Labor Law Flashcards
Wagner Act of 1935
NLRA; Sections 7 8 and 9
Concerted Activity
NLRA Sec. 7; act to enforce CBA or band with other workers for better work conditions; for the mutual benefit of all employees or bargaining unit.
NLRB Structure
5 board members - 5 yr terms; GC 4 yr term; four divisions; regional offices/attorneys; ALJ
Unfair Labor Practice
NLRA Sec. 8; 6 months SOL; file “CHARGE” with Regional office.
ULP by Employer
NLRA Sec. 8(a): no interference, restraint, or coercion.
Can ULP strikers be replaced?
No.
ULP by Union
NLRA Sec. 8(b); union cannot restrain, coerce with respect to Sec. 7 rights; cannot engage in secondary boycott; cannot picket for recognitional or org. purposes longer than 30 days; no “hot cargo” agreement
30-day picket rule
Sec. 8(b)(C); it’s an ULP for union/ EE to picket for recognition for more than 30 days
secondary boycott rule
not allowed per Sec. 8(b)(4); union cannot force boycott of secondary employer who does business with employer with whom union has a dispute.
“hot cargo” rule
cannot require an employer to not do business with some other person with whom the union has a dispute (NLRA Sec. 8(b)(8))
Taft-Hartley Act of 1947
aka Labor Management Relations Act; prohibited union ULP; makes CBA enforceable in federal court.
Landrum-Griffin Act of 1959
aka Labor-Management Reporting and Disclosure Act; regulates union activity; broadened coverage of secondary boycott provisions and partially restricted representational picketing rights of union.
Does NLRB adjudicate labor issues in bankruptcy case?
No, the Bankruptcy judge does.
When does NLRB hear a case about ULP?
Only when complaint is issued. GC discretion is unreviewable.
Equitable tolling for ULP complaint SOL
possible if fraudulent concealment
3 ways to establish union representation
Voluntary by employer; Bargaining (“Gissel”) Order; Election Petition
Election Petitions
Certification of Representation (“RC”); Representation petition (“RM”); Decertification Petition (“RD”); Withdrawal of Union Shop Authority petition (“UD”); Unit Clarification (“UC”); Amendment of Certification (“AC”)
RC petition
Filed by employees or union. Must have at least 30% “showing of interest”
RM petition
filed by ER; no showing of interest required; ER must have reasonable basis to believe incumbent no longer represents majority.
RD petition
filed by employees if 30%< no longer want union representation
Election Bar
one year from date of preceding final and valid election
Certification Bar
one year from certification date (not election date)
Contract Bar
Term of CBA or 3 years, whichever is shorter, during which rival union cannot file petition except between 90-60 days before expiration of CBA
Sabine Pilot
exception to at will; SOLE reason for discharge must be refusal to do an illegal act that would subject EE to criminal liability; must be discharged
Mixed motive in Sabine Pilot?
No.
Private COA for whistleblower in TX?
No, unless in one of the occupations that has statutory protection.
Duty to investigate before terminate EE?
No statutory
SOL for Pay day claim
180 days to file with TWC but no admin prerequisite
Vicarious liability for negligence by EE
must have been engaged in duties & activities within scope of employment; strict liability for higher employee acting on behalf of ER; ER knew or should have known
negligent hiring/retention
ER knows or should have known w/ exercise of reasonable care that EE was incompetent, unfit, or otherwise dangerous and ER failed to take reasonable measures to prevent injury to others
Joint employer
share control
Whistleblower SOL for public employees
90 days.
Chapter 451 of Tex. Labor Code
Workers’ Comp. statute: Protects against discrim/retaliation
What ER are covered by TLC Ch. 451
Only subscribers
EE BOP for Ch. 451 claim
(1) filed a WC claim in good faith or instituted a proceed (2) causal connection with AEA and (3) “but for” causation (mixed motive okay)
Texas Covenant Not to Compete statute
Tex. Bus & Comm Code Secs. 15.50 - 15.52
CNC to be enforceable, must be…
ancillary to an otherwise enforceable agreement (supported by consideration more than $$).
CNC reasonable limitations of…
scope, geography, time
Time period usually found reasonable for CNC
2-5 years, depending on balancing ER interest with EE interest
CNC must not…
“impose a greater restraint than is necessary to protect the goodwill and business interests of the ER”
blue pencil
Court may revise CNC if overly broad or strike out; ER cannot recover damages, only injunctive relief
Non-solicitation agreements
same test at CNC under the Act
Can lawyers and doctors have CNC?
No for lawyers. Doctors must have access to 1-year patients list.
Remedies for violating CNC
Actual; punitive if fraud or malice; injunctive relief; attorneys’ fees; civil penalties for theft of trade secrets (TUTSA)
Texas Arbitration Act
ARB agreement must be in writing, signed by each party, reference by incorporation okay, and must meet general terms of a K; like FAA, court doesn’t have discretion not to enforce ARB agreement
FAA vs. Tex Arb Act
TAA excludes several types of claims that FAA doesn’t, so FAA preempts if it applies.
