Kettle Jalapeño's Eye Yeah Eye Review Flashcards
Tripartite Relationship
Simplest manner of explaining essence of a Project is between three diverse groups
The Owner and the Contractor sign the Contract for Construction (Agreement), the A/E is linked by the General Conditions (i.e A-201 or EDJDC C-700) but is not a party to the Construction Agreement.
AIA A201: Long History of Success
- First issued in 1888
- Well known and understood by A/Es, Contractors, and Insurers
- Basis for many Owner developed General Conditions
- Tested in the Courts
- 1915 to 1963, Architect had “general supervision and direction of the Work”.
- 1963, Architect makes “periodic site visits”
- 1965, Major reorganization, Project Manual emerges
- 1970, Architect no longer responsible to “stop the Work”
- AGC “endorsed” A201 until 2007
In the late 1900s other industry groups started to create their own.
Standard General Conditions by Professional Organizations
- This session is based on AIA (American Institute of Architects) Document A201-2007 and2017 General Conditions of the Contract for Construction
- Other standard general conditions by other professional organizations include the following
- EJCDC (Engineers Joint Contract Document Committee) Document C-700 Standard General Conditions of the Construction Contract
- AGC (Associated General Contractors of America) ConsensusDOCS Document 200 Agreement and General Conditions Between Owner and Contractor
- DBIA, (Design-Build Institute) Standard Form 535
Tripartite Relationship
The relationship among three parties:
- Owner-Architect Agreement
- Owner-Contractor Agreement
- Third party obligations
As Design-Bid-Build delivery remains the most prevalent in the industry, we focus on this arrangement.
The Owner and the Contractor sign the Contract for Construction
(Agreement); the A/E is linked by the General Conditions (i.e. A-201) but is not a party to the Construction Agreement.
However there are duties for all three parties defined in the General Conditions
Each party must know their duties and roles, “to play the game”.
Comparison of General Conditions (A201)+
- General Provisions
- Owner
- Contractor
- Architect
- Subcontractors
- Construction by Owner or by Separate Contractors
- Changes in the Work
- Time
- Payments and Completion
- Protection of Persons and Property
- Insurance and Bonds
- Uncovering and Correction of Work
- Miscellaneous Provisions
- Termination or Suspension of the Contract
- Claims and Disputes
Comparison of General Conditions (C-700)+
- Definitions and Terminology
- Preliminary Matters
- Contract Documents: …
- Availability of Lands; …
- Bonds and Insurance
- Contractor’s Responsibilities
- Other Work at the Site
- Owner’s Responsibilities
- Engineer’s Status During Construction
- Changes in the Work; Claims
- Cost of the Work;…
- Change of Contract Price and Time
- Tests and Inspections;…
- Payments and Completion
- Suspension and Termination
- Dispute Resolution
- Miscellaneous
Comparison of General Conditions (ConsensusDOCS 200)+
- Agreement
- General Provisions
- Contractor’s Responsibilities
- Owner’s Responsibilities
- Subcontracts
- Contract Time
- Contract Price
- Changes
- Payment
- Indemnity, Insurance, Waivers and Bonds
- Suspension, Cure, Termination
- Dispute Resolution
- Miscellaneous
- Contract Documents
General Conditions Comparison+
- AlA and EJCDC Documents
- Separate and supplemental to Agreement
- High page count AIA-39 and EJCDC-62
- Design professional is “visible” in the traditional 3 party contract
- AIA subscription / EJCDC download
- AGC ConsensusDOCS
- Low page count - 35, more concise
- Design professional is not mentioned as this contract is a true two party contract.
TOC for AIA A201-2017
- General Provisions
- Owner
- Contractor
- Architect
- Subcontractors
- Construction by Owner or by Separate Contractors
- Changes in the Work
- Time
- Payments and Completion
- Protection of Persons and Property
- Insurance and Bonds
- Uncovering and Correction of Work
- Miscellaneous Provisions
- Termination or Suspension of the Contract
- Claims and Disputes
Conditions of the Contract+
- Defines basic rights, responsibilities, and relationships of parties involved in performance of Contract
- Inherent part of Owner-Contractor Agreement
As an A/E you cannot recommend which General Conditions of the Contract for the Owner to use - Why not?
If the Owner wants to change the A201, issue ‘Supplemental Conditions to the Contract for Construction* - Why?
Conditions of the Contract - Division 00
- General Conditions: Broad clauses that typically apply to all projects.
These can be modified to suit specific requirements on individual projects.
- Supplementary Conditions: Used to make project-specific modifications to the General Conditions
- For example; Change the phrase, “requests for information about”, to, “requests for interpretation of”, in art. 4.2.14
- To add to or delete from the Architect’s Duties and Responsibilities as described in Article 4. (To coordinate with the Owner-Architect Agreement in cases where the Architect isn’t providing full contract administration service.)
