Lecture Flashcards
What is a “Certificate of Formation” (TBOC 1.002(6))?
The articles of incorporation submitted to the Secretary of State.
How many different types of corporations are there (TBOC 1.002(14))?
- For-Profit
- Non-Profit
- Professional Organization
What is an S-Corp?
A For-Profit corporation as defined in Chapter S of the Federal Tax Code.
- Flow through taxation
- Owners/Shareholders limited to less than 100
- Single class of shares
What is a C-Corp?
A For-Profit corporation as defined in Chapter C of the Federal Tax Code.
- Double Taxation
- No limit on number of owners
- Multiple Share classes
What is the difference in taxation for an S and C-Corp?
- S-Corp does not tax profits of the corporation, only on the distributions to the owners/shareholders.
- C-Corp taxes the corporate earnings and the distributions to the owners/shareholders
Who creates a corporation?
An “Incorporator, Agent, Organizer” files the articles of incorporation (TBOC 3.004).
- Does not have to be an owner
- Needs to be able to receive process of service for the corporation
- Must have the capacity to contract to create a corporation
What elements must the Certificate of Incorporation include (TBOC 3.005)?
- Name of the filing entity to be formed
- Type of entity to be formed
- Purpose of the entity
- Duration (if less than perpetual)
- Street address of registered agent
- Names and addresses of initial board of directors (at least 1 required in Texas)
- Number of authorized shares
- Par Value or No Par value of the shares
- Name and address of organizer
- Effectiveness of filing election (Texas)
What are the penalties in Texas for knowingly filing a false Certificate of Incorporation?
- Misdemeanor if the person knows that the filing is materially false
- State Felony if the person intends to harm or defraud another.
What is a closely held company?
A company whose shares are not publically traded.
How is the corporation structured?
- Ownership (Own the Business)
- Shareholders
- Management (Running the Business)
- Board of Directors
- Officers
- Managers
- Employees
- Managers
- Officers
- Board of Directors
Who are Directors?
Directors are elected (hired) by the shareholders to provide management oversight for the running of the company. (TBOC 1.001(35)(a))
- Individual directors are powerless to act, all actions must be board actions.
Who are Officers?
Officers (CEO, COO, etc.) are hired by the board to manage the ongoing operations of the company and carry out the strategic direction of the board (TBOC 1.001(61)).
- Individual Officers can bind the corporation to agreements, etc.
Can a person be an Owner, Director, and Officer?
Yes
What “powers” does a corporation have?
Except as limited by the code, a domestic entity has the same powers as an individual to take action necessary or convenient to carry out its business and
affairs (TBOC 2.101(…)).
- Run the business
- Defend the business
- Grow the business
Can the “Powers” of the corporation be limited in the “Certificate of Formation”?
NO ! (TBOC 20.002)
- A corporations powers are provided by statute, not by the Certificate.
Can the “Authority” of the corporation (or officers) be limited by the “Certificate of Incorporation”?
YES (TBOC 20.002)
Can the Corporation avoid liability by using as a defense that the acts were beyond the “Certificate of Incorporation”?
- Stated Purpose - No (TBOC 20.002(b)(1))
- Inconsistent with limitation of authority - No (TBOC 20.002(b)(2))
- Lack of capacity - No (TBOC 20.002(a))
Can someone suing the Corporation assert the claim of exceeding the purpose or authority of the “certificate of incorporation”?
- Shareholder - Yes (TBOC 20.002(c)(1))
- Corporation against an Officer/Director - Yes (TBOC 20.002(c)(2))
- State against Corporation/Officer/Director - Yes (TBOC 20.002(c)(3)
What does “de jure” mean?
By right of law
- A corporation founded by legal right
When does a corporation exist in Texas?
- When an certificate of incorporation has been delivered to the SOS
- The SOS determines that the “Articles” conform to the statutes
- Files the Certificate - the Magic Happens A Corporation is Born
- Provides an Acknowledgement
TBOC 4.001, and 4.002
What is a “de Facto” corporation?
A corporation that is formed by the actions of the parties, but fails to meet the legal requirements of incorporation.
How can a “de Facto” corporation be recognized?
- A law of incorporation exists within the state
- An attempt was made to organize the corporation
- Must be a “colourable” attempt (failing to timely file not colourable)
- Operated as corporate entity after attempt
- Hausman and TBOC 3.001(d)
Is the acknowledgement from the SOS binding?
No, the acknowledge of filing is not a “Certificate of Incorporation”, but it can be submitted as evidence of a “de Facto” corporation. TBOC 3.001(d)
What is Estoppel?
- A statement made by someone signifying that a corporation had been formed
- Sellling shares is a statement
- Another person reasonably relied on the statement
- To their detriment
The person making the statement is estopped from denying the corporation, only works for contracts not tort actions
What is the public policy split on “de Facto” corporations?
- Some jurisdictions believe that the filing requirement is a mere formality
- 1/3 would not require a “colourable” attempt
- Some jurisdictions believe that the filing has significance
- 2/3 would expect a “colourable” attempt
How long does a corporation last?
