Brainscape's Knowledge GenomeTM


Top Flashcards (Certified)
All Flashcards

(FLK1) Tort Law > Land Torts > Flashcards

Land Torts Flashcards

1
Q

What are the Land Torts?

A
  • Public Nuisance.
  • Private Nuisance.
  • Trespass to Land.
  • The Rule in Rylands v Fletcher.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

What are the Elements of Private Nuisance?

A
  • Indirect Interference.
  • Recognised Damage.
  • Continuity of Action.
  • Unlawful Interference.

Always Remember: Private Nuisance is a Tort against the Land, not the Land Owner.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

Regarding Private Nuisance, what constitutes Indirect Interference?

A

An Act on the Defendant’s Land that impinges upon the Claimant’s use or enjoyment of its Land.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

Regarding Private Nuisance, what are the Recognised Types of Damage?

A

Physical Damage to Property:

  • The Nuisance causes non-trivial physical damage to the Claimant’s Property.

Sensible Personal Discomfort (“SPD”):

  • The Claimant’s senses are affected such that they cannot enjoy their Land.
  • This must be reasonably Foreseeable and materially interfere with normal human comfort.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

Regarding Private Nuisance, what are the Exceptions to the Continuity Requisite?

A
  • The Act creates a State of Affairs that risks the escape of physically dangerous or damaging material.
  • The Act is a single incident caused by an Underlying State of Affairs of which the Defendant has Actual or Constructive Knowledge.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

Regarding Private Nuisance, what constitutes Unlawful Interference?

A

The Act constitutes an Unreasonable Use of the Defendant’s Land. Relevant considerations include:

  • Time.
  • Malice.
  • Duration.
  • Frequency.
  • Lack of Care.
  • Excessiveness.
  • Locality’s Character (SPD Only).

Although things like Planning Permissions are relevant to a Locality’s Character, they are not necessarily determinative.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

Regarding Private Nuisance, what is the Position on Claimants with Abnormal Sensitivity?

A
  • If the standard of material interference with normal human comfort is met;
  • Then the Claimant can sue for the full extent of its Loss as aggravted by its condition.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

Who can Sue in Private Nuisance?

A

Anyone with a Legal (Proprietary) Interest in the Affected Land. This includes:

  • The Title Owner.
  • The Tenant in Possession.
  • The Grantee of an Easement.
  • The Licensee with Exclusive Possession.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

Who can be Sued in Private Nuisance?

A
  • Creator of the Nuisance.
  • Owner of the Nuisance Land.
  • Occupier of the Nuisance Land.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

When may the Occupier of the Nuisance Land be held Liable?

A

Independent Contractors:

  • The Occupier hires an Independent Contractor that will cause an inevitable Nuisance.

Natural Occurrence:

  • The Occupier is aware, or ought to be, of a naturally-occuring Nuisance; and
  • Fails to take reasonable steps to end it.

Adoption or Continuation:

  • The Occupier is aware, or ought to be, of a Nuisance caused by another; and
  • Fails to take reasonable steps to end it.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

When may the Owner of the Nuisance Land be held Liable?

A

The Owner:

  • Authorised the Nuisance by directly and actively participating therein; or
  • By Leasing the Property under circumstances where Nuisance was a virtual certainty.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

What are the Defences to Private Nuisance?

A
  • Consent.
  • Necessity.
  • Act of God.
  • Act of Third Party.
  • Statutory Authority.
  • 20 Years’ Prescription.
  • Contributory Negligence.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

Regarding Private Nuisance, when does the Defence of Consent apply?

A

The Claimant willingly accepts the Nuisance, or the risk thereof, by words or conduct.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

Regarding Private Nuisance, when does the Defence of Necessity apply?

A

The Act is essential for the Public Good and there is no reasonable alternative.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

Regarding Private Nuisance, when does the Third-Party-Act Defence apply?

A

The Nuisance was created by a Third Party for whom the Defendant is not responsible (barring Adoption or Continuation).

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

Regarding Private Nuisance, when does the Act-of-God Defence apply?