- Define the purpose of a Bulletin.
Important Legal Issues
7.11
- Most professionals are required by law to have advanced education and training as well as be licensed by the State
- Professionals are expected to meet the “Professional Standard of Care”
- If professionals do not exercise the standard of reasonable care, they may be negligent
- Professionals are required to comply with codes, laws and regulations
Architect/engineers have unique knowledge and capabilities. Consequently, they are expected to practice in such a manner as to achieve a professional standard of care.
Spearin Doctrine
7.11.5 and 7.11.7
“Contractor is entitled to rely on the Construction Documents provided by the Owner to be sufficient for their intended purpose and is not responsible for the consequences of defects in the Contract Documents.”
Courts interpret construction documents according to the following rules:
- Autonomy to Contract
- Entire agreement
- Specific takes precedence over general
- Trade Customs
- Practical interpretation
- Construction against the drafter
Basic Definitions+
- The Contract Documents
- The Contract Documents
-
Enumerated in Owner-Contractor Agreement
- Agreement
- Conditions of the Contract
- Drawings
- Specifications
- Addenda
- Other documents listed
- Modifications
-
Modifications
- Written amendment
- Change Order
- Construction Change Directive
- Written order for a minor change
-
Enumerated in Owner-Contractor Agreement
Basic Definitions+
- The Contract Documents
- The Contract
- Agreement between the parties
- Not an agreement with certain other parties
- The Work
- Construction and services required by Contract Documents
- Labor, materials, equipment and services to fulfill Contractor’s obligations
- Whole or part of Project
Basic Definitions
- The Project
- The Project
- Total construction of which the Work may be the whole or a part
- May include construction by Owner and separate Contractors
Basic Definitions+
- The Drawings
- The Specifications
- Instruments of Service
- Initial Decision Maker
- The Drawings
- Graphic and pictorial portions of Contract Documents
- Shows design in its completed form, location and dimensions of Work
- The Specifications
- Written qualitative requirements for materials, equipment, systems, standards and workmanship for Work
-
Instruments of Service
- Representations of creative work by Architect and consultants
- Studies, surveys, models, sketches, drawings, specifications, the Building Information Model, and similar materials
-
Initial Decision Maker
- Person identified to render decisions on claims and terminations
- Commentary: Editions prior to 2007 did not use Initial Decision Maker
- Architect was the decision maker
Intent of Contract Documents+
- Contract Documents to include items necessary for execution and completion of Work by Contractor
- Contract Documents are complementary
- Spec sections do not limit the Contractor’s assignment of work among the Subcontractors
- Performance by Contractor required only to extent of Contract Documents and reasonably inferable to produce the indicated results
- No order of precedence in the documents
Ownership of Instruments of Service
- Architect and consultants deemed author and owners of respective instruments of service
- The Following are authorized to use instruments of service exclusively for execution of Work, but does not own or can claim a copyright
- Contractor
- Subcontractors
- Sub-subcontractors
- Material or equipment suppliers
Notice Given: Electronic communication
- Except for Notice of Claims, notice may be given “in writing” if delivered in person, by courier, by US Mail, or by electronic transmission
- Notice of Claims not allowed by electronic transmission.
- (New in 2017)
Digital Data
- The parties shall agree on protocols governing the digital transmission of the Instruments of Service.
- (New in 2017)
ARTICLE 2 OWNER
ARTICLE 2 OWNER
General
- Owner is a person or entity identified in Agreement
- Designated representative has express authority to bind Owner to matters requiring approval or authorization (This is NOT the Architect)
- If requested by Contractor, furnish statement of record legal title to property (site) for Contractor’s mechanic’s lien rights
Information and Services Required of the Owner
- If requested by Contractor, furnish reasonable evidence of financial arrangements to fulfill obligations
- Secure and pay for approvals, easements, assessments and charges (Contractor responsible for permits and fees designated by Contractor Documents)
- Furnish survey describing physical characteristics, legal limitations, utility locations, and legal description
- Furnish other information or services designated by Contractor Documents, (soils report, dwgs, specs)
- Retain an Architect licensed to practice where the Project is located.
- If the Architect is replaced, Owner shall not employ an Architect for whom the Contractor has reasonable objection.
- (Relocated in 2017 from Article 4)
Owner’s Right to Stop the Work ++
-
Can issue written order to Contractor to stop the Work if Contractor
- Fails to correct Work not in accordance with Contract Documents
- Repeatedly fails to carry out the Work in accordance with Contract Documents
- Owner has no duty to stop the Work for benefit of contractor or others
Commentary: Architect does not have authority to stop the Work.
