IPR Flashcards
An invention is:
A technical solution to a technical problem.
Novel combination of ideas, often based on discovery, but cannot be a discovery.
What makes an invention patentable?
1) Novelty - It must be new
2) Inventive step - The invention must not be obvious for a person skilled in the art. “Non-obvious” in US patent language,
3) Industrial application
4) Proper enablement/sufficient disclosure - Such as a person skilled in the art can reproduce the invention without problem solving
5) It must not be excluded from patenting
Who is the inventor?
The one who got the idea (you can have multiple inventors, but in the US, you will be asked to define who came up with what part of the invention). But you can co-develop something if you iterate.
What can invalidate a patent in the US?
If there are to many or to few on a patent application. Too many and the patent can be invalidated (5-7 people are waaaay to much).
When filing a patent, when does the potential granted patent count from?
The filling date!
So you don’t always have 20 years….
What is novelty?
“Is it identical? Yes or no.” – Don’t complicate it more than that.
What is excluded from patenting?
Art. 6:
Inventions shall be considered unpatentable where their commercial exploitation would be contrary to ordre public or morality; the following, in particular, shall be considered
unpatentable:
(a) processes for cloning human beings;
(b) processes for modifying the germ line genetic identity of human beings;
(c) uses of human embryos for industrial or commercial purposes;
(d) processes for modifying the genetic identity of animals which are likely to cause them suffering without any substantial medical benefit to man or animal, and also animals resulting from such processes
How do you destroy global novelty?
- Any form of public communication! If someone not attached to the project could find the information if they wanted without special agreement or purpose.
- Also displays of the invention if you can figure out the inner workings from the display. It’s not a disclosure if you only show the outcome for example.
What is prior art?
Prior art is documentation that shows that a patent idea has already had public access. Can be anything from class books to research papers to even comic books and cartoons.
Large companies and investors will often not sign CDAs and NDAs because?
They are afraid of cross-contamination, they could already know this information, and now have to prove it. OR you can work in a big company and don’t know what other departments are doing, and are writing off rights for the company, now you have to show that you had the information already.
What is a patent claim?
A full sentence describing the claim.
If you improve on technology with a patent, what should you do?
1) File for patent on your new improved product.
2) Ask for licensing of the old technology or try to show prior art to destroy IP.
3) Maybe do cross-licensing, so you both get access to the needed IP.
What should you try to do when filing a patent?
Always file for the essential working mechanisms, so that if there are iterations, you will always have to be licensed.
Wildcards in Derwent
• 0-1 characters: $
• 1 character: ?
• 0 to many characters: *
Why patent - philosophically?
The capitalistic thought of private property transferred to “intangibilities”.
- Meaning we can start trading them and start using them in a market aspect.
- Is like a house, car, bike you name it. Physical property. You can trade them, you can “rent” out your house/patent etc.
Why is the US patent market changing?
New legislation said that nature-derived compounds/genes etc. cannot be patented. This means that fewer patents are filled and more confidential cooperation is done.
- Great example of why patents are important.
Why patent from a market perspective? What can a patent do?
A right for the patentee to prohibit others from exploiting the patented invention. It’s a negative right (you can prohibit others) - it does however not necessarily mean that you can produce it yourself.
Can you always produce your patent?
You cannot necessarily exploit the field/product you patented. You can patent human cloning, but you cannot do this. You can patent a car that goes 1000mph, but you can’t necessarily sell it in DK.
Why patent in a financial perspective?
Patents protect investments in research and development (R&D). Makes it possible to do basic business development (market sizing, profitability calculations etc.).
- BECAUSE – you can exploit and copy unpatented products or technology according to law. (You can’t make an EXACT copy, but you can always just change a corner or something small, and then it’s good. – Get a patent on the concept!)
Ecosystem in life science?
Big companies often just buy smaller companies for their IP. Are often dependent on this faster development from smaller companies.
The effect of a patent:
Prohibits the commercial processes of:
1) Using your technology/products
2) Producing your technology/product
3) Selling your product/technology
4) Importing your technology/product (to countries where you have the patent)
5) Offering your technology/product for sale
Being in possession of your technology/product with the objective of doing any of the above
What is Contributory infringement?
