Legislation and Ethics Flashcards
What is moral philosophy?
The process by which we attempt to distinguish right from wrong
Are all things that are legal necessarily ethical?
No
What is Utilitarian/Consequentialist Ethics?
A theory that weighs up the pleasure/benefit derived by an action against the suffering/cost incurred. (Created by Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill)
What are three disadvantages of a Utilitarian/Consequentialist ethical assessment?
Whether the action is right or wrong is largely dependent on the intended outcome, outcome may sometimes differ in reality. So, often includes a high level of uncertainty.
Serves the “greater good” so may discriminate against minority groups.
The circumstance under which the assessment is being made will influence the outcome.
What is the criteria used in forming a Consequentialist/Utilitarian assessment?
Intensity – extent of pleasure/benefit Duration – how long it will last Certainty – likelihood of success Proximity –time before effect occurs Fecundity – productiveness Purity – possible adverse effects Extent – how many will be affected
What is Non-Consequentialist (Deontological) Ethics?
A method of ethics assessment based on adherence to rules, duties or obligations.
Actions are inherently right or wrong irrespective of the intended outcome.
What are two criticisms of Non-Consequentialist ethics?
Time, circumstance and new knowledge have little influence on the ethical decision
Ethical decisions are difficult to influence by rational argument or discussion
What is moral absolutism?
An ethical view based on the belief that certain actions are right or wrong regardless of context or circumstance.
Why can’t we use humans instead of animals for research?
Difficult to recruit suitable volunteers
Very restrictive on the severity of interventions that can be performed
Wide variation between subjects
Volunteers have to be fully informed, which may influence the outcome
What are Marshall Hall’s Five Principles to justify animal experimentation?
- The required data can only be obtained by experimentation
- The experiment must have clearly defined objectives
- The science must relflect current understanding and avoid duplication
- The methods used should be the least sever needed to meet the objective
- Experiments must be designed to give the clearest possible results
What did the Cruelty to Animal Act (1876) do?
Made vivisection an act of cruelty unless performed in compliance with the Act.
Key points:
- Registered places used for studies
- Banned use of paralysing drugs
- Regulated what could be done without anaesthetic
- Restricted studies conducted on cats, dogs and horses
What is the purpose of the Animal Scientific Procedures Act (1986) (Directive 2010/63/EU)?
Enables regulated procedures to be performed on protected animals for a permissible purpose that would otherwise constitute an offence under other legislation (e.g. Protection of Animals Act 1911 or Animal Welfare Act 2006)
What is a regulated procedure?
Anything that has the potential to cause pain, suffering, distress or lasting harm or anything that effects the animals physical, mental or social wellbeing. This includes things done directly to the animal, such as dosing or sample, and things done indirectly e.g. withholding for or water.
What is a non-regulated procedure?
Anything done as part of normal husbandry e.g. marking for identification
What is Schedule 1 of the ASPA?
A list of the methods of killing that can be performed by any competent person registered with the University (for example).
What is Schedule 2 of the ASPA?
A list of the species that MUST be obtained from an ASPA registered source.
What is a protected animal?
All living vertebrates (excluding humans) and cephalopods, this includes foetal mammals, birds and reptiles during the last third of gestation, fish and amphibians once they can feed independently and cephalopods from the point of hatching.
Also includes embryonic and foetal forms during the first two thirds of gestation if they will live beyond the point they become protected and could result in pain and suffering after they become protected.
What is the definition of ‘living’ under the ASPA guidelines?
An animal is ‘living’ until its circulation stops or its brain is destroyed.
What are the seven ‘permissible purposes’?
- Prevention, diagnosis or treatment of disease
- Assessment or regulation of physiology
- Protection of the natural environment
- Advancement of biological and behavioural knowledge
- Higher education or vocational skills training
- Forensic enquiries
- The breeding of animals for scientific use