ Court.
Which court will all criminal cases go through (and how many end there)?
Magistrates’ Court.
(90%)
What do preliminary hearings in the Magistrates’ Courts include?
- Preparation for trial hearings for summary cases where a ‘not guilty’ plea is anticipated.
- Allocation hearings for either-way offences
- ‘Sending’ either-way offences to Crown Court after allocation hearing.
- ‘Sending’ indictable-only offences to Crown Court.
What is the maximum prison sentence that the Magistrates’ Court can impose?
A maximum sentence of 6 months for one or more offences (12 months where the defendant is convicted of 2+ either-way offences)
What is the maximum fine that the Magistrates’ Court can impose?
Unlimited fines in the most serious cases.
What type of community sentence can a Magistrate’s Court impose?
One or more of (but not limited to) the following:
- unpaid work
- complying with a curfew
- attending alcohol treatment programme
- electronic tagging
What is a Youth Court?
A specialised Magistrates’ Court for defendants aged 10-17 years old.
Which court are offences with a child or young person defendant sent to?
Magistrates’ Court (Family Court).
However, very serious offences (e.g. murder) can be sent to the Crown Court.
What is different about Youth Courts compared to normal Magistrates’ Court?
- Less formal, magistrates can engage directly with defendant and use their first name
- Magistrates are specially trained
- Public is not allowed to attend Youth Court trials
What are some examples of additional sentencing in Youth Courts?
- Youth rehabilitation orders (e.g. curfews, supervision, education)
- Detention and training orders (up to 24 months in custody)
Who are the personnel in a Crown Court hearing? 3 types of judge
High Court judge (Tier 1 - for series crimes like murder)
or
Circuit judge (Tier 2)
or
Recorder judge (Tier 3)
Has a jury.
What types of cases does the Crown Court hear?
- Indictable-only offences
- Either-way offences
- Appeals from Magistrates’ Court
- defendants convicted in Magistrates’ Court, but sent to the Crown Court for sentencing due to the seriousness of the offence
What are the 5 out of court criminal sanctions?
- Warning (from police for small amount of weed)
- Simple Caution (when it isn’t worth prosecuting - will be taken into consideration in future sentencing)
- Conditional Caution (similar to 2. but still not a conviction, requires rehab or penalty)
- Penalty Notice (fine/fixed penalty, must be paid or will be prosecuted, e.g. parking/driving fines, COVID regs)
- Community Resolution (bringing the victim and offender together to reach an informal agreement, for anti-social behaviour and less series crime)
Which court do criminal appeals from Magistrates’ Court go to?
Depends on the appeal:
- Appeals against the conviction and/or sentence go to Crown Court
- Appeals on points of law go to Divisional Court of the High Court. Known as appeals ‘by way of case stated’.
Which court do appeals from the Crown Court go to?
Appeals against conviction, sentence and/or points of law go to the Court of Appeal.
(Appeal from Mag to Crown, where further appeal on points of law can be made to Divisional Court of the High Court ‘by way of case stated’)
What is the Full Code Test?
The test for a prosecutor to charge a suspect and bring prosecution.
1st stage: Evidential stage (must be sufficient evidence to prosecute)
2nd stage: Public Interest stage (must provide a realistic prospect)
What is a private prosecution?
When a private individual or company decide to prosecute without the CPS.
What set of rules are the conduct of civil cases governed by?
The Civil Procedure Rules (CPR), for cases in the County Court and the High Court.
What is the overriding objective for the civil court system?
CPR rule 1.1: Dealing with cases justly and at proportionate cost.
Justly meaning parties are equal, the case is managed quickly and fairly and management of case is proportionate to importance of the case.
Which factors are considered as a vulnerability in a party or witness?
- Age, immaturity or lack of understanding
- Communication or language difficulties
- Physical disability
- Mental health condition
- Witnessing a traumatic event related to the case
ETC
What set of rules are the conduct of Family Court governed by?
The Family Procedure Rules (FPR)
What is the overriding objective for the Family Procedure Rules?
FPR rule 1.1: Deal with cases justly, having regard to any welfare issues involved.
In which courts may a claimant issue (start) their civil claim? Explain the circumstances around each court.
In the County Court or the High Court.
County Court: Claims around personal injury or debt/contract disputes.
High Court: Claims above £100,000 or the claim includes damages (only £50,000 or more) for personal injuries.
Acts of Parliament require that a certain type of case be issued (started) in the High Court. What type of cases are they?
E.g. Defamation cases, libel and slander.
What are the three tracks that a civil case can be allocated to?
- Small claims track
- Fast track
- Multi-track