Land - Co-ownership Flashcards
Jones v Kennott
Domestic situations may change over time. Important to take into account intention and size of contributions. Resulting trusts not appropriate. Become TENANTS IN COMMON (severing with unequal shares is unanswered).
Stack v Dowden
Presumption of JOINT TENANTS in domestic situations .
Malaysian Credit Ltd v Jack Chia MPH Ltd
Presumption of TENANTS IN COMMON in commercial contexts.
Lake v Gibson
Presumption of TENANTS IN COMMON where unequal contributions are made. Approved by Bull v Bull.
Morley v Bird
Presumption of TENANTS IN COMMON where a share has been mortgaged or granted to a secure loan
Goodman v Gallant
Severing JOINT TENANT beneficial interests will result in TENANTS IN COMMON with equal shares.
Ways to sever JOINT TENANT beneficial interest
1) Notice in writing - clear, served on all Joint Tenants at last known address by recorded delivery 2) 3 ways identified under Williams v Hensman 3) Forfeiture - cannot benefit from crime (Estate of Hall principle applied in Dunbar v Plant)
88 Berkeley Road
Notice to sever is valid even if not received
Ways to end co-ownership
1) Partition 2) Sale and division of proceeds 3) Union of interest (death of other joint tenants or by agreement)
Williams v Hensman
Identified 3 other ways to sever the JOINT TENANT beneficial interest: 1) operating under own share destroying the 4 unities, alienation via mortgage, declared bankrupt (share passes to mortgagor) 2) mutual agreement (supported by Burgess v Rawnsley) which is unenforceable but evidence of intention to sever which is enough (confirmed in Hunter v Babbage) 3) interests of all are mutually treated as being TENANTS IN COMMON (obiter dicta in Burgess v Rawnsley).
Harris v Goddard
Severance must be immediate
Tizard
Trust imposed when interest acquired due to conduct (eg contribution to purchase price)
Selling the property
- seek an order for sale from courts (TOLATA ss14, 15) - cannot exclude from property even if beneficial interest v legal - Bull v Bull - need court order (see 1) - can be made to pay rent to other co-owners TOLATA s 13 if required to balance in equity (supported in Stack v Dowden)
Bedson v Bedson
“share” for tenants in common is proportionate to the number of joint tenants prior to severance
Flegg
Equitable interests can be overreached if certain conditions are met - disposition to 2+ trustees, signed by all trustees, capital monies paid to all trustees
Kinch v Bullard
If severance sent by registered post - shall be deemed severed when would in the ordinary course be delievered