Left realism Flashcards
who are the key left realists?
Lea and young
what did Lea and Young conduct and what did they find?
- victim survey of inner city london (islington)
- w/c, blacks and elderly women fear street crime as they reported often being victims
how are Left realists similar to marxists?
see society as unequal and capitalist
how are left realists different from marxists?
- LR are reformists
- believe in gradual social change
- believe we need to develop explanations of crime based on real experience
- this will lead to practical strategies
why are lea and young critical of labelling theory?
- LT: w/c are just discriminated against by agents of social control
- LR: yes but lea and young’s survey found w/c and in some areas young African Caribbeans commit the most crime
why do left realists criticize traditional marxists?
LR:
- believe TM overemphasis crimes of the powerful
- lea and young agree white collar is under reported but its not damaging p’s everyday lives like e.g muggings
how are left realists critical of neo marxists?
LR:
- NM romanticises w/c criminals as modern day criminals
- LR says the wealthy are rarely victims of crime, it is mainly the poor that suffer at the hands of w/c
what do left realists say about marxists and labelling theories saying crime is socially constructed?
Lea and Young:
- the increase is too great to be explained
- increase is very real
- more p’s are victim and reporting
- british crime surveys support this
what are the left realist explanations for crime?
- relative deprivation
- marginalisation
- subcultures
how does relative deprivation explain crime?
- p’s resent what other have
- media and advertising make p’s more aware of it
- consumerism raises p’s expectations of material possessions
- those who can’t afford steal it
what is relative deprivation?
how deprived someone feels in relation to others or their own expectations
how does Lea and Young describe the differences in relative deprivation?
- w/c more relatively deprived than m/c
- afro carribean compare themselves to white youth in regard to life opportunities
these groups feel more relatively deprived
how does relative deprivation not necessarily lead to crime?
- only when combined with individualism does it cause crime
- pursuit of self interest at the expense of others
what is individualism?
a concern w/ the self and one’s own individual rights rather than those of the group
how do left realists argue individualism is on the rise?
- media emphasises materialistic goods
- individualism disintegrates families and communities
- it undermines selflessness
- this creates a spiral of anti social behaviour