Owner’s Right to Carry out the Work+
-
Can correct deficiencies in the Work if Contractor
- Defaults
- Neglects to carry out Work in accordance with Contract Documents
- Fails to commence and continue correction of such default or neglect
ARTICLE 3 CONTRACTOR
ARTICLE 3 CONTRACTOR
General
- Contractor is a person or entity identified in Agreement
- Designated representative has express authority to bind Contractor to matters under Contract
- Perform Work in accordance with Contract Documents
-
Not relieved of Contract obligations as a result of:
- Tests and inspections or approvals performed by others
- Architect’s administration of Contract
Review of Contract Documents and Field Conditions by Contractor+
- Execution of Contract represents Contractor
- Has visited site
- Become generally familiar with local conditions
- Correlated observations with Contract Documents
- Before starting Work, Contractor shall
- Study and compare various Contract Documents, but not required to find errors
- Take field measurements of existing conditions
- Observe any conditions at site affecting Work Conditions of
Supervision and Construction Procedures+
- Contractor shall supervise and direct Work using best skill and attention
- Solely responsible for, and have control over, following construction activities (even if Contract Documents include instructions for following activities, Contractor obligated to evaluate jobsite safety)
- Means
- Methods
- Techniques
- Sequences
- Procedures
- Coordination
Commentary: Means and Methods
- Contractors are now responsible for performing their own due diligence regarding the safety of construction means and methods dictated in the Contract Documents.
- “In the past, contractors could rely on the designer or architect’s direction stated in the Contract Documents. This addition protects the design team from legal action as safety associated with all means and method is now in the hands of the builder”.
Supervision and Construction Procedures
- Contractor responsible to Owner for acts and omissions of Contractor
- Contractor responsible for inspection of Work already performed for proper condition to receive subsequent Work
Labor and Materials
- Contractor provides and pays for following for proper execution and completion of the Work
- Labor
- Materials
- Equipment
- Tools
- Construction equipment
- Water
- Heat
- Utilities
- Transportation
- Other facilities and services
Labor and Materials+
- Contractor may make substitutions
- Only with consent of Owner
- After evaluation by Architect
- In accordance with
- Change Order
- Construction Change Directive
- Contractor shall
- Enforce strict discipline and good order among employees and persons carrying out Work
- Not employ unfit persons or persons not properly skilled
Warranty+
- Contractor warrants to Owner and Architect that materials and equipment furnished
- Will be of good quality and new
- Will conform to Contract Documents
- Will be free from defects
- Work not conforming to Contractor’s warranty may be considered defective
Commentary: Contractor does not warrant adequacy of Contract Documents *
Permits, Fees, Notices, and Compliance with Laws++
- Contractor shall secure and pay for
- Building permit
- Other permits
- Fees
- Licenses
- Inspections by government agencies
- If Contractor performs Work contrary to following, Contractor assumes responsibility and bears cost for correction
- Laws
- Codes
- Statutes
- Rules and regulations
- Ordinances
- Lawful orders of public authorities
Permits, Fees, Notices, and Compliance with Laws+
- Contractor to provide notice to Owner and Architect if following conditions encountered
- Subsurface or concealed differences that differ from Contract Documents
- Unknown physical conditions of an unusual nature that differ from those ordinarily found to exist
Contractor entitled to Change Order for unforeseen conditions.
Architect to investigate promptly & recommend adjustments to the
Contract if found to be valid
Allowances
- Costs included in Allowance
- Cost of material and equipment delivered to site
- Taxes, less trade discounts
- Costs included in Contract Sum
- Unloading and handling at site
- Labor
- Installation
- Overhead
- Profit
- Other expenses
- Cost differences adjusted by change order
(Allowances should not be confused with Bid Alternates)
Superintendent
- Contractor shall employ competent superintendent and assistants
- In attendance at Project site duringnperformance of Work
- That represents the Contractor
- Communications are binding as if given to Contractor
- Owner and Architect has no reasonable objection
- Cannot be changed without Owner’s consent
Contractor’s Construction Schedule and Submittal Schedules+
- Contractor shall submit construction schedule for the Work, (only for the Architect’s review)
- Shall not exceed Contract Documents time limits
- Revised at appropriate intervals
- Related to entire Project and extent required by Contract Documents
- Shall provide for expeditious and practicable execution of the Work
-
Contractor shall submit submittal schedule for approval
- Coordinated with construction schedule
- Allow Architect reasonable time to review, resubmittal, re-review and approval
Documents and Samples at the Site
- Contractor shall maintain following at Project site in good order and marked currently to indicated field changes and selections made during construction.
