Legal and Ethical Standards Flashcards
You receive a letter from a psychotherapist who is currently treating Mark, a former client of yours. The therapist is asking for a copy of Mark’s record, and his letter includes a signed release from Mark. Mark terminated therapy with you several months ago but still owes you for the last two therapy sessions. Although you’ve sent Mark a letter asking that he contact you to discuss his outstanding fees, he has not responded. Consequently, you decide not to send the record to the psychotherapist until Mark has paid his bill. Your decision is:
- acceptable as long as Mark’s records are not needed for emergency treatment.
- acceptable since you have no obligation to provide Mark’s current therapist with his records.
- acceptable only if you notify Mark of your decision and the reason for it.
- unacceptable since you cannot withhold a client’s record because of an unpaid bill.
- California Health and Safety Code Section 123 10 (J) applies to this situation. It states that, “this section shall be construed as prohibiting a health care provider from withholding patient records or summaries of patient records because of an unpaid bill for health care services.
If psychologists’ ethical responsibilities conflict with law, regulations, or other governing legal authority, what should psychologists do?
make known their commitment to the Ethics Code and take steps to resolve the conflict. If the conflict is unresolvable via such means, psychologists may adhere to the requirements of the law, regulations, or other governing legal authority. However, the Introduction states taht, if the “Ethics code establishes a higher standard of conduct than is required by law, psychologists must meet the higher ethical standard.”
California law is more stringent (and therefore preempts HIPPA requirements) with regard to the protection of information related to which topics?
Certain aspects of mental health treatment and HIV/AIDS testing
Who must comply with HIPPA regulations?
health care providers, health plans, and health care clearinghouses
What is Protected Health Information, as defined by HIPPA?
A type of individually identifiable health information that is maintained or transmitted in any medium and that provides information about (1) the individual’s past, present, or future physical and mental health condition; (2) the provision of health care tot he individual; or (3) past, present, or future payment for health care provided to the individual
What is not considered PHI?
Individually identifiable health information in educational records covered by FERBA or in employment records maintained by a covered entities in its role as an employer.
According to HIPPA standards, a client has the right to review request a review of the denial by a designated health care professional who did not participate in the original decision to deny access in which circumstances?
- The licensed health care professional has decided that disclosure of PHI to the client is reasonably likely to endanger the life or physical safety of the client or other person.
- The PHI refers to another person who is not a health care provider, and the health care provider believes that disclosure will cause substantial harm to that perrson
- The request was made by the client’s personal representative and the health care professional believes that disclosure to that representative is likely to cause substantial harm to the client or other person (California law does not allow a health care provider to withhold records from a patient’s personal representative because the provider believes that releasing records are contrary to the patients best interests).
The client does not have the right to request a review of a denial of the release of records under which circumstances?
1) The information is exempt from the right to access (e.g., the request is for PHI that was compiled for use in a criminal, civil, or administrative hearing)
2) The covered entity is a correctional institution or is acting under the direction of a correctional institution, the requester is an inmate, and the covered entity believes that access will threaten the health or safety of the requester, other inmates, or employees of the institution.
3. The information was obtained as part of an ongoing research study and the requester agreed to denial of access as part of the consent process
4. The PHI was obtained from someone other than a health care provider under a promise of confidentiality
Under HIPPA’s privacy rule, clients may be denied access to their protected health information in certain circumstances. Which of the following most accurately describes HIPPA’s requirements?
- Access may be denied when the psychologist believes that providing the information is reasonably likely to cause emotional distress for the client and the client is given the right to have the denial reviewed.
- Access may be denied when the psychologist believes that providing the information is reasonably likely too endanger the physical safety of the client or other person and the client is given the right to have the denial reviewed.
- Access may be denied when the psychologist believes that providing the information is reasonably likely to cause emotional distress for the client or endanger the physical safety of the client, and the psychologist determines whether the client may request that the denial be reviewed.
- Access may be denied when the psychologist believes that doing so is in the best interest of the client, and the psychologist determines whether the client may request that the denial be reviewed.