Assumed to be in purpetuity, unless otherwise specified in “Certificate of Incorporation” (TBOC 3.003, 3.005(a))
Why is the street address of the Incorporating Agent required?
Form 201 - Article 2 states that the street address is required for the process of service.
What is the difference between an organizer and agent?
- Organizer - Any person with the capacity to contract can organize and file a certificate of incorporation, like a corporation.
- Agent - A designated person that has the authority to act on behalf of the newly formed corporation, and can receive process of service.
What is “Par” value?
A minimum price per share for the authorized shares listed in the “Certificate of Incorporation”. Shares cannot be sold by the corporation for a price below the par value.
What are authorized shares?
These are the initial shares available to the ownership as per the “Certificate of Incorporation”. Additional share offerings beyond those authorized require amendment of the “Certificate of Incorporation”.
Is par value required in the Certificate of Incorporation?
Either a statement of par value or “no par value” is required.
Is a statement of purpose required?
Yes, but in Texas it is presumed to be “for the transaction of any and all lawful business”. Article 5 - Form 201,
What is a Quorum, and when is it required?
A quorum is the majority necessary for the board of directors or shareholders to take action.
- Board of Directors - >50% of board members must be present to meet and take action.
- Shareholders - > 50% of the outstanding shares must be present to meet.
Who is liable for contracts formed on behalf of the corporation prior to the filing of the articles?
Promotor, not the corporation
How does the corporation accept liability for contracts formed before the articles are filed?
The board of directors “adopts” the contract, becoming liable for it.
Once a pre-incorporation contract is adopted by the corporation, is the promoter no longer liable?
No, the promoter is still liable as a party to the contract. To remove liability, the contract must be subject to a novation.
How does net present value (NPV) work conceptually?
How does discounted cash flow work in practice?
- Decide how many years into the future you wish to use (1, 5, 10, etc.)
- Estimate the profits for each future year (Revenue - Costs)
- Apply the discount rate to the profits year by year
- Sum up the individual years
Can the social purposes of a corporation be included in the articles?
Yes (TBOC 3.007(d)-(e))
When would directors sign an amendment to the articles?
If shares have not been issued and the amended articles are adopted by the board, a majority of directors may sign. (TBOC 21.053)
Who normally signs an amended certificate of formation?
Officers (TBOC 21.053)
Who must agree to an amended certificate of incorpration if shares have been issued?
Stockholders
- By a majority of stockholders eligible to vote. (TBOC 21.054)
Where do the by-laws come from, and how can they be changed?
- The by-laws are established by the Board of Directors at the first organizational meeting. (TBOC 21.057)
- By-laws can be changed by an action of the Board or Shareholders (TBOC 21.058)
Can the certificate limit the powers of the board or shareholders?
No, the powers of each are established by statute.
Can the certificate limit the authority of the board or shareholders?
Yes, the authority granted to each can be defined in the certificate.
Must a company keep records of all shareholders?
Yes (TBOC 3.151, 21.373)
When the Certificate and By-laws contradict each other who wins?
Certificate (TBOC 21.057(b))
Can the Board amend the bylaws?
Yes, unless:
- Unless the certificate forbids it, or
- The shareholders adopt a bylaw prohibiting it.
(TBOC 21.057(c))
Must the records of a corporation be kept on paper?
No, but they must be kept in a form that can be converted to paper form within a reasonable time. (TBOC 3.151)
Do the shareholders have a right to examine the corporate records?
Yes, upon written demand stating a reasonable purpose a shareholder may examine and copy. (TBOC 21.218)
What can a shareholder do if denied access to the records?
File suit, and if successful can:
- be awarded attorney’s fees, costs and expenses
- any other damages and remedies afforded by law
(TBOC 21.222)
Can someone else vote on behalf of a shareholder?
Yes, through
- Proxy
- Voting Trusts
- Voting Agreements
(TBOC 6.251)
What is a voting agreement?
An contract between shareholders to vote in a common manner (TBOC 6.252).
- Each shareholder casts their own votes
- If agreement is in writing, can be compelled to vote as agreed (specific performance)
- DAS for breach of contract
- A copy of the agreement must be deposited with the corporation.
What is a voting trust?
A shareholder signs over the voting rights to a trust which is directed by a trustee.
- Shareholder no longer votes, Trustee does
- The trust agreement must be filed with the corporation
- Shareholder retains other rights of ownership (dividends, etc.)
What are the two required elements to “Pierce the Veil”?
- There must be unity of interest and ownership that the seperate personalities of the corporation and the individal no longer exist.
- Adherence to the fiction that the corporation exists seperately would sanction a fraud or promote injustice.
Van Dorn
What are the four factors to determine if a corporation is essentially controlled by another?
- Failure to maintain accurate corporate records and comply with corporate formalities (Not Used)
- Comingling of funds or assets
- Under-capitalization
- One freely uses the assets of another corporation as its own.