- Drawings
- Specifications
- Addenda
- Change orders
- Other modifications
- Shop drawings
- Product data
- Samples
- Similar required submittals
Shop Drawings, Product Data and Samples+
- Shop drawings (project specific), product data, (catalog info), samples and similar submittals are not Contract Documents
- Purpose is to demonstrate how Contractor proposes to conform with information given and design concept expressed in Contract Documents
- Submittals not required by Contract Documents, may be returned by Architect without action
Shop Drawings, Product Data and Samples+
- Contractor shall review submittals for compliance with Contract Documents, approve, and submit to Architect
-
By submitting submittals, Contractor represents to Owner and Architect that Contractor has
- Reviewed and approved them
- Determined and verified materials, field measurements and field construction criteria
- Has checked and coordinated submittal information with requirements of the Work and
- Contract Documents
- Contractor shall perform no Work until respective submittals have been approved by Architect
Shop Drawings, Product Data and Samples
- Work shall be in accordance with approved submittals and Contractor is not relieved from deviations from Contract Documents (or by Architect’s errors in submittal review).
- Contractor not required to provide licensed architectural or engineering services unless:
- Performance and design criteria specifically required by Contract Documents for portion of the Design-Build Work
- Unless necessary for means, methods, techniques, sequences and procedures, like shoring design
Delegated Design example: Roof trusses or pre-engineered building
Shop Drawings, Product Data and Samples
When Design-Build service is required:
- Architect must provide detailed design and performance criteria
- Contractor’s design-build service must be performed by licensed professionals
- Design-build design and shop drawings are reviewed and approved by the Contractor; not the Architect
- Architect’s review is limited to checking for conformance with the design- build criteria
- ( This process is sometimes referred to as “Delegated Design”)
- (Commentary: Provisions added in 2007)
Use of Site
- Contractor shall
- Confine operations to site and areas permitted by
- Laws
- Statutes
- Ordinances
- Codes
- Rules and regulations
- Lawful orders of public authorities
- Not unreasonably encumber site with materials or equipment
- Confine operations to site and areas permitted by
Cutting and Patching
- Contractor responsible for following and for restoring areas to condition existing prior to
- Cutting
- Fitting
- Patching
- Contractor shall not damage or endanger Work of the Owner separate Contractors
Critical for phrased work, or CM type work with multiple contractors
Cleaning Up
- Contractor shall keep premises free from accumulation of waste materials or rubbish
- At completion of Work, Contractor shall remove
- Waste materials
- Rubbish
- Contractor’s tools
- Construction equipment
- Machinery
- Surplus materials
- If Contractor fails to clean up, Owner may do so and be reimbursed by Contractor
Access to Work
- Contractor should provide Owner and Architect access to the Work in preparation and progress
Access required for testing agency or sub-consultants, or A/E staff.
Royalties, Patents and Copyrights++
- Contractor shall pay royalties and license fees
- Contractor shall defend suits or claims for infringement of copyrights and patent rights and hold Owner and Architect harmless from loss
- Contractor not responsible for such defense or loss when particular design, process or product of particular manufacturer is required by Contract Documents or where copyright violations are contained in the Contract Documents
Note disadvantage of single source type specifications
Indemnification+
- Contractor shall indemnify and hold harmless the following from claims, damages, losses and expenses from performance of the Work to the extent caused by negligent acts or omissions
- Owner
- Architect
- Architect’s consultant
ARTICLE 4 ARCHITECT
ARTICLE 4 ARCHITECT
General+
- Architect is a person or entity identified in Agreement
- Duties, responsibilities and limitations of authority of Architect as set forth in Contract Documents shall not be
- Restricted
- Modified
- Extended
- If Architect is terminated, Owner shall employ successor architect to whom Contractor has no reasonable objection (moved to 2.3.3 in 2017)
Administration of the Contract
- Architect will
- Provide administration of the Contract as described in Contract Documents until Final Certificate for Payment is issued
- Be Owner’s representative during construction
- Have authority to act on behalf of Owner to extent provided in Contract Documents
Administration of the Contract++
- Architect will visit site at intervals appropriate to stage of construction
- To become generally familiar with progress and quality of portion of Work completed
- To determine in general if Work observed is being performed in a manner, when completed, will be in accordance to Contract Documents
- Not required to make exhaustive or continuous on-site inspections to check quality or quantity of the Work
Administration of the Contract+
- Architect will not have control over, charge of, or responsibility for, construction
- Means
- Methods
- Techniques
- Sequences
- Procedures
- Safety precautions and programs
These are specifically the Contractor’s responsibility.
Administration of the Contract+
-
Architect will keep Owner reasonably informed about progress and quality of Work completed
- Known deviations from Contract Documents and construction schedule
- Defects and deficiencies observed in the Work
- Architect not responsible for Contractor’s failure to perform Work in accordance with Contract Documents
Administration of the Contract
- Architect will have no control over and will not be responsible for acts and omissions of
- Contractor
- Subcontractors
- Agents or employees
- Other persons or entities performing Work