Leadership Flashcards
What is the trait theory?
- Assumption that leadership is determined by personal traits that not everyone has
- “trait” = unchanging and stable personality attributes
- specific attributes predispose particular individuals becoming leaders
What are examples of different trait theory school of thoughts?
1 Sanskrit literatures: 10 types of leaders with examples from history and mythology
2 Aristocrats: leadership is a certain mentality characterised by subordination of individual goals to fundamental principles that guarantee stability and strength; performance and success are conditions
3 Monarchy: Divine right and elite membership
4 Meritocracy: Leadership through accomplishment; Alexander the great
5 Autocratic/Paternal: leader is head of family model “pater familias” makes all decisions
6 Maternal Leadership: Empathy and focus on emotional well-being
7 Confucianism: Ideas of correct living; student-leader relationship; leadership based on virtues of wisdom, integrity, benevolence, courage, and discipline
Describe the leadership model of Carlyle and Galton.
- talent, skills and physical traits of men of power
- leadership attributes from families of most powerful men in England
- conclusion that ability to lead is based on certain attributes, skills and talents which can be inherited
–> Leaders are born, not made
Describe the leadership model of Stodgill and Mann.
- based on series of qualitative research to challenge notion of “leaders are born”
- comprehensive list of personal characteristics that are typical for leaders
- leaders in certain situations are not necessarily leaders in others
- shift towards behavioural patters in leadership
Describe the leadership model of Lewin, Lipitt and White.
- Behavioural taxonomy to general leadership style
- influence of different leadership styles on performance
- authoritative leadership, democratic leadership and laissez-faire
Describe behavioural leadership.
- different behavioural patters rather than individual traits are seen to create leadership conditions
- different leadership styles lead to vastly different outcomes
- successful leadership is not dependant on personal traits
- leading = situation-appropriate complex behaviour patters
Describe Positive Reinforcement.
- B.F. Skinner
- behaviour modification through learning, developed the concept of positive reinforcement
- positive response follows a reaction to specific behaviour
- behaviour will likely be repeated in the future in anticipation of receiving this
- successful mgmt. style
- careful: with situations where employees are more specialised it can be seen as patronising
Describe situational approaches in Leadership.
What is criticised about it?
- leadership is not distinguished by a permanent set of personality characteristics but an event to specific situation
- Any individual can be perceived as leader, depending on the situation and their responsibilities. Individuals will respond to the leader as a result of situational demands and actions of the leader.
- Correlation between effective leadership and individual traits such as intelligence, attitude, extraversion, conscientiousness, openness and general self-efficacy. Situation will demand the expression of these traits = required for a leader
Critique:
- concentrates on few attributes: neuroticism, extraversion, openness, agreeableness, conscientiousness and neglects cognitive skills:, motives, values, social competence, expertise, and problem solving
- do not consider behaviour patters
- do not differentiate between general attributes and attributes with situations
- do not take certain attributes and behaviour variations into account
Describe situation and contingency theories in leadership.
Which prominent leadership theories are reflecting these considerations?
- situations influence people, not the other way around
- situation theory: different situations require different attributes –> there is not single optimal leadership technique nor a set of personal attributes
- leadership behaviour depends on situation
Authoritative: best in coping with crisis
Democratic: coping with teams, consensus situations
Laissez-Faire: ideation, freedom and flexible orgas
1 Fiedler’s contingency model
2 Vroom-Yetton decision model
3 Path-goal theory of leadership effectiveness
4 Blake-Mouton managerial grid model
Describe Fiedler’s Contingency model.
Based on Situational and Contingency Theory
- interaction between leadership style and situational favourability
- two types of leaders:
1 those that tend to solve the task by developing a good relationship with the group (relationship-oriented)
2 those that focus on accomplishing the task (task-oriented)
- -> there is no ideal leader
- -> both are effective when it fits the situation
Describe the Vroom-Yetton decision model.
Based on Situational and Contingency Theory.
- taxonomy to describe leadership styles that are determined by situation
- leadership behaviour should be based on a normative decision model which defines what approach is the most suitable to the situation
> Leader should decide how to lead their subordinates based on specific situational circumstances
Describe the path-goal theory of leadership effectiveness.
Based on Situational and Contingency Theory
- by House based on Vroom-Yetton
- Leaders should influence their subordinates in such a way that they develop skills and abilities that complement the resolution of the situation and possible compensate for existing deficiencies in managing it
Four types of appropriate behaviour: 1 Achievement orientation 2 Directive leader behaviour 3 Participate leader behaviour 4 Supportive leader behaviour
! ! ! Sees leadership behavior as process that calls for different strategies dep situation
> leaders have to be able to use all four flexibly
contingency and transactional model that focuses on interaction between leader and employees
Describe the Blake-Mouton managerial grid model.
Based on Situational and Contingency Theory
- Five different leadership styles that are based on factors of employee orientation and task orientation
- leader should be in 9.9 (high/high)
- extensive training problem was created to train people how to get there
- difficult to put into practice due to the length of time required to support employees and pressure to produce
Describe the theory of functional leadership behaviour.
- assumption: managers are expected to behave in a way that facilitates orga efficiency
- success of the orga depends on the effectiveness and cohesion of the group
> leadership is an individual that strengthens the group cohesion and goal orientation and is separated from orga leadership (role clarity and insecurity reduction)
> leader is responsible to do whatever its group needs
two primary behaviours of managers:
1 testing existing structures
2 creating supportive structures that facilitate task fulfilment
Describe the integrated psychological theory.