1) Selling or offering machines that can produce your product
2) Selling or offering materials which are especially suited for the manufacturing of your products when the seller knows that the buyer will produce your product from the materials.
3) Selling or offering ordinary materials which are not especially suited for the manufacturing of your product if the seller encourages the buyer to produce your product from the material.
Can you use patented technologies for R&D?
Yes! R&D is permitted to use previous patents – especially for academic research.
What happens if you’ve been doing a process for 10 years as a trade secret that somebody then files a patent on?
You can keep using your process if you can prove that you have used it (in secret) before the patent.
What convention started IPR?
The Paris convention started patents. If you file in one of the member countries of the convention, you have 12 months to file the exact same patent application in all the other countries, that has the same application date.
- STILL enforced! You have 12 months to file your patent application.
- OBS. Often the countries have different formats, but the texts etc has to be the same!
A basic timeline looks like?
Priority application (first filing of your application) – Day 0
(Paris convention kicking in here)
PCT (Patent Corporation Treaty) application – Month 12
Publication (if no previous patents overlap) - Month 18 (or later) – Always 18 months after first filing.
IPR report - Month 28
Need to file a national application or it dies - Month 30/31 (varies in countries)
(You need to file in all the countries you want a patent. You can’t do this again, because it is not novel anymore).
National patent application phase starts - 1-10 years (ish…. – it varies)
MEANING – we have a black box for 18 months where we don’t know what and who has filed a patent.
What is an IPR report?
A report done by the authorities on your patent applications novelty, inventive step and industrial application etc.
A basic timeline looks like?
Priority application (first filing of your application) – Day 0
(Paris convention kicking in here)
PCT (Patent Corporation Treaty) application – Month 12
Search result showing novelty – Month 16
Publication of the patent application (if no previous patents overlap) - Month 18 (or later) – Always 18 months after first filing.
IPR report - Month 28
Need to file a national application or it dies - Month 30/31 (varies in countries)
(You need to file in all the countries you want a patent. You can’t do this again, because it is not novel anymore).
National patent application phase starts - 1-10 years (ish…. – it varies)
MEANING – we have a black box for 18 months where we don’t know what and who has filed a patent.
What is the PCT?
PCT (Patent Corporation Treaty) – by World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO).
Makes it possible to file a patent application that is the same as filling in all the member states/countries (around 170 states). – Around 35.000DKK.
Does the priority application have to be alive when you file a PCT application?
No, you just need a number, date and a text, it doesn’t have to be live.
How do you apply for a patent in EU?
See basic timeline at/before month 30/31 – you apply for a European patent. After granting in Europe, you have to say which countries you want the grant in. THEN, the 9 month opposition period starts.
How do you apply for a patent in EU?
See basic timeline at/before month 30/31 – you apply for a European patent. After granting in Europe, you have to say which countries you want the grant in.
What is post-grant opposition?
A competitor can oppose to the grant saying there is a problem with sufficient novelty, inventive step, disclosure etc.
What is post-grant opposition?
A competitor can oppose to the grant saying there is a problem with sufficient novelty, inventive step, disclosure etc. 9 months in Europe.
What three outcomes can come from the post-grant opposition if somebody opposed the grant?
Limited, full or destroyed patent.
Why is the post-grant opposition period smart for competitors?
You can annoy the patent-filer on a European level for cheap. After patent, you have to challenge the patent in each country.
What language does the Europe patent application be in?
The major EU languages which are English, German or French
When can you prohibit somebody from using your patented technology for commercial purposes?
When the patent is granted. In the meantime, people can actually utilize your technology.
Do we truly have a 20 year patent lifespan?
No, the 20 years are from your PCT application, so if you utilize your entire 12 month from priority application to PCT, you will have 21 years.
What should the priority application be?
Broad, but specific enough to protect it, to make sure that it covers all the specific sub-patents your want in the further application process.
What “shape” do patent applications often have?
A reverse pyramid shape. Start broad and narrow it down. “Screw” – “Made of iron” – “Can have a circular head” – “10 mm” etc.