Investment Appraisal Flashcards
How do you calculate ROCE?
Average annual profit before interest and tax / initial capital costs x100%
What are the strengths of ROCE?
Expressed in terms familiar to managers - profit and capital employed
Easy to calculate the likely affect of a project on the profit and loss account / balance sheet
Managers are frequently rewarded in relation to performance against the variables
Business is judged by ROI by financial markets
What are the limitations of ROCE?
Does not ensure shareholder wealth maximisation
Figures are easily manipulated
Ignores the actual/incremental cash flows associated with the project
A project involves the immediate purchase of an item of plant costing $50,000.
Annual cash flows of $14,500 will be earned and the plant will be sold at the end of the four-year project life for $10,000.
Calculate the project’s ROCE using:
(a) Initial capital costs
(b) Average capital investment.
Average annual profit is used in both calculations:
(Total annual cash flows – total depreciation)/project life ($14,500 × 4 – ($50,000 – $10,000)/4 = $4,500 per annum
(a) Initial capital ROCE = $4,500/$50,000 × 100 = 9%
For average ROCE, need average capital investment: ($50,000 + $10,000)/2 = $30,000
(b) Average ROCE = $4,500/$30,000 × 100 = 15%
What if the target return were 12%? Would the project be accepted?
You would need to know whether the target related to the initial or average method.
Why is it more important to evaluate future cash flows rather than accounting profits in capital investment appraisal?
profits cannot be spent profits are subjective cash is required to pay dividends. Major differences between profit and cash flows will relate to: asset purchase and depreciation changes in working capital deferred taxation capitalisation of research and development expenditure.
What do relevant cash flows ignore?
Sunk costs
Committed costs
Depreciation
Interest and dividend payments
what do relevant cash flows include?
Opportunity costs
Value of best missed opportunity
How do you calculate the pay back period?
Initial investment / annual cash flow
If cash flows are uneven then use cumulative cash flow over the life of the investment
What are the strengths of the payback method?
Easy to calculate and understand
Can be used in first stage screening to eliminate inappropriate projects
Bias in favour of short-term projects which tends to minimise business and financial risk
Can be used when there is capital rationing to identify the projects that generate additional has for investment quickly
What are the limitations of the pay back method?
Does not ensure shareholder wealth maximisation
Ignores the timings of cashflows in the project and the cash flows after the payback period and therefore total project return
Ignores the time value of money
Unable to distinguish between projects that have the same payback period
Tends to favour short-term projects
Takes account of the risk of timing cash flows but not the variability of cash flows
An expenditure of $2 million is expected to generate net cash inflows of $600,000 each year for the next seven years.
What is the payback period?
$2,000,000/600,000 = 3.33 years.
Or 3 years + 0.33*12 months
3 years and 4 months.
What is the time value of money?
Money received today is worth more than the same sum received in the future because:
Potential to earn interest
Impact of inflation
Effects of risk
What is compounding?
Calculates the future value of a sum of money
How do you calculate the compounding value?
F=P(1+r)^n
F=future value after n periods
P=present of initial value
r=rate of interest per period
^n=number of periods
What is discounting cash flows?
Conversion of future cash flows to their present value
How do you calculate the discounted cash flow?
P= F/(1+r)^n
(1+r)^-n is the discount factor
F = cash flow
What is NPV?
All future cash flows are discounted to their present value and added together.
What does a positive NPV indicate?
Project should be accepted
What does a negative NPV indicate?
Project should be rejected
What are the advantages of NPV?
Considers the time value of money
It is an absolute measure of return
Based on cash flows and not profit
Should lead to shareholder wealth maximisation
Higher discounts can be sued for riskier projects
What are the disadvantages of NPV?
Not easily explained to managers
Requires the cost of capital to be known