Law test 2 Flashcards
Confederation Debates
- February 3rd - March 13th 1865
- Parliament debated the confederation of British colonies, aimed to create a union from Newfoundland to Lake Superior
- John A. Macdonald wanted a strong central power
- Alexander Galt put forth economic arguments for union
Amending Formula
A series of procedures that are listed from s. 38 - s.49 of the Constitution Act. It wasn’t easy to create because all the Provinces wanted to make sure that they had a say if/when the Constitution changed
Entrenchment
A system that makes certain amendments either more difficult or impossible to pass.
Pith and Substance
The first tool used by the courts to determine which level of government has authority over a certain matter/issue
- Asks what the essential matter of the law is by using intrinsic and extrinsic evidence
- the true aim of a piece of legislation of the government of Nova Scotia was to stop abortion clinics from being set up in the province. That much is clear from the transcripts of the debate in the legislature. However, the legislation itself was written to appear to be aimed at regulation of medical services within hospitals. The Supreme Court saw through the wording of the legislation and instead looked at those debates to come to its conclusion as to the true purpose of the legislation
Power of Disallowance
An authority granted to the governor general in council (federal cabinet) to Invalidate an act (also called a statute) passed by a provincial legislature
Soverignty-Association
The combination of two concepts: the achievement of sovereignty for the Quebec state and the creation of a political and economic association between this new independent state and Canada
- Aims to make Quebec a sovereign state while still maintaining economic connections with Canada
Patrition of the Constitution
Saw the provinces granted influence in Constitutional matters and resulted in the Constitution being amendable by Canada only, with no role for the United Kingdom
Supreme Court of Canada
- The highest court in the judicial system of Canada
- Has nine justices
- The ultimate judicial power
- Hears both Common and Civil Law cases
British North America Act, 1867
- Recieved royal assent on March 29th 1867
- United the territories Nova Scotia and New Brunswick into a single dominion called Canada
Constitution Act 1867
- Originally known as the BNA Act
- The rest is the BNA Act
Canada’s Unwritten Constitution (Convention)
-Unwritten Constitutions identified by the Supreme Court:
- Federalism
- Democracy
- Constitutionalsim and the rule of law
- Respect for Minorities
- The separation of powers and the independence of the judiciary
Court Decisions
- A judicial determination of a parties rights and obligations reached by a court based on facts and law
Federal vs. Provincial Level of Governments (Sections 91 and 92)
Division of Power
- The governmental powers and duties are split between two levels
- National (Central/Federal) and many smaller ones (provincial)
- Areas of jurisdiction were outlined at the Quebec Conference in 1864
Municipal Government
Division of Powers
- Under the provincial government
- Responsible for providing services within the local boundaries such as:
- Airports, ambulances, animal control and by-law enforcement
Education
Division of Powers
- Section 93 of the Constitution Act, 1867
- Each province can make legislation exclusivley in relation to education
The Structure of the Courts
- Trial level courts hear Civil and Criminal cases: Can be called Supreme Court, the Court of Queen’s Bench, or the Superior Court of Justice
- Appeal Level courts/Courts of Appeal: hear civil and criminal appeals from the superior trial courts listed above
Judicial Committee of the Privy Council
- Highest court of appeal for many Commonwealth countries
The Persons Case
- Edwards v. A.G. of Canada, 1927
- The ruling that established the right of women to be appointed to the Senate
Statute of Westminster, 1931
- An act of the Parliament of the UK that sets the basis for the relationship between the dominion (Commonwealth realms) and the Crown
- An Act to give effect to certain resolutions passed in Conferences heald in the years 1926 and 1930
- Gave Dominions full legal authority except in areas they didn’t want
Patrition of the Constitution
- In 1982, Canada “patriated” its Constitution
- It transferred the country’s highest law (the British North America Act) from under the British Paliament to Canada’s fedreal/provincial legislatures
The Meech Lake Accord
- A series of proposed amendments to the Constitution, negotiated in 1987 by PM Brian Mulroney
- Intended to persuade the government of Quebec to symbolically endorsw the 1982 constitutional amendments by providing decentralization of the Canadian federation
- There were concers about lack of citizen involvement in the drafting
- Passing of the Accord failed and greatly increased tensions between Quebec and the rest of Canada, sparking a renewed interest in the Quebec sovereignty movement
The Charlottetown Accord
- Proposed amendments to the Constitution of Canada by the federal and provincial governments (1992)
- Submitted to a public referendum on October 26th and then defeated
- Formally institutionalized the federal-provincial-territorial consulatative process and provided Aboriginal inclusion in certain circumstances
1995 Quebec Referendum
- The second referendum to ask voters in Quebec whether or not they should declare sovereignty from Canada
Reasonable Limits
- The limitation must have merit or importance in order to justify overriding a constitutionally protected right
Strike Down
- To abolish a law or regulation
Notwithstanding Clause
- Section 33
- Allows Parliament or the legislature of a province to derogate from certain sections of the Charter, namely section 2
- Prevents a court from invalidating a law that violates Charter provisions that relate to fundamental freedoms and equality rights (section 15)
Read Down
- Instead of striking down the law, the courts reword it in order to make it consistent with constitutional/legal principles so it can still be passed, just differently
English Common Law and Customs
- The greatest influence on our government and laws
- Systems of adjudication varied and were influenced by local custom and superstition (trial by ordeal or trial by combat)
- King Henry II trained circuit judges who traveled and held assizes (traveling courts) and heard local cases
- As judges made their rulings, they wrote their decisions and legal reasoning. Other judges could consult the decision. This was known as case law or common law, because it allowed the law to be applied in a common fashion throughout the country.
- Henry also established the jury system. The right to a trial by jury was broadened under King John who was forced to sign the Magna Carta which brought in two legal principals: Rule of law and Habeas Corpus
Canadian Bill of Rights and Limitations
- 1960
- Banned enslavement, torture, and arbitrary arrest and detention
- Enshrined the right to be presumed innocent, and the right to work
- Applied only to federal statutes, not provincial ones
The Victoria Charter
- Proposed amendments to the Constitution of Canada in 1971
- Failed attempt to patriate the Consitution, add a bill of rights and entrench English and French as Canada’s official languages
- Later suceeded on these objectives in 1982
The Charter as Law
- The Charter reflects a positive-law perspective, by including the “reasonable limits clause.” Section 1 states that any rights guaranteed by the Charter may be limited “by reasonable limits prescribed by law.” Section 33, known as the notwithstanding clause also permits Parliament or the provinces to declare a law valid even when it violates a right guaranteed in the Charter, such as the “French Sign Law” in Quebec
Rights and Freedoms
- Outlines/protects rights and freedoms such as freedom of expression and the right to equality
- Forms a part of the Constitution
Fundamental Freedoms (Section 2)
- Freedom of consiousness and religion
- Freedom of thought, belief, opinon and expression, including freedom of the press
- Freedom of peaceful assembly
- Freedom of association
Democratic Rights (Sections 3 to 5)
- Right to vote
- Right to campaign
- Right to seek elected office