Leaseholds Flashcards
- Security of tenure, Termination of Lease, Commercial Tenancy Remedies
Security of Tenure
What tenancies cannot be contracted out of security of tenure?
Periodic tenancies
Security of Tenure
What rights does a periodic tenant not have in relation to security of tenure?
Cannot serve s.26 notice!
Commercial Landlord’s Remedies
What remedy does a Jarvis v Harris clause provide?
Allows landlord to enter property, carry out the repairs, and recover the costs from tenant as a debt.
Commercial Landlord’s Remedies
What additional information will a section 146 forfeiture notice need to include, and when is it required?
For leases with a term of 7 years of more where there are 3 years or more left.
* Notice needs to inform tenant of their right to serve a counter-notice within 28 days.
* if counter-notice is served, then landlord needs leave from court to proceed.
Commercial Landlord’s Remedies
When will a landlord serve a s.146 notice for forfeiture, and what information must be included?
Applies to breaches of all covenants except non-payment of rent.
Notice must - (i) specify the breach, (ii) require remedy of the breach within reasonable time, and (iii) require the tenant to pay compensation for the breach.
When might a tenant apply for relief from forfeiture?
- Before re-entry for court proceedings
- A reasonable time after re-entry for or in peaceable re-entry
What landlord remedies are available for breaches of repair covenants?
- Damages
- Forfeiture
- Self-help
- Specific performance
What procedure must be following for Commercial Rent Arrears Recovery?
Tenant must owe a minimum of 7 days of unpaid rent.
1) L appoints enforcement officer to serve tenant with notice of re-entry if it fails to pay-up;
2) T has 7 clear days to pay-up and if it fails to E.O can enter 🏠 and seize T’s stock; and
3) Give T additional 7 days notice if it intends of selling any of seized goods.
- cannot seize goods up to the value of £1350 that are necessary to tenant’s business.
- must be sold at a public auction.
What outstanding sums can a landlord recover by using the Commercial Rent Arrears Recovery procedure?
Annual rent + interest + VAT
❌ cannot recover service charge!
How is rent payable under a commercial FRI lease?
expressed annually, but paid quarterly.
Does a landlord have an implied right to increase rent?
No, the lease must expressly provide for open market rent review.
How is an open-market rent review conducted?
market is ascertained on basis of comparable premises and characteristics
- tenant’s breaches of covenants, tenant’s voluntary improvements are not considered.
- Landlord’s breaches are taken into account.
Security of Tenure
What is the earliest and latest date of termination of a lease when a landlord serves a section 25 notice?
Latest - 6 months from date notice is service.
Earliest - 12 months from date of service.
For a post-1996 lease, what two documents will the landlord solicitor need to draft to execute an assignment of lease?
Licence to assign and AGA
Security of Tenure
How can a landlord oppose a section 26 notice?
Serve counter-notice on tenant
within 2 months and set out statutory ground of opposition.
If counter-notice is not served, landlord loses right to oppose the new tenancy.
Security of Tenure
How can a tenant renew their tenancy following service of a s.26 notice?
apply to the court before the specified date of commencement for the new tenancy but after counter-notice period has expired.
if tenant fails to apply, then landlord can apply for termination of tenancy.
Security of Tenure
What is the notice period to serve a section 27 notice?
Tenant’s notice to terminate.
Give landlord not less than 3 months notice to terminate.
Good practice, but not needed, unless holding over has begun, then must serve with 3 months notice.
Security of Tenure
What two types of section 25 notices can a landlord serve, and what are their practical implications?
- s.25 ‘friendly’ notice - landlord wishes to renew lease.
- s.25 ‘hostile’ notice - landlord wishes to terminate lease.
Security of Tenure
What are the statutory grounds a landlord can rely on when serving a ‘hostile’ s.25 notice?
1) breach of repairing obligation (serious)
2) other substantial breaches of tenant obligations
3) persistent delay in paying rent
4) availability of suitable alternative accommodations;
5) landlord intends to occupy premises
5) intention to demolish and reconstruct premises or carry-out sustantial construction
Mnemonic - BOPALI
Security of Tenure
What statutory grounds to oppose renewal of lease are discretionary versus mandatory, and what are there respective implications?