HIPPA’s privacy rule generally provides clients with greater access to PHI than does California law and usually sets the standard for determining when access may be denied. The privacy rule states that a provider may deny a patient access to his or her medical records when access is reasonably likely to endanger the life or physical safety of the patient or another person. However, in this situation, the client must be given the right to have the denial reviewed by a health care professional who was not involved in the original decision to deny access.
Under HIPPA’s privacy rule, a health care provider may disclose PHI without the client’s consent:
- only when the disclosure meets the “minimum necessary” standard
- only when the information is needed to provide the client with emergency health care services
- when the information will be used for routine treatment, payment, and health care operations purposes
- when the provider has determined that it is in the client’s best interest to do so
3
A licensed psychologist who has just started working in a rural community finds that several of her clients have problems that are outside her training and experience but that there is no other mental health professional in the community who can treat these clients. The psychologist should:
- continue seeing the clients only if they are experiencing a crisis or other emergency
- inform the client of her lack of experience and let them decide if they want to continue seeing her
- continue seeing the clients but obtain appropriate consultation by telephone
- refuse to see the clients until she receives appropriate training
- It is acceptable for psychologists to acquire new knowledge and skills during the course of their practice as long as they obtain adequate training, supervision, or consultation.
Dr. Bermeister, a licensed psychologist, is asked to provide crisis intervention counseling to individuals who were affected by a tornado that destroyed many homes in the community. Dr. B has not had experience providing assistance to people who have been traumatized by a natural disaster, but there is no one else in the area who has experience and is available to see these individuals. As an ethical psychologist, Dr. B should:
- refuse to provide counseling to these individuals
- provide counseling to these individuals but use only strategies and techniques that he has experience using.
- disclose his lack of experience to these individuals during the informed consent process
- provide counseling to these individuals but stop when the crisis has ended or when the appropriate services become available
4
What information is appropriate to share with an employee’s supervisor in the context of an employee assistance program when the employee was referred by his/her supervisor?
Whether the employee kept appointments, whether the employee needs treatment, and whether the employee accepted the treatment. The supervisor should not be given any other information about the employee without the employee’s consent.
True or false: Even when an employee refuses to sign a waiver for or an authorization for release of information prior to an evaluation for fitness for duty, an employer still has the right to limited information about the results off the evaluation.
True. They would be given information related to if the employee is able to perform essential job functions, whether any functional limitations will affect the employee’s ability to perform his/her job duties, and whether any accommodations are needed tto help the employee perform his/her job duties.
True or false: Group members are legally obligated to maintain one another’s confidentiality.
False. However, group therapist must stress the importance of doing so and describe at the outset of the group the roles and responsibilities of all parties and the limits of confidentiality.
True or false: A therapist should never keep secrets in couple and family therapy.
False. The therapist should clarify at the outset his/her policy regarding this type of information at the outset of treatment
A licensed psychologist shall retain a patient’s health service records for a minimum of ____ years form the patient’s discharge date. For minor’s, the patient’s health service records shall be retained for a minimum of _____ years from the date the patient reaches 18 yo.
7, 7
Can you deny a patient access to their records due to non-payment?
No, under CA law which supersedes the Ethics code
What is the time frame in which a psychologist must respond to a written request for access to records?
Health care provider must permit a client or client representative to inspect the client’s records during business hours within five working days following the receipt of the written request.
Health care provider must ensure that a copy of the client’s record is transmitted to the client representative or client within 15 days after receipt of a written request.
Health care provider can choose to prepare a summary of the record for inspection or copying, but HIPAA permits this only if the client agrees in advance to receiving a summary, which must be available within 10 days. If the record is long, hcp can request more time, but notify the client and have the information no more than 30 days after.
Is it deceptive/unethical for a psychologist to identify him/herself as a PhD Candidate?
Yes since this listing may falsely imply an earned degree.
Advertising
psychologists who engage others to create or place public statements that promote their professional practice, products, or activities retain professional responsibility for such statements.