FAA
interstate commerce; contract has clear agreement; meets other contract rules; court must enforce ARB; court cannot vacate ARB award unless one of 4 facts apply. Presumption in favor of ARB
to vacate an ARB award under the FAA:
court must find (1) award was procured by corruption, fraud or undue means; (2) there is evidence of partiality or corruption among arbitrators; (3) arbitrators were guilty of misconduct which prejudiced rights of one party; (4) or arbitrators exceeded their powers.
FCRA
Fair Credit Reporting Act
FCRA applies to what?
When ERs use credit reporting agency to obtain background info re applicant or EE
FCRA rules
must obtain written consent from applicant/ EE; must provide results to EE within 3 business days (3 days for invest. CR) if taking AEA and provide reason and rights under FCRA; FCRA applies to credit reports and investigative Consumer reports; EE has right to contest in 60 days and right to know who the CRA is. ER must certify to CRA that ER followed FCRA rules. FCRA disclosure and acknowledgment must be separate document(s); if applicant requests- ER must provide full CR disclosure within 5 days of request; there is individual liability.
Penalties for violating FCRA
actual damages ($100-$1,000); punitive, costs and attorneys’ fees. No punitive for negligent noncompliance.
FCRA rules for EE making less than $75k/year
CRA may not supply ER with info re 10+ yr old bankruptcy and not other adverse info (e.g., tax liens, credit collection, convictions, etc.) 7+ years old
SOL for FCRA
2 years after EE discovers, not more than 5 years after occurred
Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964
protects certain groups; applies to ER with 15+ employees
EE req’t of T 7
15+ (any) employees in each of 20+ calendar weeks in the current or proceeding calendar year
EEOC requirements for T 7 claim
file with EEOC in 300 days (180 days if file with TWC); 90 days file suit after RTS letter
TCHRA requirements for TWC
180 days to file with TWC; 60 days to file suit after RTS letter.
T 7 protected classes
RNCLRS: Race, National Origin, Color, Religion, Sex (includes gender and pregnancy)
THCRA protected classes
RNCLRS + age and disability (15+ employees even for age)
BFOQ
bonafide qualification: Defense to discrim claim; must relate to essence of central mission of ER’s business. not available for Race or Color
McDonnell Douglas burden-shifting framework
(circumstantial cases only) Burden of proof always with plaintiff; if est. prima facie case, then burden of persuasion shifts to ER; if ER proffers LNDR; then burden shifts back to EE to rebut with pretext.
Causation / mixed motive in T 7 claims
but for causation if mixed motive: ER must show that it would have taken AEA absent impermissible factor
T 7 prima facie disrimin case
(a) protected class (b) qualified for job (c) AEA (d) because of protected class or treated less favorably or replaced by someone not in protected class.
Retaliation
(a) engaged in protected activity (b) AEA (c) causal connection
AEA
adverse employment action that affects term or condition of employment
harassment
egregious; affects work conditions
quid pro quo
sexual harassment; offer benefit in exchange for sexual act
protected activity
oppose or participate in an action that EE reasonably believes violates T 7 (objective standard)
disparate impact
neutral policies applied equally have disproportionate adverse effect on protected group
After acquired evidence
may be a defense to limit damages; ER shows that it would have taken same AEA if it discovered AAE
duty to mitigate
EE must try to find comparable job; does not need to lower standards, but may need to lower sights. Is not required to take substantially lesser job.
Remedies for T 7 / TCHRA violation
reinstatement (but front wages if no reinstatement); injunction; lost wages (back & front pay); interest; compensatory; punitive; attorneys’ fees/costs
Punitive damages for T 7 violation
if violation was willful (knowing, malicious; or reckless)
Statutory caps under T 7
for comp/pun damages only: 15 - 100 [$50k] 101-200 [$100k] 201-500 [$200k] 500+ [$300k]
ADEA damages
same as T 7 except no comp/punitive damages
Can defendant get attnys fees if prevails?
Yes, if suit was frivolous or w/o foundation
Religious accommodation
affirmative duty to accommodate religious practice for sincerely held belief if not an UNDUE hardship
Undue hardship under T 7
If ER cannot accommodate because cost is too high
Posting and recordkeeping for EEOC
EEOC must be posted in conspicuous location; EEO-1 must be filed by ER with 100+ ee (not gov’t or schools, or tax exempt private membership clubs); EEO-1 includes breakdown of EE according to race, sex and ethnic categories; filed annually
42 USC 1981 (SOL and caps/EE reqt)
no admin prereq; race only (right to contract); does not apply to Fed employees; 4 year SOL; no caps; no min EE required
CRA of 1991
provided for jury trials for T 7 and ADA; placed statutory caps; codified disparate impact theory; extended to American ERs operating abroad