Law - Vocabulary and Concepts Flashcards
Advanced Sheets (court reporter)
Advanced Sheets are the cases issued in pamphlet form prior to their publication in the bound volumes.
American Law Reports (2nd’ary) A.L.R.
American Law Reports (2nd’ary) (West) = A.L.R. = provides
- editorial discussion on the topic of law
- reports leading to cases
- summaries of important cases
- cross-reference to West Key No.
- Index to Annotations: Table of Laws, Rules & Regs, and Annotation History Table
Annotations - by atty. generals
Annotations - by atty. generals
- The Atty. General gave an interpretation of part or all of the law.
- Annotations by Atty. Generals have some authority, but…
- Only Persuasive, NOT Precedent Holding.
Annotations - of a case
Annotations - of a case
Case annotations are short paragraphs on how courts have interpreted and applied the statute.
They help you understand how the case is relevant to your case.
What can a person APPEAL?
An appellant can only appeal on “questions of law”, and not questions of facts.
An appellant can only claim the trial judge made errors in application of law principles but not of facts
Everyone has the right to ONE appeal.
Appellate Court (define, and functions)
an Appellate Court hears appeals from the trial courts within its jurisdiction (i.e. within its purview). It can be called Supreme Court, or Court of Appeals, or Supreme Judicial Court. . an Appellate Court usually accepts the facts found (determined) by the trial court. It does not ordinarily consider facts or witnesses or factual events (when, what, where) because all that was done by the trial court. . an Appellate Court is to assess and decide the claim that the trial court committed legal error. Legal errors could be: - Prejudicial rulings: admitting or excluding testimony or evidence - Mistakes in law-application, in selecting and applying rules, insufficient evidence to prove the case - Violation of state or federal constitutional provisions
Appellate Court (names and structure)
The highest court in many states is called the Supreme Court, or the Court of Appeals, or the Supreme Judicial Court. In the federal court system, the highest court is the United States Supreme Court. Then there are intermediate appellate court, or the United States Court of Appeals, which is organized on a regional basis into 12 circuits + 1 Federal Circuit.
Binding Precedent
a Binding Precedent means - - a decision of a court in a prior case controls the decision in future cases with similar facts and issues - for both the deciding court and for all inferior (lower) courts within the same jurisdiction. (remember: within the same jurisdiction) a Binding Precedent is both a norm (should) and a prediction (expected).
Brief (a court brief)
A court brief is a concise outline of an actual court decision
Brief (a lawsuit brief)
embodies the points of law which attorney desires to establish, together with arguments and authorities, upon which to rest his contention
Brief (a court document)
a Brief (in the meaning of a court document) is - a formal written argument - submitted to a court - at a motion, during trial, or on appeal
Brief (of a case)
- A Brief of a case is a summary of the important elements of a published case. It contains - - facts - procedural history - issue - holding - judgement - reasoning.
- Briefing a case means dissecting and summarizing the parts of a case to understand the whole.
Briefing a case - basic steps
Briefing a case - basic steps
- Read the opinion
- Heading
- **Facts **
- **Procedural history **
- Issues
- Judgment
- Holding
- Law / legal principle applied
- Reasoning
- Concurring / Dissenting
- Add’l comments or impression? (your own)
Briefing a case - Comments/Impression
Briefing a case - Comments/Impression
This is YOUR OWN comments / impressions:
- Your reactions and critique of the opinion
- What you like or dislike
- Is the reasoning sound, contradictory, not logical?
- What is the political, economic, social impact?
- Is the decision similar to those in similar cases? (in line with other cases?)
Briefing a case - Concur/Dissent
Briefing a case - Concur/Dissent
A judge may write dissenting opinion OR a separate concurring opinion (if agreeing with the decision, but disagreeing with the logic / reasoning)
***The only thing to summarize in a concurrence or dissent is the RATIONALE of the Justice***
Briefing a case - Decision
Briefing a case - Decision
The DECISION in a Case Brief summarizes
- the rules of law
- how the rules of law applied to the facts
- what conclusion the (appellate) court reached
Use the IRAC method for the DECISION of a Case Brief
IRAC = (Response to) Issue, Rule of law, Analysis of the rationale and how it applied the law to the fact, Conclusion
Briefing a case - Statement of Facts
Briefing a case - Statement of Facts
a. Identify parties, relationship, status
b. Relevant facts to tell what happened that led to the parties suing each other (Why the controversy?)
c. Procedural facts: (1) cause of action (C/A); i.e. what law was broken, (2) relief sought by plaintiff, (3) defense raised by defendant
Briefing a case - Heading
Briefing a case - Heading
a. Case name ( to identify parties)
b. Court name
c. Date of decision
d. Page of number on case book
Briefing a case - Holding
Briefing a case - Holding
Holding is a statement of law = the court’s answer to the appealed issue.
Holding = either positive or negative of the statement of Issues
Holding = not just a Yes or No. May start with a Yes or No, but must explain Reasoning WHY
Briefing a case - Issues
Briefing a case - Issues
- The statement of issue s/b written in ONE SINGLE SENTENCE - usually a YES or NO Question*
- The question s/b phrased as a LEGAL QUESTION because it describe the legal problem the court solved.*
a. Substantive Issues - Law in dispute
- Legally relevant facts (what led to the dispute of law)
b. Procedural issues: Why the appellant claimed the lower court was wrong (ruling on evidence, jury instructions, judgment, etc.)
Briefing a case - Judgment
Briefing a case - Judgment
What is this court’s final decision?
This court’s response to the appellant? Affirm, reverse, reverse w/ instruction, remanded for clarification, etc.?
Briefing a case - Law / Legal Principle
Briefing a case - Law / Legal Principle
Rule of Law / Legal Principle =
- What the court applies to determine the substantive rights of the parties.
- Could be a Statute, a Case Rule, a Regulation, or prior cases’ holdings (common law)
- Can be expressly or implied
Briefing a case - Legal Procedure
Briefing a case - Nature of Case
Briefing a case - Procedural Basis
Briefing a case - Procedural Basis / Nature of Case / Legal Procedure
= a very short statement - ONE SENTENCE - to explain how and why the case is presented before the (appellate?) court.
(you must know the legal procedure really well to do this, but this part of the case brief is of very little importance. However, if the case has enough info to do this, you must do it in a case brief).
Briefing a case - Nature of Case
Briefing a case - Legal Procedure
Briefing a case - Procedural Basis
Briefing a case - Procedural Basis / Nature of Case / Legal Procedure
= a very short statement - ONE SENTENCE - to explain how and why the case is presented before the (appellate?) court.
(you must know the legal procedure really well to do this, but this part of the case brief is of very little importance. However, if the case has enough info to do this, you must do it in a case brief).