Compensation of press
Psychologists do not compensate employees of press, radio, television, or other communication media in return for publicity in a news item
paid advertisements
a paid advertisement relating to a psychologists’ activities must be identified or clearly recognizable as such
Solicitation of testimonials
Psychologists do not solicit testimonials from currentt therapy clients/patients or other persons who because of their particular circumstances are vulnerable to undue influence.
Solicitation of business
Psychologists do not engage, directly or through agents, in uninvited in-person solicitation of business from actual or potential therapy clients or other persons who because of their particular circumstances are vulnerable to undue influence.
Business and Professions Code Section 2936 requires psychology licenses and registrants to post a notice regarding which of the following in a conspicuous location in their place of business?
- Information on how to contact the psychologist in an emergency
- Information on how to contact the board concerning questions and complaints
- the psychologist’s policies regarding fees and insurance reimbursement
- the potential limits of confidentiality
2
Which of the following best describes a psychologist’s legal obligations when providing mental health services over the internet?
- A licensed psychologist may not provide mental health services over the internet except in emergency situations
- A licensed psychologist may not provide mental health services over the internet unless he/she has been certified as an internet providerr
- A licensed psychologist may provide mental health services over the internet but must obtain an informed consent from the client verbally and in writing before doing so
- A licensed psychologist may provide mental health services over the internet but must provide the client with a standard disclaimer before doing so.
3
Section 123149 of the California Health and Safety Code applies to providers of health services that utilize electronic recordkeeping services only. It states that:
- the original hard copy of patient records must be maintained as a backup for an electronic copy
- the original copy of any record containing the patient’s signature must be maintained even when the record has been electronically stored.
- the original hard copy of patient records may be destroyed once the records have been electronically stored.
- the original hard copy of a patient’s records may be destroyed once the records have been electronically stored only after obtaining the consent of the patient to do so.
3
When a therapy client requests a summary of his or her record (rather than a copy of the entire record), a psychologist must provide a summary within _____ working days after receipt of the client’s written request unless the record is of extraordinary length or treatment of the client was terminated within the last 10 days.
- 6
- 10
- 15
- 20
2
You are the only psychologist in a rural community. Your daughter’s Girl Scout leader calls, saying she wants to begin seeing you in therapy to work through feelings related to a recent divorce. As an ethical psychologist, you:
- refuse to see the woman because doing so would constitute a multiple relationship
- see the woman because you are the only psychologist in the community and her problem is unrelated to her role as a Girl Scout leader
- ascertain the seriousness of the woman’s problems and agree to see her only if she appears to be in a crisis situation
- assess the potential for exploitation or loss of objectivity and base your decision about seeing her on the outcome of the assessment
- Because you are the only psychologist in the community, you wouldn’t necessarily refuse to see the woman in therapy but would want to consider the potential consequences before agreeing to do so.
You are starting a program for parents who are recently divorced. You tell the editor of the local newspaper (who just divorced her husband and has physical custody of their 10-year-old daughter) that she can attend the program for free if she puts an article about the program in the paper. According to the ethics code, this is:
- unethical because you should not compensate a newspaper employee for publicity in a news item about your services
- unethical only if you influence the editor’s choice of content for the article
- ethical as long as the arrangement doesn’t compromise your objectivity when providing services to the editor
- ethical only if the editor would otherwise be unable to attend the workshop due to her inability to pay the fee
1
As defined in the APA’s Ethics Code, uninvited in-person soliciation of business by a psychologist is:
- acceptable as long as the solicitation is not coercive.
- acceptable when it involves providing disaster or community outreach services
- acceptable as long as the person’s best interests are of paramount concern
- never acceptable
2
What two requirements must be met for a minor, age 12 or older, to consent to outpatient mental health treatment or counseling services and to residential shelter services?
- The mental health professional believes the minor is sufficiently mature to participate intelligently in the services
- The minor would present serious physical or mental harm to self or others without the services or is the alleged victim of incest or child abuse
When a minor does not meet the criteria to consent to treatment, the family code provides several exceptions to this rule. What are these exceptions?
