Land weak areas Flashcards
Which rules to use for positive covenant
Must use common law
Passing of burden in common law
CANNOT pass - 3 exceptions:
* Doctrine of mutual benefit + burden
* Chain of indemnity covenants (as only burden of restrictive covenants pass - allows them to sue)
* Lease - both restrictive + covenants bind (except personal ones)
Requirements for doctrine of mutual benefit & burden
- Benefit + burden must be linked
- Benefit + burden conferred in same transaction
- Genuine choice as to whether to accept
Passing of benefit in common law
Can pass by:
1. Express assignment or
2. Implied assignment
Requirements for express assignment (passing of benefit under law)
a) must take place at same time as transfer
b) must be in writing (& signed?)
c) written notice must be given to original covenantor (person with burden)
Requirements for implied assignment (passing of benefit under law)
a) covenant must touch + concern the DL
b) intention for benefit to run with DL (express in cov or implied by statute UNLESS personal/excluded)
c) original covenantee must have held legal estate in DL
d) successor must hold legal estate in DL (need not be same type e.g. LH/FH)
TILL
What does touch & concern the land mean?
a) only benefit dom owner while they own DL
b) affect nature, quality, use or value of DL
c) NOT be expressly personal
Passing of burden under equitable rules
Tulk v Moxhay - RAIN:
1. Must be restrictive
2. Must accommodate DL
3. Must be intention for burden to run with DL (express in cov or implied by statute UNLESS personal / excluded)
4. Must be notice (notice in CH of SL OR D(ii) land charge)
What does accommodate the DL mean (passing burden under equity)?
a) original covenantee + successors must have retained an interest in DL at time of creation + enforcement
b) covenant must touch + concern the land (see other flashcard)
c) sufficient proximity between DL + SL
PIT (think rain pitter patter)
What if the restrictive covenant is not protected as notice or D(ii) land charge?
Purchaser for value not bound - donee is!
Passing of benefit under equitable rules
(1) Covenant must touch + concern DL
(2) Successor to original covenantee must have legal or equitable estate in benefited land
(3) Intention that benefit run with DL, i.e.:
* Express annexation in cov OR automatic statutory annexation (UNLESS personal/excluded)
* Express assignment
* Building scheme
LIT
Building scheme requirements
a) all buyers buy from same seller
b) seller divided estate into plots
c) covenants were intended to benefit ALL plots
d) each buyer buys on understanding that covenants intended to benefit ALL plots
treated as by-laws that are reciprocally enforceable by plot owners
Effect of registrable disposition of registered estate for valuable consideration
Takes effect over ANY pre-existing rights in the land, EXCEPT:
* those protected on register
* overriding interests
any that should have been protected but were not are lost forever!
NOTE donees take the land subject to ALL pre-existing interests, irrespective of whether they have been protected via registration!
5 types of registrable disposition
- Transfer of registered estate
- Grant of new lease of more than 7 years
- Grant of legal charge / mortgage
- Express grant / reservation of legal easement
- Grant of LL’s right of entry
What is meaning of registrable dispositions
Do not operate at law until registered!
3 categories relevant to registered land
- Registrable dispositions
- Interests protected by entry (minor interests)
- Overriding interests
Who do minor interests (those protected by entry) bind?
Bind 3rd party purchase for value if protected by:
* notice, or
* restriction
NOTE: donee bound regardless!
Effect of a notice in register
Doesn’t guarantee proper creation / existence of interest - only that IF it has been properly created, it will be binding on buyer
Registered land
Which interests are protected by notice
a) home rights
b) estate contracts
c) equitable easements
d) equitable leases
e) freehold restrictive covenants
Registered land
Which interests are protected by restriction
a) LH restrictive covenant
b) Trusts of land
Where a trust exists, what is purpose of restriction in proprietorship register
To help ensure overreaching occurs
Does overreaching apply to both registered and unregistered land?
Yes
How does overreaching take place?
By paying the capital money to at least 2 trustees - must not be paid direct to the beneficiaries unless they are also a trustee
What are overriding interests
Bind any purchaser even if not protected by registration