Lecture 2 Flashcards
Goals of secondary education
- promote independent thinking and make your own well-informed choices
- it used to be about socialization (religious norms, conformity)
Secondary education as we know it should not be taken for granted
- in developed countries, it used to be that only the elite and males had access to secondary education
- but in the last century the economy became the knowledge economy
- in developing countries there was the same delayed pattern -> only for males and urban middle class, and not there is a distinction between public and private schools
Differenecs between developed countries
- US: comprehensive high school
- Europe: college preparatory and vocational
- this is decided at an early age
- pro: early idea of the future, better able to tailor teaching
- con: less advantageous for those developing later
US inequalities
- distinction between public and private schools
- funding depends on state (or even district)
Japan and China
- admission to University only for highest performing students
- makes them not more unhappy
- during university it is fun and exploration
Factors promoting educational success
- wicked problem -> causality is difficult to establish
- parenting style
- SES
- school
- peers
- individual
Parenting style
- authoritative parenting style typically works best
- high demand, high responsiveness
- promotes self regulation
School
- school size (between 500-1000) (in a small school there is more chance to be invovled in extracurriculars or be on the school board, for a large school there are more courses to choose from)
- class size (20-40)
- school climate
- values
Peers
- if there are higher achieving peers -> increases grades but may decrease academic self concept
SES
- higher IQ (IQ is heritable and niche picking thing)
- better nutrition
- less health problems
- less stressors
- more involved parents
Is school a meritocracy?
- does success only depend on talent and effort or also on background and luck?
- belief in school meritocracy legitimizes inequality ( if they think school is a meritocracy they are more likely to be okay with inequality)
Individual
- if they work (paid work) hours per week <10
- motivation (C,R)
Factors promoting lack of educational success
- absenteeism: predictors include negative attitude toward school, externalizing or internalizing problems, substance abuse, low involvement of parents
- dropout: predictors include low SES, low grades, low IQ or learning problems, culmination of problems over time
Solution to prevent dropout and absenteeism
- caring teachers
- small classes
- starting early
- supplemental academic training
- employement oriented training
Motivation
- willingness to invest one’s capacities
- i.e. capacity (potential peformance) influences actual performance and this is moderated by motivation
Why is motivation important?
- it is an important predictor of school success
- Jenkins curve: percentage of students who love school massively drops as grade level increases
How to measure motivation in school contexts
- need for cognition scale: tendency to engage in and enjoy effortful cognitive endeavors
- academic delay of gratification: study a little every day for an exam in this course and spend less time with your friends, or spend more time with your friends and cram just before the test
Self regulation questionnaire academic
- autonomous
intrinsic: enjoyment, fun
identified: self valued goal, interpersonal importance - controlled
introjected: self or other approval, avoidance of disapproval
external: rule following, avoidance of punishment
Disadvantage trait indices
- cannot be used in experimental studies
motivation manipulation (STATE) (study idk i zoned out my bad)
- motivation manipulation
- ADHD kids
- assigned to three conditions: either only feedback or assigned 1 coin or 10
- peformance was lower on only feedback condition
- but if you motivate them with coins, level of performance is equal to typically developing kids
- of task is very lengthy they peform worse but with motivation given some of these impacts are decreased
Academic diligence tasks (STATE)
- motivation assessed by time spent on academic task
- diligence is domain general
Effort discounting task (STATE)
- first perform some task (i.e. working memory)
- how much should we pay you extra to redo a difficult task instead of an easy task
- if low additional amount (motivated)
- motivation depends on performance in difficult task
Lazowski: overview of motivation theories and matching educational intervention in studies
- mindset
- competence, autonomy, relatedness
- goals
- extrinsic rewards
- more ideas??
Mindset
- fixed vs growth
- very weak correlation with performance
- mindset interventions only slightly effective
- only for low SES or at risk students
- finally somebody who provides the nuance to this topic omfg
Self determination theory
- Competence -> longitudinal
- Autonomy -> choice
- Relatedness -> belonging
- fulfilment of needs increases autonomous motivation
- these do all actually increase performance but yet mainly if extrinsic rewards are not salient
Motivation: goals
- having a goal enhances motivation
- mastery goals: development of competence (negative feedback is valued as good as it fosters development)
- performance goals: demonstration of competence, negative feedback is valued as bad, as it hinders demonstration
- academic goals are among highest ranked by adolescents
If academic goals are so important why do they not devote time to school? why do they not like school?
- delay discounting: value of a goal is discounted by its delay, more so in adolescents than adults
- since the result is so far in the future
Extrinsic rewards
- extrinsic rewards do improve performance
- but they may decrease intrinsic motivation (subject to debate)
- so should be apply them? -> yes, predominantly for tasks that are not intrinsically motivating
Resilience
peforming well, despite major setbacks: i.e. low SES
Buoycancy
- performing well despite daily setbacks i.e. a poor grade
Motivation
it is to move (toward a goal), it includes intrinsic and extrinsic motivation
What does motivation entail
Trait motivation measurement
- questionnaire assessing autonomy and control