Leadership Flashcards
Definition of leadership?
-process where an individual influences group members in a way that inspires them to achieve a group goal
Mann (1959)
key traits
- looked at correlations between key personality traits and leadership
- highlighted traits of intelligence, masculinity, adjustment, dominance, extroversion, conservatism
What is the Great person theory of leadership?
- identifies leadership as a constellation almost of personality attributes that give people charisma and ability to lead
- such as above average size, healthy, physically attractive, sociable, intelligent, talkative etc
Studies on the importance of leaders?
- Barrick et al (1991) found high performing executives added 25 million dollars more than average performers to the value of company
- Joyce et al (2003) found effective CEOs improve company performance by 14%
Lippitt and White (1943)
effect of leader styles
- autocratic (liked leader less, aggressive/dependent/self-oriented atmosphere, high productivity when leader is present)
- democratic (liked leader more, friendly/task-oriented atmosphere, high productivity throughout)
- laissez-faire (like leader less, friendly/group-centred/play-oriented atmosphere, low productivity when leader is present)
Effect of charisma on leadership?
- the situation calls out for a charismatic leader, a need for change
- thought that charisma arises through behaviour and relationship with followers
Bass (1985, 1990)
leader-group relations
- distinguished between 2 types of leader-group relations
- transformational (leader provides vision/inspiration) and transactional (leader becomes involved when problems arise)
- transformational is to believed to be more effective as they inspire them to go the extra mile
- types of leader sub-categories: individualized consideration, inspirational motivation, idealized influence, intellectual stimulation
Sherif et al (1961)
- Robbers cave study
- found that when the boys were asked to move to a competitive situation they changed the leader of their group compared to the situation that required greater cooperation
Carter and Nixon (1949)
changing leaders
- looked at pairing up school pupils and asked them to do certain tasks within these pairs and found that they had different leaders based on the task that they were doing
- successful leadership reflects the situational demands rather than being purely governed by personality
What is the contingency theory?
- effectiveness of task oriented versus socio-emotional leaders is contingent on their match with the situation
- states that most important feature of the situation was the degree of situational control
- situational control is determined by the quality of leader-member relations, clarity of the structure of the task, intrinsic power and authority granted to leader by virtue of their position
- when situational control is very high/very low the task-oriented leaders are most effective
What is the least preferred co-worker scale?
- measures leadership style rather than anything relating to their co-workers
- high LPC is relationship-oriented leadership style
- low LPC is task-oriented style
Misumi and Peterson (1985)
difference in cultures
- distinguished how different cultures value task performance and group maintenance, how they may see examples of different types
- it varies in cultures, e.g. eating lunch together may be seen as group maintenance where as others may see it as something that isn’t highly important
Smith et al (1989)
- assessed task performance in the UK and the US and in Japan and Hong Kong
- asked whether they thought it was appropriate to to measure task performance by the individual or their co-workers
- in the US and UK it’s more appropriate to ask individuals (task-oriented)
- in Japan and Hong Kong it was more important to show consideration by asking co-workers (person oriented)
What are the criticisms of contingency theory?
- not sure what the LPC score is actually linked to
- scale doesn’t capture 20% of population
- low test-retest reliability
- leadership has been shown to be taught
- seems unlikely that view on leadership would be stable and fixed
What’s the social identity theory of leadership?
- leadership has identity function
- we look to our leaders to express, clarify, focus, forge and transform our identities