Lecture 3 - Liberalism Flashcards
What are the four main strands of Liberalism in IR ?
- Sociological Liberalism (Transnational relations)
Interdependence - Liberalism (Functionalism and Complex Interdependence)
- Institutional Liberalism (International Institutions)
- Republican Liberalism (Democratic Peace Theory)
What is the first assumption of Liberalism ?
The multi-centric approach
What’s the multi-centric approach in liberalism ?
- Monolithic state is downgraded & international organizations (IOs), multinational corporations (MNCs) & NGOs are also key actors
- Social actors, such as individuals & private groups, play a primary role in promoting differing interests in an environment with scarcity of resources and conflicting values
According to Liberalism, is the state a unitary actor ?
No, the second assumption of Liberalism is that the state is not a unitary actor
What does it imply that the state is not a unitary actor for liberalism ?
- States represent subsets of society that can impose themselves through fair procedures
- Decision-making involves multiple groups such as political groups, pressure groups & bureaucracy, making international affairs more complex than Realist beliefs
- Endogenous factors play a role in foreign policy
What does Liberalism say about the rationality of the state ?
The state is not always rational
What does it imply that the state is not always rational for liberalism ?
- Foreign policy decisions result from clashes, bargaining, compromises & alliances, rather than purely rational processes
- Rationality in this context means the maximization of communal welfare in the long term, emphasizing collaboration over conflict
How does Liberalism view the agenda of IR ?
The agenda is wide and diversifie
-> it includes not only security & high politics but also issues of low politics, such as social, economic, environmental & human rights concerns
What is the Democratic Peace Theory in Republican Liberalism ?
- Democracies do not go to war with one another
- They value individual liberty, autonomy, legitimacy, self-determination & non-interference
- If all states were liberal-democratic, there would be no wars & peace & prosperity would prevail
What are Immanuel Kant’s 3 conditions for perpetual peace ?
- The civil constitution in every state should be republican
- The right of nations should be based on a federation of free states
- The rights of men as citizens of the world should be limited to universal hospitality
What are MONADIC explanations for why democracies don’t fight each other ?
- Ontological : Democratic leaders are accountable to a voting public, who suffer the most from wars
- Structural : Decision-making in democracies is slow, divided & transparent, making aggression less likely
- Normative : Democracies externalize their internal methods of peaceful conflict resolution
- Resources : Democracies have greater wealth & prefer to preserve infrastructure & resources
What are DIADIC explanations for why democracies don’t fight each other ?
- Legitimacy : Democracies are friendly with similar regimes, making war a self-contradiction
- Reciprocity : Democracies respect agreements & trust each other more
- Economic : Democracies trade more among themselves, reducing the likelihood of conflict
What is Doyle’s contribution to Republican Liberalism ?
Emphasizes that democracy leads to peace through 3 elements :
- Domestic political cultures based on peaceful conflict resolution
- Common moral values, forming a “pacific union” among democracies
- Strengthened peace through economic cooperation & interdependence
What questions are raised by the Democratic Peace Theory 2.0 ?
- How to expand the zone of peace & spread liberal ideals ?
- Is it right to export or impose democracy through war (e.g., Iraq invasion 2003) ?
- The idea that the world is divided into democratic (zones of peace) & non-democratic (zones of conflict) countries
How has the rise of China challenged liberalism ?
Raised disputes over :
- Democratic dividend (economic) : questioning whether economic growth leads to democracy
- Democratic legitimacy (political) : contrasting China’s focus on welfare vs. Western emphasis on rights
- The concept of the Beijing consensus & authoritarian resilience as an alternative to liberal democratic models
What is collective security ?
- Each state accepts that the security of one concerns all & agrees to join a collective response to any aggression
- It can escape the vicious circle of the realist security dilemma by fostering cooperation
- It benefits small & medium-sized powers & requires non-aggression, collective response to aggression & a shared interpretation of liability
How are global public goods addressed in IR ?
In the absence of a world government, global public goods are managed through :
- Collective security
- International law
- International institutions & regimes
- Intergovernmental organizations (IOs)
- Global governance & supranational integration
What is the Theory of Interdependence ?
- IR are influenced by trans-governmental & trans-national dynamics
- Interdependence means one actor’s decisions affect others & can be political, economic, or social
- It can be symmetrical or asymmetrical, promoting cooperation (liberal view) or creating vulnerability (realist view)
What is the Theory of Complex Interdependence ?
According to Keohane and Nye (1977), Complex Interdependence involves :
- Multiple channels of interaction beyond just state-to-state
- No hierarchy among issues (security is not always the top priority)
- Reduced importance of military power, leading to an overlap between domestic & foreign politics & the marginalization of military might in international affairs
How does Realism differ from Complex Interdependence ?
- Realism emphasizes military security, state power & high politics, with states focusing on short-term, relative gains
- Complex Interdependence focuses on various goals, the manipulation of interdependence & the significant role of international organizations (IOs), emphasizing long-term, absolute gains
What is the Theory of (Neo-)Liberal Institutionalism ?
- International cooperation offers benefits & drives European integration - Functionalism & neo-functionalism (Mitrany & Haas) highlight the role of IOs, non-state actors, integration & interdependence in fostering cooperation
What is the “neo-neo synthesis” of the 1980s ?
Refers to the convergence of Neo-liberalism & Neo-realism :
- Both view states as rational actors in an anarchic system but differ in emphasis
- Neo-liberals prioritize low politics, absolute gains & cooperation, while neo-realists focus on high politics, relative gains & survival