- Scouller (2011)
- Combines strengths of older theories (attribute, leadership style, situational, function) together
- expands these by adding: Ongoing personal development of the leaders
1 attribute theory - leader is born - are not useful for development of leaders
2 one ideal leadership style cannot be applied to all situations
3 most situational, contingency and functional theories assume that leaders are able to change their behaviour according to circumstances –> difficult in practice due to unconscious beliefs, fears, habits, etc.
> no older theories focus on trust, leadership presence, inspiring others, gaining trust, etc.
Three levels of leadership:
1 public ls
2 private ls
3 personal ls
Public/private = types of behaviour: four dimensions of leadership 1 a shared motivating group purpose 2 measures of progress and results 3 collective unity or team sprit 4 individual selection and motivation
Personal
- internal sate of an invidious can be developed to have a stronger leadership role, presence, know-how and aptitude
1 technical know-how and ability
2 developing correct attitude towards others
(foundation for authentic leadership)
> inner self-control is key towards trusting relationships
What is transactional leadership?
What is transformational leadership?
Transactional:
- relationship between a group and its leader in relation to achieving objectives
- assigning tasks and rewards achievement for performance
- sanctions for non-performance
- focused on instruments of power =employees follow to reach objective
- MBO
Transformational:
- based on transactional with additional dimension
- admiration, trust, and respect shown towards the leader
- leaders are role models:
1 convey connection
2 challenge employees to think critically
3 coach them
4 encourage good performance
5 strive to align employee goals + orga goals
Why is Leadership an emotionally charged process?
- leadership climate has significant impact on employees
1 mood of the individual employees are influenced by leaders and their attitude (“emotional infection”
2 affective tone of the group influences the mood of employees
3 group dynamic process resulting from mutual tasks, efforts and goals all influence feelings
> positive mood improves performance of the group
Leaders must create situations that lead to emotional reactions (feedback, assigning tasks, distributing resources)
Emotional reaction must be understood and handled correctly for the climate (emotional intelligence
Describe the Neo-Emergent Theory.
- Oxford School of Leadership
- leadership mainly takes place through transmission or orga of information about leaders and their behaviour
- not really based on actual actions of leaders
e. g. American elections:
- based on political motivation
- highly edited press releases
- public is steered towards special emotional reactions
Why are roles important for Leadership?
What are characteristics of roles?
- leadership cannot be understood by simply analysing attributes and actions of leaders
- leadership should be considered an event created in the interaction between individuals assuming the roles of leader and follower
- roles can be defined as the actual and tangible forms which the self takes - every role is a fusion of private and collective elements. Every role has a private and a collective side
1 Roles are specific
2 Roles are formed by the individual
3 Roles are the result of individual skill and the expectation of the group
What are groups?
What is important as a result for managers?
- defined as communicative networks and conventionally some form of leadership
- common objective that connects and unifies members
- each member in group has an allocated task
- interaction patterns within a group evolve over time to clarify who does what when
- role can thus be considered a socially defined pattern that is expected of a group member
Important:
> roles in a group are independent of role-bearer, because what is expected of the role-bearer does not change, regardless of whom has undertaken the role
> difference between personal behaviour and role behaviour
What functional roles exist?
1 Initiator: Suggests new direction, solution, procedure
2 Information seeker: questions new ideas, checks for validity and accuracy
3 Information giver: consults on expert opinions, facts, etc.
4 Opinion seeker: tries to find relevant values and beliefs to solve team task, focused on opinion instead of facts
5 Opinion giver: contributes values and beliefs
6 Evaluator: develops concepts, rate proposals for practicability, logic, etc.
7 Doer: does what the team assigned them
8 Internal rules and regulations practitioner: takes care of group necessities, follows procedure, etc.
9 Secretary: takes minutes, writes reports
What are socio-emotional roles?
1 Encourager:
- gives others positive feedback
- praises, rewards, supports
2 Peacemaker:
- acts as diplomat and is responsible for consensus
- tries to reach agreement
3 Compromise maker:
- tries to defuse conflicts through compromises and avoidance
4 Tension appeaser:
- can spontaneously break the ice, facilitates friendly atmosphere
- can help others relax and diffuse tension
5 Confronter:
- proactive in preventing the team from conflicts
- opposes excessive coziness that impacts on performance
What are destructive roles?
1 Chatter: takes long to say something
2 Pedant: always includes unimportant details
3 Inspiration producer: normally says the first good idea
4 Definer: fights tooth and nail about concepts
5 Fence sitter: does not want to and will not commit
6 Defeatist: constantly voices an uneasy feeling without constructive sugg.
7 Procrastinator: postpones everything till later when more facts are available
8 Troublemaker: chats so loudly that overall process is disturbed
9 Personalizer: takes everything personally and is offended
10 Manipulator: want to influence people with praise and flattery
11: dominator expects to get her way in everything
What is important for managers about role types?
- functional, socio-emotional, destructive roles
- each individual can take on different roles or even several roles at a time
- depending on situation the contribution of all roles types should be acknowledged
- recognising different roles is a very big challenge for managers
- leaders are subject to different expectation as they correspond with different role types
> Focus Leadership: offset and unite the differences of the group members in their different roles and ensure no-one is frozen
role type and situational context go together
responding appropriately to different role patters and their demands, maintaining fairness between roles and respecting strengths and limitations