A

The Nuisance was created by an Act of God (barring Adoption or Continuation).

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

Regarding Private Nuisance, when does the Defence of Statutory Authority apply?

A

The Act is:

  • Authorised by Statute;
  • Exercised with all due care and skill; and
  • Inevitably causes the Nuisance.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

Regarding Private Nuisance, when does the Defence of 20 Years’ Prescription apply?

A
  • The Act has been an actionable Nuisance for at least 20 Years; and
  • No action has ever been taken.

The Period starts from when the Act becomes a Nuisance.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

What are the Remedies for Private Nuisance?

A
  • Damages.
  • Injunction.
  • Abatement.

Injunctions are the primary Remedy.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
20
Q

Regarding Private Nuisance, how are Damages awarded?

A

Physical Damage:

  • Consequential Economic Loss; and
  • The lesser of either Repair or Renewal Costs.

Sensible Personal Discomfort:

  • The Defendant may argue that Damages should be awarded instead of an Injunciton.
    • Relevant considerations include Public Benefits, Planning Permissions, and commecial impacts.
  • If successful, the Court will award based on the consequent decrease in Property Value.
21
Q

Regarding Private Nuisance, when may the Court only award a Partial Injunction?

A

When the Act has a Public Benefit.

22
Q

Regarding Private Nuisance, what is Abatement?

A
  • The Claimant’s entitlement to enter the Defendant’s Property and do what is reasonable and necessary to end the Nuisance.
  • Notice is necessary, unless it is an emergency.
23
Q

What are the Elements Public Nuisance?

A

Act or Omission:

  • The Defendant performed, or failed to perform, a particular Act.

Continuity (or Lack Thereof):

  • The Act or Omission was either continuous or singular.

Class:

  • The Act or Omission affected a representative cross-section of a Class of Subjects in a similar manner, time, and place.

Material Disruption of Comfort and Convenience:

  • The Act or Omission materially disrupted the comfort, convenience, or normal use of a public space; which
  • Had a substantial and reasonably foreseeable impact on the Public’s ability to ordinarily enjoy or use it.
24
Q

Regarding Public Nuisance, which Types of Damage are Recoverable?

