lay magistrates Flashcards
what are the lay magistrates
unpaid part time judges who have no legal qualifications and hear cases in the magistrate’s courts
qualification of lay magistrate’s
good character understanding and communication social awareness maturity and sound temperament sound judgement commitment and reliability
appointment of lay magistrates
in order to decide who to appoint , the judge relies on recommendation made by the local advisory committee
what are the interview panels
2 stage interview process
what happens in the first interview
tries to find out more about the candidate’s personnal attributes
what happens in the second interview
test the candidates’ potential judicial aptitude and this is done by a discussion of at least two case studies which are typical of those heard regularly in magistrates’ court
how are trained the lay magistrates
supervised by the magisterial committee of the judicial college
most training delivered locally
appraisal
composition of the bench
17,500 lay magistrates: 47% men 53%women good representation of ethnic minorities only 3% are under the age of 40
role of magistrates
deal with all summary offences
deal with triable either-way offences where defendant chooses trail in the CM
deal with preliminary issues:bails and remands
transfer indictable case to the crown court
youth court
family court
what is the magistrate’s clerck
a legal adviser
what is the clercks’ duty
to guide the magistrates on questions of law
what are the 3 m
middle-class
middle-aged
middle-minded
what people can be found in the magistrates’ court
bench of lay magistrates
clerk of the court
solicitors/barristers
legal executive
advantages of lay magistrates
Local knowledge of the area in which they serve (Paul v DPP)
Few appeals
They represent a cross section of society and the bench aims to be balanced
Cheap and cost effective
Great public confidence in Magistrates
disadvantages of lay magistrates
Not a ‘trial by peers’, contrary to trial by Juries - Magistrates convict about 90% of all cases
Too much reliance on Legal Advisers