Lecture 3 - Darwin Flashcards
What is intelligent design?
The idea that we are complex and must have been made by something even more complex (God)
Camera/eye analogy
What is creationism?
Says that biological structures are created by an intelligent being (God)
What are the problems with creationism?
Pushes the Q back - who created the intelligent being?
Evidence for evo exists
eg) body parts did not emerge suddenly, parallels across history/species like brain similarities, fossil evidence, vestigal phenomenon
Poor design (blind spot)
Describe the significance of the trip that Darwin took.
1831 - 5 year trip companion
Spent time in South America, Brazil
Went through the Galapagos Islands
What evidence did Darwin collect?
- Rocks filled w/ seashells far from shore - how?
- Witnessed earthquake
- Lyell’s Principles of Geology
Earth formed gradually, making time for evolution - Collected/logged species and data
Animals, skins, bones, etc - Noticed relationship between old animals and now by studying fossils
- Differences across different islands - eg. beaks and shapes
- Diff birds had diff functions
eg. fins, paddles, sails, wings - Some creatures only existed in certain parts of the world
- Found grasshopper 300 miles at sea
- On land there were few sparse species; in water there were hundreds
- Thought about how he came to the islands
How did Darwin put the evidence together?
Read Malthus’ essay on population (1838)
Without war/disease, human pop would grow until out of resources
This would result in the struggle for existence where the strong survive and weak perish
What is the significance of pigeon breeders?
Darwin compared pigeon breeders to nature
Artificial selection akin to natural selection
What is natural selection?
Nature’s way to compensate for lack of resources
Produce more than can survive
Available resources favor those with a trait advantage
The trait is passed down through reproduction
Over long time, the species changes
What is the function of mental life, according to evolution?
Originated for reproduction and survival
What did evolution contribute to psychology and society?
Variability/individual differences
Eugenics
Comparative psychology
What kept Darwin from sharing his findings?
Fear of the Church
Vestiges was pubb’d in 1844 and very poorly received by Darwin’s contemporaries and his mentor Sedgwick
Discuss On the Origin of Species
1859
Ch 1 - Variation under domestication: deliberate breeding
Ch 2 - Variation under nature: indvd diffs and random chgs
Ch 3/4 - Struggle for existence and natural selection: beneficial variations are selected by nature
Remaining 11 chs - evidence and objections
Describe some evidence that Darwin collected for evolution.
- 8 year barnacle study - specimens from all around the world
- Idea of division of labor - more life in one area if diff parts of the environment were used (eg. plants grow at different depths)
Darwin left areas of his garden untouched for 3 years and documented it - Successfully planted seeds from pigeon droppings
How do species diverge?
Through the modifications that help them adapt to different places in nature
More differences lead to better chances of adapting
What is the species problem?
- How is there such diversity?
- Why do some disappear?
- Why are some similar to fossils?
- Did they all fit on Noah’s Ark?
Describe Erasmus Darwin.
Believed that organic life came from a single creature, and that species develop and advance
Humans were the culmination but could still improve