- Alcohol and Drug-related problems (exception does not apply to replacement narcotic abuse treatment); physiciian shall disclose medical information concerning the care to the minor’s parent or legal guardian upon his or her request, even if the minor child does not consent to the disclosue, without liability for the disclosure
- Prevention and treatment of pregnancy
- Victim of Rape
- Victim f sexual assault
- Exposure to infectious, contagious, or coommunicable diseases
- Self-sufficient minors (minor must be 15 or older; living separate from guardian; managing own financial affairs)
You are treating 14 year old Samantha with the consent of her parents. One day you receive a phone call from Samantha’s father, who wants access to her therapy records. You believe that agreeing to his request may be psychologically harmful to Samantha. You:
- must comply with his request because Samantha is a minor
- must comply with his request because he consented to Samantha’s therapy
- may deny access because of your concern about the consequences of doing so
- have no obligation to allow him access to Samantha’s records but may comply as a courtesy
3
A nonemancipated minor may receive treatment without parental knowledge and consent in which of the following situations?
- The minor is at least 12 years of age, is requesting counseling for an alcohol-related proglem, and the provider has determined it would not be appropriate to contact the minor’s parent.
- The minor is at least 12 years of age and is seeking medical care related to the diagnosis or treatment of a sexually transmitted disease or other disease that is required by law to be reported to a local health officer
- The minor is of any age, is seeking diagnostic or treatment services related to a sexual assault, and the provider believes that the minor’s parent or guardian is the perpetrator of the assault
- All of the above
4
When a minor cannot legally consent to his or her own mental health treatment, who can provide consent?
- If parents are married, either parent alone may authorize tx
- When parents are divorced but share joint legal custody, either parent alone may consent to therapy.
- If a parent has sole legal custody, that parent may unilaterally make mental health care decisions
- Unmarried parents, minors who are parents, and legal guardians have authorization to consent to tx
- Caregivers who meet the appropriate requirements and sign an authorization affidavit may give consent for a minor’s treatment
- In an emergency, no consent is necessary, and a psychologist may treat a minor regardless of who brought the minor for treatment
The duty to warn does not apply to which situations?
- Someone other than the client is the dangerous party (however, potentially encourage client to report danger)
- Someone other than a family member reports that a client has threatened to harm someone (psychologist would want to address this issue with the client)
- There is no reasonably identifiable victim or victims (may not have duty to warn/protect but may need to hospitalize)
- The client threatens suicide
Who can inform when a patient has tested positive for HIV virus?
Physicians and surgeons may inform a patient’s spouse, other sexual partners, needle-sharing partners, and other health care workers when a patient has tested positive for the HIV virus. May not identify the patient but may tell the individual that he/she has been exposed to the HIV virus.
What is a psychologists duty when working with a client who is HIV positive?
Encourage client to notify sexual and needle-sharing partners; offer to help them make the disclosure; inform client of client’s legal duty to inform their sexual partners
If client expresses an intent to infect a specific person, psychologist may ave a duty to warn but should consult with a colleague and/or attorney.
When should involuntary commitment be considered?
- The danger that the client poses to self or others is imminent or the client is gravely disabled.
- The danger or grave disability is the result of a mental disorder or chronic alcoholism.
- The client has refused or is unable to comply with a recommendation to enter a psychiatric hospital voluntarily.
What constitutes a 5150?
It is a 72-hour hold and states that, “when any person, as a result of a mental disorder, is a danger to others, or to himself or herselff, or gravely disabbled, a peace officer, a member of the attending staff of an evaluation facility designated by the county, designated members of a mobile crisis team, or other professional person designated by a county, may upon probable cause, take, or cause to be taken, the person into custody and place him or her in a facility designated by the county and approved by the State Department of Mental Health as a facility for 72 hour treatment and evaluation
What is 5230?
Similar to 5250 but individual has same problems as the result of alcohol or drug use