Jury Trial Flashcards
Jury Trial - As right/waiver
In fed court any part can demand it affirmatively
- if not: deemed waived and case by “bench trial”
- if granted: receives “docket designation”
DEMAND: SERVED + FILED withi 14 days since service of last pleading
Jury Trial - Judge/Jury duties
- Jury: decides Q of fact: i.e. dx, breach of contract, tort
- Judge:
1) Decides Q of law: i.e. admissibility of E, N claims, equitable actions like specific performance or injunctive relief
2) Discretion to decide on “predominant nature” of case (law or fact) - If both present court allows jury to decide first issue of fact
Jury Trial - Process (Steps)
1) Jury selection
2) Jury Instruction
3) Counsel closing arguments
4) Jury deliberation
5) Verdict
Jury Trial - Jury selection aka “voir dire” - Gral
- Both counsel can interview and select juror
- Pool of juror has to be fair cross-section of community
Jury Trial - Jury selection - Challenges Types (2)
1) Peremptory
2) For cause
Jury Trial - Jury selection - Peremptory Challenge - Gral
- “No reason”
- In civil causes only 3-per side
Jury Trial - Jury selection - Peremptory Challenge - C restrictions
Peremptory challenge not solely based on:
- Race - Gender
Jury Trial - Jury selection - “For cause” Challenge - LIB causes
1) Lack of qualification (18 y/o, convicted felon, not US citizen, inhabiility to communicate in English)
2) Incapacity - unsound of body and mind
3) Bias
Jury Trial - Jury selection - “For cause” Challenge - LIB - Lack of qualification (4)
- >18y/o
- Not US citizen
- Can not communicate in english
- Convicted felon
Jury Trial - Jury selection - “For cause” Challenge - LIB - Bias
- actual or implied
- i.e. juror related /employed by party, answer show clear impartiality
Jury Trial - Jury Instructions - gral
- Formal instructions by judge to jury before deliberation
- Orally or in writing
Jury Trial - Jury Instructions - Content to reflect applicable law and give space to juror to argue own theory (4)
1) Role of judge
2) Burden of proof
3) Required elements for the cause of action and D’s asserted defenses
4) Special instructions for this case
Jury Trial - Jury Instructions -Timing
- After all trial E presented - Counsel allowed to meet w/judge to decide on language
Jury Trial - Jury Instructions - Party objection to content
- On the record and at earliest opportunity
- Object to content or rejection to give instruction
Jury Trial - Counsel Closing Arguments
- Each party addresses jury
- Party w/burden of proof opens and close
- Refer only to E presented on trial
- NO personal opinion or comment on insurance
Jury Trial - Jury Deliberation
- In private
- Consider only E to be presented in trial
- Not conduct own investigation or research
- Not discuss w/anyone outside until verdict
Jury Trial - Verdict - gral
- At least 6 jurors must participate
- Decision has to be unanimous unless party agree otherwise
- Presiding juror reads out loud
- Post verdict parties can poll the jurors
Jury Trial - Verdict - “Special Verdict”
Verdict as answer to specific questions posted by judge
Jury Trial - Verdict - Effect of “hung jury”
- When no unanimous verdict
- Possible mistrial
Jury Trial - Jury Misconduct - Effects
Potentially can “set aside” judgment because of mistrial
- Mistrial is declared for some cases (improper action, clerical error)
- not usually for other cases (improper reasoning or thought process, life experiences, bias/prejudice)
Jury Trial - Jury Misconduct - Grounds (5)
1) Improper actions
2) Improper reasoning or thought process
3) Life experiences
4) Bias/prejudice
5) Clerical error
Jury Trial - Jury Misconduct - Improper actions- Considerations by court
- Court will set aside by motion considering Severity of actions and degree of prejudice to losing party
- i.e.: discuss w/other before verdict, independent research, reach verdict by luck (flip coin)
Jury Trial - Jury Misconduct - Improper reasoning or thought process
- usually not set aside by court
- i.e. fail to follow jury instructions, fail to understand or consider E, give too much/little weight to E, calculation of DX
Jury Trial - Jury Misconduct - Life Experiences
- jurors can share btwen them
- Court will usually not set aside
Jury Trial - Jury Misconduct - Bias or Prejudice
- Usually court will not set aside - notion that voir dire deal with this type of risk
- EXCEPTIONALLY set aside w_hen bias concealed during jury selection_ but later expressed