L3. Guidance for Standards I-VII Flashcards
1. Demonstrate the application for the Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct to situation involving issues of professional integrity 2. Distinguish between conduct that conforms to the code and standards and the conduct that violates the code of standards 3. Recommend practices and procedures designed to prevent violation of the code of ethics and standards of professional conduct
Members and candidates must adhere to the following principles
- Comply with the applicable laws (law that governs conduct) or regulations related to their professional activities
- Must not engage in conduct that constitutes a violation of the code and standards, even though it may be legal
- In absence of applicable law or when code and standards impose a higher degree of responsibility than applicable laws and regulations, must adhere to code and standards
1A. Recommended procedures for compliance (Members are candidates)
- Stayed informed: regularly informed about the changes in applicable laws, rules and regulations and case law. Participate in internal or external education program
- Review procedures: On regular basis to ensure procedures reflect current law and provide adequate guidance to employees about permissible conduct
- Maintain current file: Maintain readily accessible current references copies of applicable statutes, rules and regulations and important cases
1A. Recommended procedures for compliance (Distribution area laws)
Make reasonable efforts to understand applicable laws, both country and regional for where their investment products are developed and distributed
1A. Recommended procedures for compliance (Legal counsel)
Seek advice of compliance personnel or legal counsel concerning legal requirements or compliance department
1A. Recommended procedures for compliance (Disassociation)
Document violation and urge firms to attempt to persuade perpetrators to cease such conduct
1A. Recommended procedures for compliance (Firms)
- Develop and/or adopt code of ethics
- Provide information on applicable laws
- Establish procedures for reporting violations
Standards I
Applications of the standard
Standard I (Professionalism)
a) Standard I(A) Knowledge of the law
- Notification of known violations
- Dissociating from a Violation
- Following the highest requirements
- Laws and Regulations based on religious tenets
- Reporting potential unethical actions
- Failure to maintain knowledge of the law
b) Standard I (B) Independence and objectivity
- Travel expenses
- Research Independence
- Research independence and intrafirm pressure
- Research independence and issuer relationship pressure)
- Research independence and sales pressure
- Research independence and prior coverage
- Gifts and entertainment from related parties
c) Standard I (C) - Misrepresentation
- Disclosure of issuer- paid research
- Correction of unintentional errors
- Non-correction of known errors
- Plagiarism
- Misrepresentation of information
- Potential information misrepresentation
- Representing out of date information
d) Standard I (D) - Misconduct
- Professionalism and competence
- Fraud and deceit
- Personal actions and integrity
Types of pressure - Standard 1B
- Buy side clients
- Fund manager and custodial relationships
- Investment banking relationships
- Performance measurement and attribution
- Public companies
- Credit rating agency opinions
- Influence during the manager selection/ procurement process
- Issuer- paid research
- Travel funding
1B. Recommended procedures for compliance (Protect the integrity of opinions)
Establish policies stating that every research report concerning the securities of a client should reflect unbiased opinion of the analyst, design compensation systems that protect integrity of investment decision process
1B. Recommended procedures for compliance (Create restricted list)
Remove controversial company from research universe and place it on restricted list
1B. Recommended procedures for compliance (Restrict special cost arrangement)
No corporate insurer should reimburse members for air transportation or not always be hosted by insurer
1B. Recommended procedures for compliance (Limit gifts)
Limit acceptance of gratuities. However, does not preclude customary, ordinary business related entertainment as long as purpose is not the influence
1B. Recommended procedures for compliance (Restrict investments)
Encourage investment firms to develop formal policies related to employee purchases
1B. Recommended procedures for compliance (Review procedures)
Implement effective supervisory and review procedures to ensure analysts and portfolio manager comply with policies relating to personal investment activities
1B. Recommended procedures for compliance (Independence policy)
Establish policy on independence and objectivity of research and implement reporting structures and review procedures to ensure that research analysts do not report to and are not supervised or controlled by any department of the firm that could compromise the independence of the analyst
1B. Recommended procedures for compliance (Appointed officer)
Appoint senior officer with oversight responsibilities for compliance with the firm’s code of ethics and all regulations concerning its business
(Guidance) Types of misinterpretations
- Impact on investment practice
- qualifications, credentials or performance record
- exercise care when incorporating third party information - Performance reporting
- benchmark selection process that are not comparable to their strategy - Social media
