Learning Unit 4 Flashcards
Give an example to illustrate and explain Postman and Power’s argument that “news is often made rather than gathered”
- some events have near-universal interests and consequences
- most news doesn’t even exist in the event, an event becomes news
- this occurs when it’s selected for notice out of the confusion around us
- news is more often made rather than gathered
- news is made on the basis of what journalist thinks is NB and interesting
- journalists have the power to set an agenda or change the frame
What is suggested by “we see what we expect to see ; often we focus on what we are paid to see”
- depends on journalists point of view
- subjective interpretation of the reader or listener
- the problematic nature of “facts” is that journalists see what they are paid to see
- those who lay us to see usually expect us to accept their notions not only of what is NB but of what are NB details
- we find ourselves evidence that supports our worldview
E.g. ENCA vs SABC news
Define news according to postman and powers
- a viewer must know something about the political beliefs and economic situations of those who provide news
- then the viewer can understand why some events are considered NB by those in charge of TV news and may compare those judgements with their own
- journalists try to determine what audiences think is NB and interesting
- there’s a perspective that argues against journalists imposing their own sense of significance on an audience, journalists must keep their own opinions to themselves
- many viewers depend on journalists to tell them what’s NB even if journalists were mere followers of public interest
- not all members of the audience agree on what they wish to know
- a viewer mustn’t only know what he or she thinks is significant as well
- a viewer must always take his/her relationship to a larger audience. TV is a mass medium therefore TV news show wasn’t meant for you alone
- it is public communication and the viewer needs to have some knowledge and opinions about the “public”
SH Donald Trump vs people killed in Nigeria
Why is it said that media and the broader culture are interrelated
Cultural consumption
- consuming aspects of our culture and another culture (hairstyle, food…)
Social issues
- family values, materialism, acceptance, stereotypes, inequality, awareness…
Social unity
- Are we bringing people together through watching these shows or are we driving people apart through our judgements?
Explain the marketplace of ideas metaphor with respect to policy and diversity.
- underlying theoretical justification for most diversity policies
- diversity is a key sub-component of an effectively functioning marketplace of ideas
- key dimension of the First Ammendment freedoms
- citizens are free to choose from a wide range of sources
- citizens participate in diversity to increase knowledge, encounter opposing viewpoints and become well-informed decision makers
- framework, source content and exposure diversity are the key to a self governed society
Discuss the difference between variety and diversity.
VARIETY
Raw number of outlets or content choices available.
I.e. Genre of channels
DIVERSITY
Focuses on the number of choices and the differences among them
I.e. The number of channels within a particular genre
- increasing variety may be an NB policy objective
- increases in number of outlets can potentially lead to increases in diversity
List the dimensions of diversity.
SOURCE DIVERSITY
Ownership diversity
Workforce diversity
CONTENT DIVERSITY
Format programme type diversity
Demographic diversity
Idea/Viewpoint diversity
EXPOSURE DIVERSITY
Horizontal exposure diversity
Vertical exposure diversity
Explain source diversity.
- the assumption that optimum citizen decision making arises from consideration of diverse/antagonistic info sources
- communication policy makers have historically wanted to increase diversity of sources available to media audiences
- diversity contains sub-components and source diversity is conceptualized through
- – diversity of content/ programming
- – ownership of media outlets
- – diversity of workforce within outlets
Explain ownership diversity as a sub-category of source diversity.
This is comprised of:
- diversity of content/programming
- diversity of ownership of media outlets
Explain workforce diversity as a sub-category of source diversity.
- regulations to increase diversity of sources of info include diversity of workforce within media outlet
- policy makers have regulations such as: BBBEE and FCC’s Equal Employment Opportunity for broadcast liscencees
- rules encourage broadcast to have a personnel mix that reflects the market area
- stations can’t discriminate based on gender, religion, colour, race…
- AA measures must be in place to target women and minorities so that workforce reflects market
Explain content diversity.
- second link in the diversity chain
- policies around source diversity assume that increased source diversity = increased content diversity
- policy objectives are pursued via structural regulation (affect the nature of the sources) compared to behavioural regulation (affect the actions of the sources)
- structural changes brought about by the policies are only an intermediate point on the way to achieving more far reaching policy objectives
Explain format or programme type diversity as a sub-category of content diversity.
- refers to the category designations given to radio formats and individual TV programmes
- e.g. Range of different types of TV shows from which a viewer can choose during prime time
- is comedies x2, dramas x2, movie x1, crime x1
- policy makers have generally valued this kind of diversity
Explain demographic diversity as a sub-category of content diversity.
- racial, ethnic, and gender diversity of the people featured within electronic media programmes
- minority groups and other demographic groups must be portrayed in accordance with prevalence in society
- roles on TV must reflect diversity of population including more women in the industry, therefore, source content relationship has been asserted again
- e.g. Oscars - no black actors or actresses nominated
Explain idea/viewpoint diversity as a sub-category of content diversity.
- represents the most elusive component of content diversity
- diversity of viewpoints and of social, political and cultural perspectives represented within the media
- central to the ‘marketplace of ideas’ metaphor and its relationship to effective demographic self-governance
Explain exposure diversity.
- central to comm policy because of relevance to ‘marketplace of ideas’ metaphor
- diversity of content sent vs. content received (what the audience selects)
- how many sources is audience exposed to? Are they varied? Diverse programming?
- some policy makers feel that audience exposure goes beyond the control of diversity policy and diversity perspective
- assumption that audiences that are provided with content variety, consume variety
- ‘marketplace of ideas’ cannot take place without variety or diversity exposure
- consumption of ideas (diverse) = well informed decision making