Macaluso
What does “Promote Injustice” mean from the Van Dorn case?
Something less than an affirmative showing of fraud, or some wrong beyond a creditors inability to collect.
What are some examples of “Promoting Injustice”?
- Unjust enrichment
- A parent company causes subsidiary liabilities but subsidiaries lack of ability to pay relieves parent of obligation
- Hiding assets in a liability free corporation,while creating liabilities in an asset free corporation.
Sea Land
What are the practical elements of “Piercing the Veil”?
- Equitable remedy
- Party seeking relief has the burden of proof
- Totality of circumstances test used to evaluate if veil should be pierced
- Each case decided on its own facts/merits
What is a possible third prong of “Piercing the Veil”?
That creditors/business folk are saavy enough to properly vett a potential corporation to assess the risk they are taking before entering into a contract.
Laya
What is Utilitarianism?
If the benefit is great enough to warrant the harm to others, it is justified.
What is the order of payment when a corporation is insolvent, “equitable subordination”?
- Government
- Federal
- State
- Trustee
- Secured Creditor
- Unsecured Creditor
- Equity holder (shareholder)
What are the characteristics of an “Arms Length” loan?
- Payment terms and schedule
- Collateral
- Defined interest
What are the rules for determining if claims are allowed in insolvency proceedings?
- When a claim is found to be inequitable, it may be set aside, or subordinated to the claims of other creditors
- Inequitable is whether, within the bounds of reason and fairness, such a plan can be justified.
Costello
What is the test for inequitable claims for a person with fiduciary relations with a corporation?
Whether or not under all the circumstances the transaction carries the earmarks of an arm’s length bargain.
Pepper
Must a Texas Corp. hold its meetings in Texas?
No (TBOC 6.001(a))
- Provided by or fixed by governing documents (Certificate or By-Laws)
- Agreed to by all person entitled to notice of the meeting.
Where must a Texas Corp hold its meeting if it is not entitled to have it outside of Texas or there is no agreement of those concerned about the meetings location?
Must be held at the corporate offices (TBOC 6.001(b))
Is a face to face meeting of shareholders/board required?
No TBOC(6.002)
Alternate forms are okay, telephone, skype, etc., as long as those in attendance can hear and be heard.
Can you object to a call and notice of the meeting in a skype meeting?
Yes (TBOC 6.003)
What if no record date is set for a meeting?
Then the record date becomes the notice date. (TBOC 6.101(1))
What other ways can corporate action be taken other than a meeting?
Unamimous Written Consent to Action (TBOC 6.201)
Can a corporation block a shareholder proposal on a proxy statement?
Yes,
- if the SEC reviews and provides a “no action” letter.
- proposal violates state or federal law
- is false or misleading
- is ordinary business
- concerns personal claims
- is moot
What must a proxy statement include (Rule 14(a))?
- All matters to be voted on:
- Directors
- Proposals
- Identity of all proxy holders
- Compensation paid to all officers and directors
What must a proxy statement not do (Rule 14a-9)?
Provide false or misleading statements of any material fact, or omit any material fact that would make the statements misleading.
What are the elements required to prove a false of misleading proxy statement?
- Materiality
- Causation
- Standing
- Scienter (Intent)
How is materiality established?
The substantial likelihood that a reasonable shareholder would consider it important in deciding how to vote.
Northway
How is Scienter/Intent established?
The supreme court has yet to define, but it could be negligence (should have known), extreme recklessness (knew of the possibility but didn’t care), intent (knew and purposely did it).
How is causation established?
If materiality is established then causation is also assumed. Reliance is not required.
Can a shareholder proposal be included in the corporate proxy materials?
Yes
- Must be a shareholder (record owner) of at least 1% or $1000 in market value
- Proposal cannot exceed 500 words
- May only have one proposal per proxy statement
Must each share get one vote?
No (TBOC 21.366)
Votes per share can be allocated as per the certficate of formation, otherwise one vote per share.
What is considered ordinary business (14a-8 (i)(7)?
Policy considerations
- actions that are fundamental to running the corporation that they are not practical for shareholder oversight
- shareholders cannot micro-manage the company
What types of shareholder proposals are not ordinary business?
- Lobbying/Political activities of the corporation
- Environmental/Climate Change
- Sustainability
- Diversity of the Board
- EEO
- Human Rights
Must a corporation hold an annual meeting?
Yes (TBOC 21.351)
- Time and place to set in corporations by-laws
Can a “special” meeting be called.
Yes (TBOC 21.352)
Who can call a special meeting?
- President
- Board of Directors
- Any other person authorized by the certificate or by-laws
- Shareholders of certain percentages not to exceed 50% entitlted to vote, at least 10% all shares entitledto vote.
Is notice required for a general meeting?
No (TBOC 21.353)
Is notice of a “special” meeting required?
Yes (TBOC 21.353(b))
Notice must be given and include the purpose of the meeting.
Can “notice” be provided electronically?
Yes (TBOC 21.353(c))