- provide information that are allowed to be distributed - Omissions
- when certain inputs are omitted, resulting outcomes may provide misleading information - Plagiarism
- forms include; a) take research done by others and release as own b) using excerpts from articles prepared by others with only slight change in wording without acknowledgement c) citing specific quotations as attributable to leading analysts and investment experts without naming specific references d) using charts and graphs without stating references
- includes oral plagiarism
- Work completed for employer
- work done and completed while employed by a firm are property of the firm cannot be reissued under his/her name
1C. Recommended procedures for compliance (Factual Representations)
Provide a list of facts about the company or appoint authorised employees to speak on behalf of the company
1C. Recommended procedures for compliance (Qualification summary)
Firm can assist by reviewing employee correspondences that contain representations of individual or firm qualifications
1C. Recommended procedures for compliance (Verify outside information)
Responsible for credibility when providing information to clients on third party sources
1C. Recommended procedures for compliance (Maintain webpages)
Contain current information
1C. Recommended procedures for compliance (Plagiarism policy)
- Maintain copies
- Attribute quotations
- Attribute summaries
1D. Recommended procedures for compliance (Code of ethics)
Develop code of ethics to which all employees must subscribe
1D. Recommended procedures for compliance (List of violations)
Disseminate a list of potential violations and associated disciplinary sanctions
1D. Recommended procedures for compliance (Employee references)
Ensure employees are of good character and not ineligible to work in the investment industry because of past infractions of the law
Standards II
Applications of the standard
Standard II (Integrity of capital markets)
a) Standard II(A) Material nonpublic information
- Acting on nonpublic information
- Controlling nonpublic information
- Selective disclosure of material information
- Determining materiality
- Analyst recommendations as material nonpublic information
b) Market manipulation
- Independent analysis and company promotion
- Personal trading practices and price and or volume
- Creating artificial price volatility
- Pump priming strategy
- Pump and dump strategy
What is material information?
Information is material if its disclosure have an impact on the price of a security or if reasonable investors would want to know the information before making a decision. Eg; earnings, merges and acquisitions, innovative product, new patents, change in management, bankruptcies etc
- source of information also determines materiality; the less reliable, less likely info will be considered material. Educated conjecture by subject experts not involved in trials is unlikely to be material
What constitutes non public information?
Until it has been disseminated or is available to marketplace in general (as opposed to a selected group of investors)
If individual uses info provided legitimately by source company for specific purpose such as conducting due diligence for activities such as mergers, no violation BUT if used to do trade or entice others to trade, then there is a conflict with the standard
(Guidance) Mosaic Theory
Analyst gathering and interprets information from sources inclusive on nonmaterial nonpublic information provided by the source company directly; analyst are free to act on this collection without risking violation
- Analyst are free to use mosaic information in their research reports but should save and document all their research. Evidence of analysts’ knowledge of public and nonmaterial nonpublic information about a company strengthens the assertion that conclusion is reached solely through appropriate methods rather than the use of material nonpublic information
2A. Recommended procedures for compliance (Achieve public dissemination)
Encourage issuing company to make information public
2A. Recommended procedures for compliance (Adopt compliance procedures)
Especially compliance in such as areas such as review of employee and proprietary trading, review of investment recommendations, document of firm procedures, and the supervision of interdepartmental communications in multiservice firms
2A. Recommended procedures for compliance (Adopt disclosure procedures)
Companies should share information equitably irregardless of where the analysts comes from or if they have a history of writing negative reports
2A. Recommended procedures for compliance (Firewall elements)
Prevent the communication of material nonpublic information within firms, using firewall as barrier. Min. elements of such system includes;
- Substantial control of relevant interdepartmental communications
- Review of employee trading through the maintenance of ‘watch’ ‘restricted’ and ‘rumour’ lists
- Documentation of the procedures designed to limit the flow of information between departments
- Heightened review or restriction of proprietary trading while a firm is in possession of material nonpublic information
2A. Recommended procedures for compliance (Personal Trading Limitations)
Employees should make periodic reports of their own transactions and transactions made for the benefit of family members. Securities should be placed on restricted list when a firm has material nonpublic information
(Guidance) Market manipulation
Includes practices that distort security prices or trading volume with the intent to deceive people or entitles that rely on information in the market
