Key Theorists - Control, Punishment and Victims Flashcards
Key Theorist – Clarke (1992): Situational Crime Prevention
WHAT DOES TH THEORISTS ARGUE ABOUT SITUATIONAL CRIME PREVENTION STRATEGIES?
- This method limits the opportunity to commit crime by reducing efforts and reducing rewards.
- By removing opportunities, less crime will take place.
Key Theorist – Clarke (1992): Situational Crime Prevention
HOW CAN THIS THEORY BE EVALUATED?
GIVE AT LEAST ONE EXAMPLE.
At least one from:
- This theory assumes that crimes are committed on a rational basis (the view that criminals act rationally, weighing up the costs and benefits of a crime opportunity before deciding whether to commit it), but this is often not the case.
- Chaiken et al argue that this type of crime prevention does not reduce crime, as criminals just relocate to where the crime is easier to commit.
- Assumes crime is opportunistic and not due to underlying social structures (e.g. capitalism).
- Ignores underlying issues e.g. poverty.
- The theory focuses on state crime and doesn’t take into account other types of crime e.g. tax evasion and fraud.
- Situational crime prevention works to some extent in reducing certain types of crime.
Key Theorists - Chaiken et al: Evaluating Situational Crime Prevention
WHAT DOES THIS THEORIST ARGUE?
- Criminals will get round the issue of situational crime prevention by displacing the place in which they commit the crime.
Key Theorists - Chaiken et al: Evaluating Situational Crime Prevention
WHAT IS SPATIAL DISPLACEMENT?
- Moving somewhere else to commit the crime.
Key Theorists - Chaiken et al: Evaluating Situational Crime Prevention
WHAT IS TEMPORAL DISPLACEMENT?
- Committing the crime at a different time.
Key Theorists - Chaiken et al: Evaluating Situational Crime Prevention
WHAT IS TARGET DISPLACEMENT?
- Choosing a different victim.
Key Theorists - Chaiken et al: Evaluating Situational Crime Prevention
WHAT IS TACTICAL DISPLACEMENT?
- Using a different method to commit the crime.
Key Theorists - Chaiken et al: Evaluating Situational Crime Prevention
WHAT IS FUNCTIONAL DISPLACEMENT?
- Committing a different type of crime.
Key Theorists – Wilson and Kelling: Environmental Crime Prevention Strategies
WHAT THEORY DID THEY COME UP WITH?
- Broken window theory.
Key Theorists – Wilson and Kelling: Environmental Crime Prevention Strategies
WHAT DO THESE THEORISTS ARGUE?
- If issues such as dog fouling, noise and beggars are left unfixed, this gives a message that no one cares and leads to a spiral of decline.
Key Theorists – Wilson and Kelling: Environmental Crime Prevention Strategies
WHAT TWO STRATEGIES DO THEY SUGGEST SHOULD BE IMPLEMENTED TO PREVENT CRIME?
- Environmental improvement - tow abandoned cars, fix windows (change the appearance of the environment).
- Zero tolerance policing- not just as a reaction to crime but any disorder even if it is not illegal.
Key Theorists – Wilson and Kelling: Environmental Crime Prevention Strategies
HOW CAN THIS THEORY BE EVALUATED?
GIVE AT LEAST ONE EXAMPLE.
At least one from:
- In New York zero tolerance policing showed positive results: from 1993 - 1996 homicide fell by 50%.
- However, in New York at the time there were 7000 extra police officers and a general decline in crime in general in the USA at the time.
- While homicides declined, attempted murders increased.
- Zero tolerance policing is popular in the UK and USA.
- Zero tolerance policing and environmental changes may help to some extent, but the root causes of why crimes are often committed e.g. poverty, is not being dealt with.
Key Theorists – Newburn and Rock (2006): Class and Victims
WHAT DO THEY SUGGEST?
- Marginalised groups are more likely to be victims.
Key Theorists – Newburn and Rock (2006): Class and Victims
WHAT DID THEY FIND WHEN THEY CONDUCTED A STUDY ON 300 HOMELESS PEOPLE?
- That they were twelve times more likely to have experienced violence than the general population. One in ten had been urinated on while sleeping rough.
Key Theorist - Miers (1989): Positivist Victimology
WHAT DO THEY ARGUE ARE THE THREE MAIN FEATURES OF POSITIVIST VICTIMOLOGY?
- It aims to identify the factors that produce patterns in victimisation – especially those that make some individuals or groups more likely to be victims.
- It focuses on interpersonal crimes of violence.
- It aims to identify victims who have contributed to their own victimisation.