L08-L10 Pharmacovigilance Flashcards
What are the objectives of establishing the Health Products Regulation Group within HSA?
1) Safeguard public health
- Ensure appropriate technical standards (quality, safety & efficacy) are met
- Facilitate recalls, product withdrawals
2) Facilitate
- Access to safe, good quality and efficacious health products
- Support development of a high quality healthcare system
3) Assure
- Instill trust, confidence and credibility of products at home and abroad
List the range of products regulated by HSA.
Investigational drugs Medical devices Cosmetics Therapeutic products Complementary health products Tobacco products Advanced therapy products (e.g. CTGT products)
Which categories of health products are subjected to the highest level of control by HSA?
1) Therapeutic products
- POM
- POME
- P-only (OTC)
- GSL
2) Medical devices
- Class A has the lowest risk
- Class D has the highest risk
Which category of complementary health products has a higher level of regulatory control, as compared to its peers?
Chinese proprietary medicines
- Required to list products with HSA
Explain the role of HSA in the risk management framework in ensuring the safe & effective use of quality drugs in Singapore.
1) Risk-based approach titrated according to inherent risks
- High risk: Therapeutic products
- Low risk: Complementary health products, cosmetics
2) More stringent controls adopted for high risk products
- Therapeutic products: Pre- & post-market controls
- CPMs: Listing process (reduced registration controls) & post-market controls
- Cosmetics: Notification process & post-market controls
- Others: Post-market controls
3) Approval of therapeutic products by HSA only occurs when benefits outweighs risks for intended population & use
- Tolerance for risk is higher for drugs that treat serious & life-threatening diseases or diseases w/ few or no alternative Tx options
- Balance of benefit/risk ratio continues to be monitored post-marketing; regulatory action taken when benefit/risk ratio changes
- NO PRODUCT IS RISK-FREE!
List the various crises & the year of occurrence that influenced the development of the pharmacovigilance framework.
1) Sulfanilamide tragedy (1937)
- Led to US FDA Food, Drug & Cosmetic Act to establish safety requirements
2) Thalidomide tragedy (1950s)
- Led to development of congenital abnormalities in babies & taken off the market in 1961
- Led to 1962 Kefauver-Harris Amendment to US FDA Food, Drug & Cosmetic Act to establish efficacy and clinical trial requirements
3) Practolol (1975)
- Resulted in “Prescription Event Monitoring (PEM)” program in UK & NZ
4) Biologicals prepared from bovine material (1990)
- Resulted in sophisticated concept to reduce risks & use of cattle-derived medicines
5) Rofecoxib (2004)
- Caused MI more frequently than classical NSAIDs w/ higher GI toxicity
- Resulted in comparison of risks between medications i.e. risk/risk balancing
Define ‘adverse drug reaction’.
WHO definition:
Reaction that is noxious/harmful and unintended and occurs at doses normally used in man for prophylaxis, diagnosis or treatment of disease of the modification of physiological function
- Exclude overdose, drug abuse & medication errors
Define ‘side effect’.
Any unintended effect occurring at doses normally used in humans that is related to pharmacological properties of drug
- Can refer to positive or negative effect
Differentiate between ‘adverse events’ & ‘adverse reactions’.
AE: Causality not implied.
ADR: Causality assumed; i.e. this event would NOT have happened if the drug had not been taken
Calculate the true frequency of clozapine-induced agranulocytosis occurring, when WBC counts were performed for 2100 participants in a randomised clinical trial, with a confidence interval of 95%.
True frequency of ADR (i.e. agranulocytosis) <= 1/700
Rule of Three:
For statistical reasons, in the event that a given ADR was not detected in clinical trial w/ population of certain size, it is only possible to rule out w/ 95% CI that point estimate for frequency of ADR is NOT higher than 3 times the size of the investigated population.
What are some limitations of conducting clinical trials to detect serious, rare ADR?
1) Clinical trial is usually designed to test efficacy & detect common ADR, BUT NOT serious, rare ADR!