Discretionary - if ground is made, court ‘may’ accept landlord’s application.
- breach of repair obligations
- other susbtantial breaches of tenant obligations.
- persistent delay in paying rent
Mandatory - if ground is made out, court ‘must’ find in favour of landlord.
- availability of alternative accomodation.
- landlord intends to occupy premises.
- intention to demolish/carry out substantial works
BOP (Disc) ALI (mandatory)
Security of Tenure
Following termination of a periodic tenancy, how much compensation is payable by the landlord?
Only available if mandatory grounds (save for alternative suitable accomodations are made out)
If the tenant occupied:
- less than 14 years - 1x rateable value
- 14 or more years - 2x rateable value
Security of Tenure
Can a lease exclude the right to receive compensation following termination of a protected tenancy?
Yes, but will be void if the tenant or their predecessors in the business have been in occupation for 5 years or more at the date of termination.
- Key difference between date of termination vs. date notice is served.
Security of Tenure
What is the procedure to contract out of security of tenure?
1) Landlord must serve a health warning notice on the tenant before completion of the lease.
2) Tenant must provide a declaration before completion.
- signed declaration (at least 14 days before completion)
- statutory declation (if less than 14 days until completion).
Security of Tenure
What is the extent of the court’s powers to renew a lease in a secured tenancy?
Grant a term up to 15 years to begin three months after proceedings are disposed of.
* Order for open market rent to be paid
* Any other suitable term with regard to the current tenancy and circumstances.
* New terms - provided these are fair and reasonable, with burden falling on person seeking to impose new clause to prove.
Security of Tenure
How might a court take into account the status of a old lease when exercising its powers to renew a secured tenancy?
By renewing tenancy, old lease will become a new lease.
* Loss of privity of contract may still be considered in determining the rent payable (s.34(4)).
Security of Tenure
What information should a section 26 notice contain?
Served by tenant to renew lease.
Set out terms of renewed lease in notice to landlord and state the date of commencement of new tenancy.
cannot be served later than 6 months and earlier than 12 months before proposed date of commencement.
Security of Tenure
What is interim rent?
Court has the power to fix a new rent based on an open market rent review.
- Either party can apply.
- court considers what would be a reasonable amount for tenant to pay.
Effective either from earliest date of termination that could’ve been specified in either a s.25 or s.26 notice (6 months in both cases).
- Where s.25 is served - rent is calculated at 10-15% reduction less than market value.
- Where s.26 is served - rent is at market value.
Security of Tenure
How many days does an unhappy tenant have to apply for revocation of a court’s ordered tenancy and what is the effect of doing so?
14 days
* By doing so, tenant gives up its right to renew entirely.
Security of Tenure
How does the five-year rule restrict a landlord’s statutory grounds for opposing a renewal of a secured tenancy?
a landlord must have owned their superior title for at least 5 years to rely on statutory ground to of intended reoccupation. (s.30(1)(g)).
Designed to prevent landlords from buying property’s subject to existing tenancies, with the aim of eventually vacating the premises.
- note - exclusion does not apply if landlord bought the property with vacant possession.
Lease Termination
What are the five ways a lease may be terminated?
1) effluxion of time
2) break clause in contract
3) notice to quit by tenant
4) surrender
5) merger of leasehold/freehold interest
Lease Termination
How might a sublease be affected by surrender of the headlease?
subtenant becomes the immediate tenant of the head landlord on the terms of the sublease.
Commercial Landlord’s Remedies
What are the six remedies for breaches for covenant to pay rent?
- damages
- action in debt or insolvency proceedings
- look to gurantor/rent deposit (s.17 notice)
- commercial arrears rent recovery
- forfeiture
- equitable remedies
Commercial Landlord’s Remedies
What is the limitation period to enforce a tenant’s debt?
6 years
Commercial Landlord’s Remedies
When might a landlord be granted an injunction against a tenant?
where a tenant is attempting to unlawfully assign their lease.
Commercial Landlord’s Remedies
Does a landlord have an automatic right to forfeiture?
no, lease must expressly provide for it.
Commercial Landlord’s Remedies
When is a landlord at risk of waiving their right to forfeit?
when it acknowledges a breach has occured, but fails to take action against it.
- whether a landlord’s intended to do so is immaterial.