A
  • Personal Injury.
  • Property Damage.
  • Pure Economic Loss.
  • Material Inconvenience.
  • Consequential Economic Loss.
25
Who can Sue in Public Nuisance?
* **Individuals**. * **Local Authorities**. * The **Attorney General**.
26
When can an Individual Sue in Public Nuisance?
When it has suffered **Special Damage**, meaning it has suffered **direct and substantial Damage**: * **Over and above** the rest of the **Class**; or * **In a different way** to the rest of the **Class**.
27
Who can be Sued in Public Nuisance?
The **Creater** of the **Nuisance** or **any other person responsible** therefor.
28
What are the Defences for Public Nuisance?
* **Necessity**. * **Act** of **God**. * **Act** of **Third Party**. * **Statutory Authority**. * **Contributory Negligence**. ## Footnote The **main Defence** is **Statutory Authority**.
29
What are the Remedies for Public Nuisance?
* **Damages**. * **Injunction**. ## Footnote **Damages** are **unavailable** if the **Claim** is **brought** by the **Local Authority** or the **Attorney General**.
30
What are the Elements of Trespass to Land?
**Direct and Physical Interference:** * The Defendant directly and physically interfered with the Claimant's Land. * This includes causing Third Parties to enter or placing, throwing, or diverting objects onto the Land. * Interference can be continuing if the object unlawfully placed, thrown, or diverted remains on the Land. **Intention to Interfere** * The Defendant's Interference was a deliberate, intentional act. **Lack of Lawful Justification or Consent** * The Defendant's Interference was unlawful, unnecessary, and without consent.
31
Regarding Trespass to Land, what constitutes the 'Land'?
* The **Ground**. * The **Subsoil**, **down** to the point where the **notion of ownership** is **absurd**. * The **Airspace**, **up** to the point **necessary** for **ordinary use and enjoyment** of the Land.
32
Who can Sue in Trespass to Land?
**Anyone** with a **Possessory Interest** in the Land.
33
Who can be Sued in Trespass to Land?
The **Trespasser**.
34
What are the Defences for Trespass to Land?
* **Consent**. * **Necessity**. * **Abatement**. * **Lawful Authority**.
35
Regarding Trespass to Land, what are the Two Types of Necessity?
* **Public Necessity:** Entry to prevent a Public Disaster (e.g., firefighting efforts). * **Private Necessity:** Entry to protect Oneself or one's Property from imminent harm.
36
What are the Remedies for Trespass to Land?
* **Re-Entry**. * **Damages**. * **Injunctions**. * **Mesne Profits**. * **Recovery of Land**. ## Footnote **Trespass is actionable *per se***.
37
Regarding Trespass to Land, what is the Remedy of Re-Entry?
The **Claimant's right** to **retake possession** of **their Land** using **reasonable force**.
38
Regarding Trespass to Land, what is the Remedy of Mesne Profits?
* **Compensation** for the **profits made** or **expenses saved** by the Defendant **while Trespassing**. * The **Claimant** must **evidence** the **Defendant's profits** or the **Land's rental value**, respectively.
39
Regarding Trespass to Land, what is the Remedy of Recovery of Land?
A **Court Order** to **remove** the **Defendant** from the **Claimant's Land**.
40
What are the Elements of the Rule in Rylands v Fletcher?
**Introduction of Object to the Defendant's Land:** * The Defendant voluntarily brings an Object it controls onto its Land. * This is called Accumulation. **Capacity for Damage upon Escape:** * The Object has an exceptionally high risk of causing damage if it Escapes. * The Defendant has Actual or Constructive Knowledge of the Object's destructive capacity if it Escapes. **Escape to the Claimant's Land:** * The Object itself Escapes from the Defendant's Land to the Claimant's Land. **Foreseeable Harm to the Claimant's Land:** * The Escaped Object causes Foreseeable Harm to the Claimant's Land. * Reasonable care to prevent Escape will not avoid Liability. **Unnatural Use of the Defendant Land:** * The Defendant's use of its Land was extraordinary and unusual by contemporary standards, all things considered.
41
Who can Sue in the Rule in Rylands v Fletcher?
**Anyone** with a **Possessory Interest** in the Land.
42
Who can be Sued in the Rule in Rylands v Fletcher?
* **Creator** of the **Nuisance**. * **Owner** of the **Nuisance Land**. * **Occupier** of the **Nuisance Land**.
43
Regarding the Rule in Rylands v Fletcher, what are the Recognised Types of Damage?
* **Property Damage**. * **Consequential Economic Loss**.
44
What are the Defences for the Rule in Rylands v Fletcher?
* **Consent**. * **Act** of **God**. * **Common Benefit**. * **Act** of **Third Party**. * **Statutory Authority**. * **Default** of the **Claimant**.
45
Regarding the Rule in Rylands v Fletcher, what is the Act-of-God Defence?
The **Escape** was **caused** by a **reasonably Unforeseeable natural event**.
46
Regarding the Rule in Rylands v Fletcher, what is the Defence of Common Benefit?
If the **Claimant derived** a **Common Benefit** from **Accumulation**, it is deemed to have **implicitly consented** thereto.
47
Regarding the Rule in Rylands v Fletcher, what is the Third-Party-Act Defence?
The **Escape** was **caused** by an **Unforeseeable act** of a **Third Party** over whom the **Defendant had no control**.
48
Regarding the Rule in Rylands v Fletcher, what is the Defence of Default of the Claimant?
**Escape** was **caused wholly** by the **Claimant**.
49
What are the Remedies for the Rule in Rylands v Fletcher?
* **Damages**. * **Injunction**. ## Footnote **Damages** are the **main Remedy**.

(FLK1) Tort Law (6 decks)

Brainscape helps you reach your goals faster, through stronger study habits.
© 2025 Bold Learning Solutions. Terms and Conditions