2) Cumulative sample size exposed to drug, before the drug is marketed, is usually 1500-3000 patients, which is too small to pick out serious, rare ADR!
- Less for CTGT products; more for vaccine trials
3) Too short a duration of 1-3 years to pick out serious, rare ADR
4) Concerns that some ADRs may occur after Tx for > 6 months
Define ‘pharmacovigilance’.
Science of collecting, monitoring, researching, assessing and evaluating information from healthcare providers and patients on the adverse effect of medicines, biological products, herbal and traditional medicines, with a view to identifying new information about hazards and preventing harm to patients.
Explain the relevance of pharmacovigilance.
1) Circumvent limitations of clinical trials
2) Determine genetic/environmental influences
3) Biomedical sciences form the 4th pllar of economic engine, thus the need to monitor for ADR of medicinal products.
4) Ageing population encourages polypharmacy and diminished hepatic/renal functions increases risk of ADR occurring.
5) Increasing use of complementary medicines
List the steps of the pharmacovigilance framework.
1) Signal / risk detection
- Monitoring ADRs to detect risks & changes in risk/benefit profiles
2) Risk assessment
- Assessing risk/benefit profile
3) Risk minimization
- Minimising risk by appropriate regulatory actions
4) Risk communication
- Communicating information to optimise safe and effective use
Describe how signal detection works in the pharmacovigilance framework.
1) Early indicator or warning of a potential new problem with a drug, or class of drug
- Reported info on possible causal relationship between adverse event and drug
- Relationship being unknown or incompletely documented previously
- Usually > 1 report required to generate signal
2) Hypothesis w/ data & arguments that support it from one or more sources
3) Evidence in signal is NOT conclusive & is ONLY an early indication
- May change substantially over time as more data accumulates
- Further investigation may or may not lead to conclusion that product caused event
4) May provide additional or new information about adverse or beneficial effects of an intervention, or information about an already-known association of a drug w/ an adverse drug effect
- e.g. range of severity, postulating MOA, indicating at-risk group, suspected dose range, pharmaceutical group-effect or lack of effect etc.
__% of approved drugs have serious adverse effects undetected prior to approval.
50%
Which local data source is less successful in Singapore in identifying potential signals in the pharmacovigilance framework?
Registries for selected drugs
Name some sources of potential signals captured in pharmacovigilance.
1) Pre-market (i.e. clinical trials)
2) Post-market
3) International data
- WHO International Drug Monitoring Programme
- Environmental scanning (e.g. literature, media reports, info from other regulatory agencies)
- International regulatory exchanges
4) Local data
- HCP
- Autopsy reports and toxicology labs
- Active surveillance initiatives (e.g. Critical Medication Information Store - CMIS, sentinel sites, registries for selected drugs)
- Mandatory reporting by SG law of drug companies
What are some advantages of ADR reporting?
Operates for all drugs given to patients
Operates throughout entirety of drug’s lifespan
Relatively inexpensive to operate (vs clinical trials)
Accessible to all physicians/dentists/pharmacists
Can provide rapid identification of newly identified ADR
What are some disadvantages of ADR reporting?
Low level of reporting worldwide
Schemes require HCPs to recognise ADRs
- Recognition complicated by many ADRs mimicking naturally-occurring illnesses
Data collected relate to suspected associations only
Unable to provide incidence rates because of lack of denominator data
- i.e. unable to know fully how many people are exposed to drug
- Clinical trials are more accurate
What criteria should be captured during signal detection when using a qualitative method?
Frequency Nature / type of event Time to onset Duration Attempts to rechallenge / dechallenge
List the available methods used for quantitative signal detection in pharmacovigilance.
1) Frequentist methods
- Proportional reporting ratio (PRR)
- Reporting odds ratio (RRR)
- Sequential probability ratio tests (SPRT)
2) Bayesian approaches
- Applied to signal detection and clinical trials
- Bayesian Confidence Propagation Neural Network information component (BCPNN) / WHO
- Multi-item GPS Gamma Poisson Shrinker
- Empirical Bayes Geometric Mean (EBGM)