Includes dissemination of false or misleading information
Includes transactions that deceive or would likely to mislead market participants by distorting price setting mechanism of financial instruments
(Guidance) Information based manipulation
Spreading false rumours to induce trading by others
; refrain from pumping up price of an investment by issuing misleading positive information or overly optimistic projections of a security’s worth only to later dump the investment once the price, reaches an artificially high level
(Guidance) Transaction based manipulation
When an individual knew or should have known that his actions could affect the pricing of a security; transaction that artificially affect prices or volume to give impression of activity or price movement in a financial instrument or securing a controlling, dominant position in a financial instrument to exploit and manipulate the price of a related derivative or underlying asset
Standards III
Applications of the standard
Standard III (Duties to clients)
a) Standard III(A) Loyalty, prudence and care
- Identifying the client
- Client commission practices
- Brokerage arrangements
- Excessive trading
b) Standard III(B) Fair dealing
- Selective disclosure
- Fair dealing between Funds
- Fair dealing and transaction allocation
c) Standard III(C) Suitability
- Investment suitability - Risk profile
- IPS updating
- Following an investment mandate
- IPS requirements and limitations
d) Standard III(D) Performance Presentation
- Performance calculation and length of time
- Performance calculation and asset weighting
- Performance attribution changes
d) Standard III(E) Preservation of confidentiality
- Possessing confidential information
- Disclosing confidential information
- Disclosing possible illegal activity
Members and candidates are considered to have custody when;
They have direct or indirect access to client funds
(Guidance) Identifying actual investment client
Not always so direct. When an investment manager managing the personal assets of an individual, client is easily identified. But when manager is responsible for portfolios of pension plans or trusts, the client is not the person or entity who hires the manager but the beneficiaries of the plan/trust
(Guidance) Soft dollars or soft commission policies are
When an investment manager uses client brokerage to purchase research services; paying higher brokerage commission that he would normally pay to allow for the purchase of goods/services without corresponding benefit to the client violates the duty of loyalty to the client.
Eg. An example would be a mutual fund receiving research and advising services in return for sending order flow through a brokerage desk
3A. Recommended procedures for compliance (Regular account information)
Submit to each client, at least quarterly, an itemised statement showing funds and securities in the custody or possession of the member or candidate.
Disclose where the assets are to be maintained or where or when they are moved
Separate clients’ assets from any other party’s assets
3A. Recommended procedures for compliance (Client approval)
When uncertain about course of action with respect to a client, should disclose questionable matter in writing to client and obtain approval
3A. Recommended procedures for compliance (Firm policies)
Should include;
1. Follow all applicable rules and laws
- Establish investment objectives of client; make reasonable inquiry into client’s experience, risk and return objectives and financial constraints before making recommendations
- Consider all information before taking action; suitability of investment relative to 1) client’s needs and circumstances 2) investment’s basic characteristics 3) basic characteristics of total portfolio
- Diversify; reduce loss
- Carry out regular reviews
- Deal fairly with all clients with respect to investment actions
- Disclose conflict of interests
- Disclose compensation arrangements
- Maintain confidentiality
- Seek best execution; refers to trading process that seeks to maximise value of portfolio within client’s stated investment objectives and constraints
(Guidance) (Investment recommendation) Recommendation that is disseminated outside the organisation is considered a communication for general distribution
Information must be disseminated in a manner that all clients have a fair opportunity to act on every recommendation
(Guidance) (Investment action) Distributing shares fairly to all customers whom investments are appropriate
If issue is oversubscribed, should be prorated to all subscribers. Members should forgo sales for themselves or family members unless managed similarly to accounts of other clients
3B. Recommended procedures for compliance (Firm policies)
Initial recommendations be made available to all customers who indicate an interest. Points to consider when establishing fair dealing compliance;
- Limit number of people involved
- Shorten time frame between decision and dissemination
- Publish guidelines for pre-dissemination behaviour; prohibit personnel who have prior knowledge of recommendation from discussing or taking action
- Simultaneous dissemination
3B. Recommended procedures for compliance (Disclose trade allocation procedures)
How they select accounts to participate in an order and how they determine the amount of securities each account will buy/sell
3B. Recommended procedures for compliance (Establish systematic account review)
To ensure no customer or client given preferential treatment and actions taken are favourable to account’s objectives